again, if u assume noobs then none of this shit mineswell work, but if u assume smart players, then whichever maf hasn't been called out yet as maf can cc watcher. therefore, cop outs his report if u assume optimal play.
if villager dies n1 and mafia stalks the other villager n2, i agree that mafia can go for a 2/3 shot at PR by killing the cop's inno (and thereby eliminate a lawyer-clear in the process). but mafia would have been better off killing cop and cc'ing watcher, because assuming everyone in the game is good, it won't be obvious which watcher is legit. also, mathematically if a villager dies n1, it is more likely that maf stalked a PR than a remaining villager (though that includes cop). if you are arguing that cop concealing report works in a game of noobs or with mafia that is too afraid to cc, then i will concede. otherwise, assuming optimal players, cop outs report.
I didn't know what you meant about your new avatar until now, because I kept seeing your old one from the cache. New one, though, is quite, quite awesome.