the logan version of widow is cool and not op. lynching the widow wouldnt let doctor protect and mafia would get pr. the only part i disagree is the mafia sided thing, i think it should be town and punish village if ever lynched (just like lk, leader, secretary...)

Ok, maybe the delay wasn't a good idea

Postman
-Ships a package containing a random item to a player each night
-Sided with the village

Sweet and simple

I don't know if this was the plan already, but if the town can't win while the sidekick is alive, it'd be possible to make mafialess games with third party factions other than killer/werewolf, which would be cool.

The sidekick should be able to win when dead. If not, it can impossibly truly team up with the third parties. Imagine how awkward a meeting between a werewolf and a sidekick would be if the werewolf only needs immunity for the next day to win the game.

Sidekick needing to be alive when the third party wins doesn't really make sense from flavour perspective either.

We're playing with penguins and tree stumps. Butterfly is the next logical step.

admin says

only complaint is Butterfly's name is too weird

Penguin isnt a weird role name??

only complaint is Butterfly's name is too weird

just read through each role in more detail. keep revising the roles. may be a good chance i'll build all of them!

petition to rename gambler to kenny rogers

Even if Donor isn't voted the most it should still be made for the Main Lobby, since it would be the perfect role for it, and the coding would be simple as for it.

cool i like it

admin says

which versino of gambler?

revision

https://epicmafia.com/role/12618

I prefer the 3rd party one: (from pastebin link):

Gambler (revision)
- Each day, picks a player to gamble at night
- Both players will pick rock, paper, or scissors in separate meetings
- The loser dies the next day unless there is a tie
- Wins after 2 successful gambits
- Third party

Its more of a random role so in my opinion works better as a 3rd.

which versino of gambler?

Gun revealer and revealer are the same.

Don was a mistake

I still don't know why Don surpassed those roles ...

hint how to win as gambler:

1. pick the most SJW person or a person you suspect as mafia/evil role

2. choose paper

thank me later

How about this role :
- Duck
- Sided with town, no visit
- Each night ( each morning) receives a random report from a random investigating role in game. The report could be on everyone, and it can be det/cop/tracker/watcher/priest/santa ... report, or can be forger/actress/jan/gramp report. Or it can be "you are poisoned" or "you receieved a suit" report. If there is no role that can get report in your game or you are roleblocked, you get no report.
- The report looks so real that jour may think that you're actually a det/ stalker
- If you are visited that night, the report is 100% legit (true). If no one visits you, the report is 50% legit, aka duck report.

tldr: Duck is a blue that become a role in game that get report on random person each night. The report can be fake or true.

moonlightseal says

Dueslist is a less interesting Gambler

buddy, shooting people is always interesting

gambler and monkey sound fun, duelist for specific setups too, widow revision is just a bad strongman, and honestly who wants delayed item giving

Why isn't horse on this list?

Dueslist is a less interesting Gambler

hey admin this role:

√ Bard
√ sided with the village
√ each night can choose to sing a story to the town on the following day
√ the story will have four sentences, each talking about a player in the game
√ only one sentence in that story is true

broke upvote barriers so i guess youre making it?

handyman seems like a great role all around