There needs to be a system in place that would allow mods to be properly measured in there ability to handle reports fairly and properly. I very much doubt that there is some one who consistently looks over every report and evaluates if mods are making the correct verdicts.
Why not implement a way to allow the community to "vote" on the end report verdicts and let the players decide if they believe the decision is fair or not. This would prevent any sort of mod abuse and allows the people who run the site an easy way to evaluate wether or not the mods are doing there job well. This also would be helpful for mods in the appeal process, as mods would be able to read the results and if the overwhelming majority of people believe the verdict given was incorrect, they know that the report needs to be reassessed.
One possible way to do this would be to implement a poll after a report decision has been made. Mods would still have the ultimate power in the final decision, but at least this way we give the community an easy route to help improve and monitor the site.
How can you prove that? you don't have a system in place that accurately moderates mods performance, so now you're just making baseless claims again.
deletedalmost 8 years
that's why there is an appeal system, and if that fails, a complaint subsection of the forum so you can engage the community with your greivances. Or you can pm the admin/a mod you think has a better grasp on the rules personally
Thats why something like this needs to be in place.. If some one makes a wrong decision they are more then likely to do it again.
10% is way much ..... majority of reports are handled properly but like you've admitted here at least 10% are not, and there needs to be a way to fix that.
you don't need any examples of continous wrong verdicts, we all know they happen, lets not play devils advocate to everything
deletedalmost 8 years
epicmafia is a game that's too reliant on luck because there is no guarentee that youll ever be put in a position where you can directly effect the outcome of the game and is really only a party game at it's heart. Any attempt to make it competitive is ill conceived.
Okay, that's a legitimate problem with epicmafia, let's work on some solutions here.
One idea I had was to add fps elements to it to raise the skill cap. But that's just a suggestion, Im really just working at making em better.
But youre not allowed to insult my fps idea unless you can come up with a better idea
My idea is any sort of implementation of a better way to moderate mod performance, the poll was just a suggestion.
Please show examples of where ive dodged anything i have answered literally everything thats been proposed to me
deletedalmost 8 years
youve had 14 pages of reasons that youve dodged around every time. (see: the fact youre not even trying to defend the poll idea anymore...which was pretty much...your entire idea)
So is this thread just a "there needs to be a better way to give moderators feedback" thread now? Because that is true and will always be true on this site and every other site. But at least here, youre able to converse directly with moderators no matter how stupid your idea is (see: this thread)
You don't understand... the idea of a poll or w/e is irrelevant to me at this point. Im just waiting for some one to actually give real backed up reasons that I cant counter. I have only seen 1 post from anyone here that actually counters my idea effectively.
deletedalmost 8 years
Egotists are unwilling to let go of their ideas, not because they believe in their merit, but because they enjoy the idea of having their own ideas
-Stanley Power
deletedalmost 8 years
when your head is so deep inside your own butt, that you dont know up from down, are unwilling to listen to reason, and your horrible idea thread is wildly successful just because of the number of people it has managed to bewilder.
If you read you would see there are a few regular players who have defended the idea, wether its idea of a poll or the idea of some sort of moderation needed. Mods and Role Mods are definitely biased in this issue as it takes as away there power and directly affects them.
I only voted once why are you making baseless claims and the majority of the people who voted no are associated with one another through one way or another wether there past mods role mods etc...
