Did I throw game?

Memojiabout 8 years ago

Guys,

I'd like to bring out this game and collect your opinions with the subject perspective.

Please help me review this game, with turn on the vote log & time span https://epicmafia.com/game/6673648/review

Downvote if you think I did throw game

Upvote if you think I did not.

Leave comment if you have any opinions.

Long story short: I got a GT vio for this game and mod suspend my trophy.

Mori sent private message to various mods and blacksnakemoan report and self vio it https://epicmafia.com/report/253996

Then I appealed the report: https://epicmafia.com/report/254000

The relate report here: https://epicmafia.com/report/254002

GrannyPixel was blacksmith in this game, who admits this is not a GT. She was in game so she knows what exactly happened.

The final result from mod team is Sustained.

Mori sent PM to mods with her opinion that I used Phoenixi as a GT acc to make her lose while she was #20 and Memoji was about #6

In statistic of Mori:

Here is the proof about my screen buggy

With MisterPresident's spamming votes and drop-line vote due to long name, I mishammerred on hooker

I need to hear more opinions. Thanks,

Phoenixo – Memoji

Arrogateabout 8 years ago
Since you wanted me to look at this I did, I know my opinion means nothing, but whatever, I have free time.

Ok, I was looking at that, why did you hammer your hooker, aka the one you innoed as cop that game?
I mean reading though, I don't really think there was any intent to throw, sheriff shot day 1, why would bs want to vest him there? and that's what cost you the game, that vest. I mean by hammering hooker, that pretty much "cleared you" in the eyes of most people. Like, you were actually trying to play all 4 days, and well day 5 you ended up being confirmed maf. So my verdict? No vio. You had the 1 guy vote spamming, and a sheriff randomly hipfiring day 1. Like if maf had won, people would've reported the sheriff for the hipfire, and it possibly would've been refunded.
1
Firdabout 8 years ago
no offense but mori is just a fckin rat, she played terribly the whole game and had the guts to report the one who was solo carrying his team for misclicking
deleteddeletedabout 8 years ago
just recommended ally and bsm for cia jobs. you'll be contacted shortly by kevin hart for your top level investigations here.
1
Shoopieabout 8 years agoedited
Again wouldn't even be a debate is MisterPrezzy didn't break a rule and vote spam in the first place :P
2
PatrykSzczescieabout 8 years ago
Alright, I didn't read the related report because I thought it was a kind of a duplicate. Now, I have.

Memoji said another player in the report. This doesn't determine his intention to GT there. As you see, you also mistook a name, as for Memoji those 2 people are not known to him and the only thing he knew was that he intended to hammer town.

If you assume that I would lie, you better have some grounds for suspicion, at least.
1
JeffreyAaronabout 8 years ago
Lmfao
denialabout 8 years ago
PatrykSzczescie
I am in consent with two first posters.

Phoenixi doesn't deserve a vio.

Mori doesn't deserve to be sanctioned.

I can't find posts relating to Mori's claim that Phoenixi had 3 different excuses relating this hammer. I only see that Phoenixi intended to hammer the sheriff.

Memoji, mods don't have any tools that help them see more information in games than a normal player does.

I find it hilarious that mods use a single post between spam-voting and hammering as a reason for the vio. Voting logs have no timestamps and the post required only hitting Enter.

It's disgusting that mods unpaused the round and let it end like this.
probably because you get the luxury of getting to half- it since your opinions largely not going to matter in the determination of the outcome

go read the comments if you want to find out where/why mori said he had 3 different responses

one was in game, one was in another game and then in the report itself (when he included a screenshot), he said he tried to vote baller(sheriff) and townread (cop) and then he mistakenly voted (iamblah) hooker

also, determination of how long a pause there was between mrpresident voting, and phoenixi hammering was not solely made because of mori's recollection of the event nor the 'one message' because relying on either of those as a would be really troubling

also, not sure why you think we'd keep the round paused solely for this event when discussion has already been ongoing for several days and the decision was made

anyways his reasoning for hammering hooker was shoddy and imo it doesn't justify/explain why he made the hammer given how the game played out

if you messed up and decided to lie about it in a way that might make sense, thats probably a mistake to do
Takiabout 8 years ago
blacksnakemoan
shh he might try say he was using a phone now
*lag
SteelixMegaabout 8 years ago
i threw game
blacksnakemoanabout 8 years ago
shh he might try say he was using a phone now
bewilderedabout 8 years ago
The claim that someone in game said there was a pause means nothing as vote spamming can mess up someones client if it's bad. i.e. using a phone
1
PatrykSzczescieabout 8 years ago
I am in consent with two first posters.

Phoenixi doesn't deserve a vio.

Mori doesn't deserve to be sanctioned.

I can't find posts relating to Mori's claim that Phoenixi had 3 different excuses relating this hammer. I only see that Phoenixi intended to hammer the sheriff.

Memoji, mods don't have any tools that help them see more information in games than a normal player does.

I find it hilarious that mods use a single post between spam-voting and hammering as a reason for the vio. Voting logs have no timestamps and the post required only hitting Enter.

It's disgusting that mods unpaused the round and let it end like this.
3
Perishabout 8 years ago
tldr he threw game
jimmasterabout 8 years ago
tldr?
deleteddeletedabout 8 years ago
Literally every time im about to comment on a report due to its CorrUPT anD BIASEd anD StRonGLY MOD ABUSIVE nAture i see that blacksnamkemoan is the one who filed the report??? How about you get over your obsession with me bsm honestly.
10
blacksnakemoanabout 8 years ago
JeffreyAaron
BSM: don’t talk about me or it’s harassment
Me: doesn’t talk about him
BSM: JEFF IS PATHOLOGICAL LIAR BTW ROFL


??????
Literally every time i report someone you comment on it.

How about you get over your creepy little obsession with me cùnt
4
Perishabout 8 years ago
Gerry
Nat come back to MafiaScum.
honestly i just dont have the energy for that kinda game anymore. sorry.
2
JeffreyAaronabout 8 years ago
Get a life dude and for the love of God please stop mentioning me you’re being creepy
JeffreyAaronabout 8 years ago
BSM: don’t talk about me or it’s harassment
Me: doesn’t talk about him
BSM: JEFF IS PATHOLOGICAL LIAR BTW ROFL


??????
groundhogdayabout 8 years ago
blacksnakemoan
unrelated, holy i just linked a picture and it was of phoenixo's pie but instead it showed some creepy dude

that's really crazy
blacksnakemoanabout 8 years agoedited
unrelated, holy i just linked a picture and it was of phoenixo's pie but instead it showed some creepy dude

blacksnakemoanabout 8 years agoedited
are we looking at different phoenixo accounts

seven mods looked at your vio.

24 people didn't know you had a 2nd vio for GTing, and probably didn't know you lynched your own hooker when it was mafia autowin
Gerryabout 8 years ago
Nat come back to MafiaScum.
1
Memojiabout 8 years ago
FYI:
I didn't have any vio report since I was Phoenixo

Memojiabout 8 years ago
Real questions here

1. How many mod in the mod team who investigate the comp game and judge the competitors, such as my case?

2. Which tools, technique that mods use to replay the games before you give a report into vio?
I'd like to know if you use the high-tech solution for that review.

If the way you review the games same as other players use, I don't think you have a better judgement than us.


Let's review the vote result from various players:

24 upvotes vs 8 downvotes

Not including people commented it is not a vio.