Back to General Discussion

Transgendered 6 year Old?

about 9 years

http://www.worldstarhiphop.com/videos/video.php?v=wshhx2auSudRf3n6t5b5

A former Texas educator filed a federal discrimination complaint against a learning center in Katy, Texas, after being fired for refusing to address a 6-year-old girl as a transgender boy.The boys parents were a same sex couple

Thoughts? o.O

Was the teacher justified in calling the student a girl
40
No
25
Yes
about 9 years

roadman says


JasonCone says


Felons says


leo says


Felons says


pereking says


Felons says


pereking says

it doesn't really matter if the kid can or can't decide their gender, transgender people are real and exist. it is not up to the teacher to decide if the kid is transgendered or not and as long as the kid is serious about being addressed by the other gender the teacher should respect their wishes


but it's up to the parents to assign a gender to the kid?


it's up to the kid


so if the kid self identified as a pear would the teacher have to call the kid a pear?


otherkin is way different from gender identity.

( not to make a debate on that too, but they aren't comparable )


'UCKIN LOL!


What about like wolf kin?? what if i identify is a wolf boy you gotta call me wolfy


What about if I identify as royalty. I will accept nothing other than to be addressed as, 'your highness'.


what if i identify as a girl just so i can go into their bathrooms and watch them pee?
about 9 years
i love internet debates so much
about 9 years

Felons says


mindful says

omg im not even trans and you annoy me so much

sum1 whos mod pls delete this thread


why would a mod delete a thread in the General Discussions that isn't offending anyone?


( echo chamber of screaming behind felons, bloodied meat upon the walls, Felons debates on whether or not his reality is an echo chamber... as though it is him talking, no one else, no one claiming he is transphobic...

Scene Ends. )
deletedabout 9 years
deletedabout 9 years
tumblr is a way better site and community than this one. i mean, say what you want about it, but this place is almost invariably worse w/r/t discussing anything.
about 9 years
it doesn't matter whether people think the child was 'really transgender' or not. it's not your freaking place to judge. true, children don't know what they're talking about half the time. but if this kid wants to identify as a boy, let him. he's not hurting anybody by doing so. at that age it's very important for kids to express themselves and discover who they are. would it really have been THAT hard to call the child by his preferred pronouns? really??? especially after the parents asked her to. teachers are supposed to be supportive of children, and nourish them to help them establish their personality. playing pretend is a large part of that. teachers understand this, and encourage children to use their imagination. if this teacher wanted to inspire creativity by allowing children to be themselves, then why would she refuse to address the child as his preferred pronouns because she thought he wasn't 'really transgender'? to me this indicates that this person is unfit to be a teacher due to their discriminatory actions, and i agree with the decision to fire her.
deletedabout 9 years
Ronald Reagan is my favorite president
about 9 years
Please stop the bad people without outrageously liberal opinions from posting in my safe space.
about 9 years

roadman says


leo says

you don't know how many people on tumblr would rip you apart from that


Yeah, cause tumblr is law. The problem isn't what people will say to you on tumblr, the problem is being on tumblr in the first place. #terrified #tumblrisawful


but roadman.. i was joking... u hurt me so much
deletedabout 9 years
glad i didn't read this thread
about 9 years

mindful says

omg im not even trans and you annoy me so much

sum1 whos mod pls delete this thread


why would a mod delete a thread in the General Discussions that isn't offending anyone?
about 9 years

leo says

you don't know how many people on tumblr would rip you apart from that


not participating in irrelevant debate but this is a funny sentence
about 9 years
Mods, please delete this thread.
about 9 years

leo says

you don't know how many people on tumblr would rip you apart from that


Yeah, cause tumblr is law. The problem isn't what people will say to you on tumblr, the problem is being on tumblr in the first place. #terrified #tumblrisawful
about 9 years
and lol at u comparing it to a pear
i hope you rereas your post look at how ignorant it is and delete it devante
deletedabout 9 years
(What people don't want to admit is that there is a working, stable and completely hetero-normative world outside their room and tumblr, and this somehow makes people v angry when you talk about it)
about 9 years

leo says

you don't know how many people on tumblr would rip you apart from that

deletedabout 9 years
omg im not even trans and you annoy me so much

sum1 whos mod pls delete this thread
about 9 years
i just think everyone should do what makes them happy if its not hurting any1 else lol =) we're all dying in the end =)
about 9 years

