Back to General Discussion

Transgendered 6 year Old?

about 9 years

http://www.worldstarhiphop.com/videos/video.php?v=wshhx2auSudRf3n6t5b5

A former Texas educator filed a federal discrimination complaint against a learning center in Katy, Texas, after being fired for refusing to address a 6-year-old girl as a transgender boy.The boys parents were a same sex couple

Thoughts? o.O

Was the teacher justified in calling the student a girl
40
No
25
Yes
about 9 years
Children should be educated on transgender at the age of 6 in the same way they should be educated on using firearms.
deletedabout 9 years

ling says

connor when you get married am i invited?




(Also serious)
about 9 years
(Serious)
about 9 years
connor when you get married am i invited?
about 9 years

Stragger says

Ur right, genetics and science are unimportant in the dystopian world of non-binary ppl and their taste for bad cartoon shows


hey man you brought up the hypothetical, i'm just pointing out how your joke was kinda dumb
about 9 years

roadman says


angelic says

i don't see why any parents would support their child as identifying as transgender unless they are supporting their childs decisions, knowing the discrimination the kid will surely receive

i knew i was a girl by age 4 or 5. i refused to wear anything but dresses (biologically a girl too but yeah


How the hell can you even compare transgender to knowing you're a girl, when in fact, you are a girl?


I think transgender children also know theyre not a girl or not a boy and no one can possibly understand unless in that situation
about 9 years

angelic says

Felons im going to assume that the child was treated as a girl because born a girl but their inclinations toward masculine habits and happiness in being identified that way is why they want to identify as a male

parents pushing a gender on a child is an entirely different scenario


They

Are

6

Years

Old
deletedabout 9 years

Hibiki says


Stragger says

5 years from now Doctors who help with childbirth will be forced to say "It's a..." and nothing else as associating gender roles will be haram.


it's a baby, genius


Ur right, genetics and science are unimportant in the dystopian world of non-binary ppl and their taste for bad cartoon shows
about 9 years
man i hate how harrold still frequents EM to remind me about how much i hate him. why didn't he stay gone???????
about 9 years

mindful says

teachers should avoid calling students boys or girls to be gender inclusive


You should avoid saying anything.
about 9 years
Felons im going to assume that the child was treated as a girl because born a girl but their inclinations toward masculine habits and happiness in being identified that way is why they want to identify as a male

parents pushing a gender on a child is an entirely different scenario
about 9 years

mindful says

teachers should avoid calling students boys or girls to be gender inclusive


LMAOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
deletedabout 9 years

Felons says

Hey Bobby, put these blindfolds on and pin the tail on the gender, we'll have absolutely no influence on your decision.


You are defending your case really badly. Please just delete this thread, connor is insufferable with these issues, actually he's insufferable regardless
about 9 years

Stragger says

5 years from now Doctors who help with childbirth will be forced to say "It's a..." and nothing else as associating gender roles will be haram.


it's a baby, genius
deletedabout 9 years

mindful says

teachers should avoid calling students boys or girls to be gender inclusive


That's a kneslapper
about 9 years

angelic says

i don't see why any parents would support their child as identifying as transgender unless they are supporting their childs decisions, knowing the discrimination the kid will surely receive

i knew i was a girl by age 4 or 5. i refused to wear anything but dresses (biologically a girl too but yeah


How the hell can you even compare transgender to knowing you're a girl, when in fact, you are a girl?
about 9 years

angelic says

i don't see why any parents would support their child as identifying as transgender unless they are supporting their childs decisions, knowing the discrimination the kid will surely receive

i knew i was a girl by age 4 or 5. i refused to wear anything but dresses (biologically a girl too but yeah


like i said earlier, dressing a certain way as a child is understandable, when you as a child are saying "I'm a GIRL!" more likely than not your parents told you that you were that gender and that's why you decided that.
deletedabout 9 years
teachers should avoid calling students boys or girls to be gender inclusive
about 9 years
i mean, you could say that it doesn't change how justified she is, but that doesn't remove her actual justification and my inner-most disdain for christianity
about 9 years
a 6 year old will literally not form a gender for themselves, the 6 year old was instructed that they were the above gender, no matter what open-mindedess you guys wanna push it's a lie.
deletedabout 9 years
5 years from now Doctors who help with childbirth will be forced to say "It's a..." and nothing else as associating gender roles will be haram.
about 9 years

Hibiki says


Felons says

The teachers religion has nothing to do with this, just like the parents sexual orientation doesn't lol


no it very much does. she said she was justified because she trusts god['s "original decision"]


Why is it okay for a 6 year old to believe they're transgendered, but you feel that inverted commas are necessary when religion is involved?
about 9 years
i don't see why any parents would support their child as identifying as transgender unless they are supporting their childs decisions, knowing the discrimination the kid will surely receive

i knew i was a girl by age 4 or 5. i refused to wear anything but dresses (biologically a girl too but yeah
about 9 years
Hey Bobby, put these blindfolds on and pin the tail on the gender, we'll have absolutely no influence on your decision.
about 9 years

angelic says


Felons says


angelic says

who the hell said his parents pushed a sexuality on him

my god

people need to stop being obsessed with others affairs that aren't hurting anyone else. maybe katy wants to be addressed as a boy now. maybe katy will have a change of heart later. maybe the child is bigendered. who knows. let the kid decide for himself and do what makes him happy


You think the parents had NO influence on this 6 year old calling themselves a boy?


perhaps the parents were open-minded in allowing the child to identify as preferred gender moreso than straight parents may be

i don't see that as pushing a gender on a child


If your parents didn't tell you you were a (enter your gender here) at your age would you know which one you were?


What are you telling me rightn ow? the parents said "Hey Billy, which of these sounds more appealing to you? Boy or Girl!?!"