Back to Epicmafia

Did I throw game?

Memoji
over 6 years

Guys,

I'd like to bring out this game and collect your opinions with the subject perspective.

Please help me review this game, with turn on the vote log & time span https://epicmafia.com/game/6673648/review

Downvote if you think I did throw game

Upvote if you think I did not.

Leave comment if you have any opinions.

Long story short: I got a GT vio for this game and mod suspend my trophy.

Mori sent private message to various mods and blacksnakemoan report and self vio it https://epicmafia.com/report/253996

Then I appealed the report: https://epicmafia.com/report/254000

The relate report here: https://epicmafia.com/report/254002

GrannyPixel was blacksmith in this game, who admits this is not a GT. She was in game so she knows what exactly happened.

The final result from mod team is Sustained.

Mori sent PM to mods with her opinion that I used Phoenixi as a GT acc to make her lose while she was #20 and Memoji was about #6

In statistic of Mori:

Here is the proof about my screen buggy

With MisterPresident's spamming votes and drop-line vote due to long name, I mishammerred on hooker

I need to hear more opinions. Thanks,

Phoenixo – Memoji

Mori
over 6 years

Mile says

Mori should be the one to be disqualified for conspiring to get her competition out.

I have always liked Mori but this is despicable behavior IMO.


Dude, what competition?? I trophied regardless, I didn't know he had a previous violation, how is that my fault? If he didn't have a previous violation he wouldn't be round suspended.

Also it was maf autowin and MisterPresident's final vote was up for several seconds before he went and hammered someone else, and changed his excuse for it three times.
Memoji
over 6 years


I managed to vote sheriff – Baller or cop – Townread
Iamcoolguy
over 6 years
oh yeah i remember this
deletedover 6 years
Phoe left a server i was in cos we were talking about an unranked game.

phoe cheating......mods give ya heads a wobble
Memoji
over 6 years
I got a GT vio from a banned user - MrNice, aka ABC

https://epicmafia.com/report/253532

Mod vio me even thought he admitted he join game for throwing.

https://epicmafia.com/game/6665456

After that, he got 8 vio reports and was banned again:
https://epicmafia.com/report/254032
Taki
over 6 years
Agreed with the first two comments. I'm not going to point fingers, but this was probably the mod's line of thought: He would have won if he had blitz'd town and the game would have been over. But as Dawdle and Memoji has brought up, it's quite possible he had some issue with his screen.

Even if that wasn't believable to whoever was moderating the report he still played based off of his wincon. It wasn't like he was intentionally throwing from what I'm seeing as Mile brings up. He made a very clear attempt of remedying his accident until the end. "Gamethrowing, by its most basic and all-encompassing definition, is knowingly playing against your win-condition." He had no malicious intent of deliberately losing as shown in the last day.

I wouldn't call this modabuse as the mod was looking at this from one angle. But I do think this should be brought up to attention.
deletedover 6 years
Mori should be the one to be disqualified for conspiring to get her competition out.

I have always liked Mori but this is despicable behavior IMO.
Volta
over 6 years
Didn't even read, just don't want Pikachu to win a trophy.
Shoopie
over 6 years
Well personally, I think it's MisterPresident's fault for vote spamming in the first place. You were pushing on voting Mori before claiming they were hooker in order to protect yours so iunno... Seems intentions to win were there.
Edark
over 6 years
how did u even get a vio for this lol
Memoji
over 6 years
Updated. Sorry.
deletedover 6 years
wrong screenshot, Memoji lol
Memoji
over 6 years
Mori sent PM to mods with her opinion that I used Phoenixi as a GT acc to make her lose while she was #20 and Memoji was about #6


In statistic of Mori:


Here is the proof about my screen buggy

With MisterPresident's spamming votes and drop-line vote due to long name, I mishammerred on hooker
Memoji
over 6 years

Shoopie says

Has it been appealed yet? I would appeal.

I agree that you don't deserve a violation for this.



I appealed and got "sustained"
https://epicmafia.com/report/254000
deletedover 6 years
Shoopie, it was appealed and sustained TWICE

https://epicmafia.com/report/254000
https://epicmafia.com/report/254002
Shoopie
over 6 years
Has it been appealed yet? I would appeal.

I agree that you don't deserve a violation for this.
bewildered
over 6 years
No, I believe you just forgot about the vest after being to invested into the game. You did try your best to win and you did actually just make a mistake, you do not deserve a GT violation for this. Even with one more win, Mori would still be second place.
CommanderZenith
over 6 years
Yeah I'm not sure why this received a GT vio. It definitely wasn't an intended vote and you were also very clearly playing to win (which you almost managed to do).
deletedover 6 years
Harkinian's point is exactly right. There was clearly NO intent to lose WHATSOEVER. He ccd cop and even won the cop cc, which should be proof enough. You could even argue that hammering hooker there could be a strategic play. Absolutely ridiculous vio.
Dawdle
over 6 years
MisterPresident was votespamming which would have caused the vote menu to kick around, that right there is evidence Phoenixi hadn't intentionally killed his own comrade.
Harkinian
over 6 years
Doesn't look like you played with the intent to lose so I wouldn't call it a throw, I don't think there's too many players about who can honestly say they've never misclicked before in their lives.