Back to Epicmafia

Official Sandbox Setup - Remastered

Bebop
over 7 years

Hey everyone, I've been saying I would do this for the last few days and it's finally here. An update to the classic Sandbox closed-roles setup that everyone loves! The twist is, that the community can voice their opinions on what should and shouldn't be in it! I have made a shortlist of roles, seperating them into categories of Yes, No, and Maybe. Roles in the Yes category will be going in the setup, No roles obviously will not be going in the setup, and Maybe roles are up for debate whether or not they are in the official setup or not. Of course, if you see a role in Yes or No that you believe belongs elsewhere, you're absolutely welcome to voice that opinion also and it will be taken into consideration.

Without further ado, here are the roles sorted into their categories:

Please use this thread to discuss what should be added and what shouldn't. Primarily discuss the Maybe roles, but if there are discrepancies in the Yes and No categories, please voice them here too.

Bebop
over 7 years
>play mafia with a friend
>you roll filibuster, they roll townsided role
>for epic lulz they always NL/vote against the filibuster
>entire town thrown into autoloss

whilst sandbox is a fun fun lobby, i think this'd get pretty old and irritating fast, although if people want it that's fine with me
deletedover 7 years
In defense of Maybe

-Huntsman is a check in power to Hunter and should be included. So many huntsman gets lynched D1 and it's extremely satisfying.

-Trickster and Cthulhu are both chaotic fun roles

-Nomad is a survivor but cooler but as I posted on bug reports it's glitched
baabaa
over 7 years
Add creepygirl pls
Shwartz99
over 7 years
Filibuster is too mafsided
deletedover 7 years
Telepath and Whisperer are the same so they shouldn't be in different categories.

Admirer turns into Killer with no Killer so no point in excluding it. Go murder

Filibuster is a weak role I'll concede but in it's defense it relies on town to not be stupid, which is something that is rare for a Mafia game
Bebop
over 7 years

Shwartz99 says


Bebop says

agent and spy are in maybe because they're so-so roles at best and the bug that surrounds them atm is irritating


I wasn't aware there's a bug. What is it?


my mistake, lucid actually fixed this yesterday (thank you cub for your persistence in getting this fixed)
Bebop
over 7 years

Jimbei says

Yes for people creating their own setups instead of living off of a default one


not everyone wants to make their own setup to host individually every time, i thought it would be useful for the "default" setup to be at the very least community-decided so that it can appeal to as many people as possible
Shwartz99
over 7 years

Bebop says

agent and spy are in maybe because they're so-so roles at best and the bug that surrounds them atm is irritating


I wasn't aware there's a bug. What is it?
deletedover 7 years
Yes for people creating their own setups instead of living off of a default one
Bebop
over 7 years

nepenthe says

yak agent and spy are 100% yes roles

bleeder shouldn't be more than a maybe (or even a no tbh)


i meant to put yak in the yes, will update that now

agent and spy are in maybe because they're so-so roles at best and the bug that surrounds them atm is irritating
nepenthe
over 7 years
yak agent and spy are 100% yes roles

bleeder shouldn't be more than a maybe (or even a no tbh)
Shwartz99
over 7 years
Invis, agent, lk, km, butterfly, trickster, thulu, cyborg, nomad, prophet, alien, cg, librarian, silencer, blinder, yak, gator, spy, fiddler, plumber, diabolist, mm should be allowed from the Maybe category imo

The rest should be No
dooze
over 7 years
NO ZOMBIE PLS