With recent threads regarding under/overrated players as well as the best players on EpicMafia, I thought it would be an interesting idea to have most active players be classified in a tier-list, based on their overall in-game skills.
I plan on ranking well-known players, but I might forget a few people! If you'd like to be included in my list or would like a more detailed explanation on my opinion, feel free to comment.
Tier list I will be using
TOP: The best of the best. Proficient in all roles and great as either alignment. Highly knowledgeable, does not make many mistakes, and capable of thinking fast.
GREAT: Competent as either alignment, might be better at one over the other, but skilled at both. Confident players who really know how to use logic and other persuasion tactics to help their team to victory.
GOOD: Highly competent at just one alignment or decently capable at both. May struggle with a certain aspect of the game (scumhunting, persuasion, towntelling, etc.), but still better than most.
ABOVE AVERAGE: Players who are typically well-rounded, but not particularly outstanding in anything. They might lack the confidence or knowledge of the players above them.
AVERAGE: Your average mafia player. Might make good reads sometimes and may not be the most obvious mafia, but are unable to apply these skills consistently or naturally. Usually, they have a lot of room for potential.
BELOW AVERAGE: Players that are only really good at doing one thing. Their alignments are transparent and oftentimes they don't help or hinder the game. You've probably played with them a thousand times but can't remember a single notable play they've made.
TRASH: The worst of the worst. They unintentionally make the game harder than it needs to be for everyone involved. Lack of knowledge, are often incapable of seeing what they've done wrong, and are easily influenced.
MEME: Players who intentionally make the game harder than it needs to be. These are the power trippers who force everyone to play in suboptimal ways while lacking the skill to reap the benefits from it.