JasonCone says


Felons says


leo says


Felons says


pereking says


Felons says


pereking says

it doesn't really matter if the kid can or can't decide their gender, transgender people are real and exist. it is not up to the teacher to decide if the kid is transgendered or not and as long as the kid is serious about being addressed by the other gender the teacher should respect their wishes


but it's up to the parents to assign a gender to the kid?


it's up to the kid


so if the kid self identified as a pear would the teacher have to call the kid a pear?


otherkin is way different from gender identity.

( not to make a debate on that too, but they aren't comparable )


'UCKIN LOL!


What about like wolf kin?? what if i identify is a wolf boy you gotta call me wolfy


What about if I identify as royalty. I will accept nothing other than to be addressed as, 'your highness'.
about 9 years

JasonCone says


Felons says


leo says


Felons says


pereking says


Felons says


pereking says

it doesn't really matter if the kid can or can't decide their gender, transgender people are real and exist. it is not up to the teacher to decide if the kid is transgendered or not and as long as the kid is serious about being addressed by the other gender the teacher should respect their wishes


but it's up to the parents to assign a gender to the kid?


it's up to the kid


so if the kid self identified as a pear would the teacher have to call the kid a pear?


otherkin is way different from gender identity.

( not to make a debate on that too, but they aren't comparable )


'UCKIN LOL!


What about like wolf kin?? what if i identify is a wolf boy you gotta call me wolfy


you don't know how many people on tumblr would rip you apart from that

i was just saying the two are different, this isnt my soapbox to complain about otherkin or defend them. this is a transgender issue, and felons had no reason to bring that up as a comparison.
about 9 years
i'm not sure what identifying as transgender has to do with being addressed as a panda or a pear, maybe i'm missing something
about 9 years

Felons says


leo says


Felons says


pereking says


Felons says


pereking says

it doesn't really matter if the kid can or can't decide their gender, transgender people are real and exist. it is not up to the teacher to decide if the kid is transgendered or not and as long as the kid is serious about being addressed by the other gender the teacher should respect their wishes


but it's up to the parents to assign a gender to the kid?


it's up to the kid


so if the kid self identified as a pear would the teacher have to call the kid a pear?


otherkin is way different from gender identity.

( not to make a debate on that too, but they aren't comparable )


'UCKIN LOL!


What about like wolf kin?? what if i identify is a wolf boy you gotta call me wolfy
deletedabout 9 years

alexicon says


how u feel if he start self harming bc he cant be himself cuz u all jerks HOW U FEEL THEN JUST LET HIM LIVE HIS LIFE HE AINT HURTING U


i'd think that it's unfortunate that his parents lacked foresight
about 9 years

Felons says


leo says


Felons says


leo says


Felons says

If the same 6 year old kid went to school saying I hate black people you all would agree that it isn't the childs own opinion on their racism, instead it was something they most likely than not learned from their parents.

Much like this transgender identity. At the age of 6 you're incredibly impressionable, if your parents are telling you that you're an XYZ at the age of 6 you're going to believe you're an XYZ


hey, i used to play games believing i was an animal or a mermaid or some and my dad encouraged me to mess around.

but at school and after playtime? i knew i wasn't any of those. i knew i was a boy!

shut up, and nobody cares.


cool, were you 6? and based off your post on page 5 you do.


if you're going to claim me arguing on the basis you're being a transphobic jerk is me caring, then i guess you got me there.

and yes, i was around that age. kids have borders between imagination and reality.


have i once said in this thread that I hate transexual people? Or did I say I don't think a 6 year old child can tell themselves what gender they are.

Let's allow children to give themselves a gender when they are old enough to walk themselves to school.


you don't have to say it to be transphobic. if you're going to be this ignorant, i suggest you remove yourself from the pleasures of anonymity online and consult a professional.