over 8 years

ALL TIME RANKING CITING BACK TO 2008

Based on trophies, win rates and most of all how you played your best in games. Including cheaters and trolls that i've seen play seriously. Everyone's rank is based on when they're trying their best and in their respective primes (for a few thats specified in brackets).

God tier: BigBadBoy (on any tryhard account), Regfan (before playing w/ Sachy)

A++: Crypto (circa 2011 when not playing in circlejerk tables), Girallon (as catbae), Fantastic (before returning as skeptical), Jaguar (before '11), Soben (after he stopped trolling in broken english and before '12)

A+: Brownpimp007 (when running or as immaculate), Chesskid4 (when he was a secret alt as Tatatmi), Effulgence (before '11), Prevail (during his time as Flex/Fix/Knuckleballer even tho he cheated), Strider (just before he started dating Kerry), theshiv (during his time as Nero),

A: Alcoway, Anthony642 (as SonOfZeus), Atikur (when she pretended to be a guy), Belthazar666, Blastoise87 (as Gay even tho he cheated on it), Cirno (as Nimara), CocaCola, Duckhunter (before '11), Fading (as False even tho he cheated on it), Joole, Radiohated, Rednose2 (as Mertens/Temper), RickKnight (before '10), Sonseray, SystemOverload (as TweIve), Tatsuya, ThirdAug, Turquoise, ubaldooo (as Despicable), Vestige, Vigoroth (as Steven), Zyklon

A-: Achieina, Angelfire, Apeescraper, Applecidersyo, Bearissoslow, Benjerman, Billstickers, Cajunjack, Chupps, Dag, Deborah, Dreamcatcher, ElijahMikaelson (as ChaosBlaze/Eatos), epiclulz, Erica, Eritas, Forbs, Forever, Goodbar, Grace, Haymon (as Cansilo), GerryOat (as Note), Giga13, Hedger, Insanoflex, JeffreyAaron, KindaIWantTo, Kittykeri, Kittenz73, LOLUMAD (before '11), Lmaobird (as Iridescent), MachiavellianGhost, Mangofruit (as yushchenko), Nanita (as Coldsummers or Polms), Pranay7744 (as Dessicate), Radar (as Lust), Rathwins1, Redfoo (as dsmith97), Riotkiller14, RoseOnPlayer, SaintsDynasty, Slyintine, soda17, speedofstupid (as original Shacky account), theeraser, Tomato, Veiexku (as kcinowai and before '10), Vilden, xxerox (as a secret alt like lucidsnows), Zekashis

B+: Account, Alexicon (as Pinacolada), Andrew (as Masterball), Arcbell, Bacde, Bernin, BGA, bubbasparXXX, Bubbles, Calvin, Cavsfan, DangeloD (as bazookaB), Dannyboy, Dared, Dennis, DLGn, doomsday, Dreamquakes, DrJackShephard, Drysc, eckstavo, Emperorschance, Endorphins, Error, Eshbd, Ferny, Gerksterr, h1n1flu, Harodihg, Heck, HoratioCaine, Implosion, Incarcerated, itg321 (as iceaac), Jeep, Jesusofnazareth, Jezebelalli, JM123, Junter, Karmaloop, Kelly, Kerry, Lamer, Ling, lolwot, lotus, lucidrains (during start of the site), Mapreduce, Matt12, Matt55, MaximillionPegasus, MilesPrower, Miloo7, Minie, Murica, Naegiri, Nagerous, Nahdia, Nevermaf, Okeas, OTB (as misselainey), Pereking, Petricigy (before sex change), Pogoster (before going mental), Projectmatt, Raven (as Phoenix), Riddler, Rondar, Roshiez, Sachy, Sammon (as Goatemis), SGR, Shamu, Shrub, Sineadiio, Sirius, Stiffy, Sunstorm, Super, Terra, thebrontosaurus, thejkb, theonlyjazznation, Thrillvy, TMjuke (as Tibbers), Trolleyz, vashthestampede (as Vexium), Vedarshi, Vifam, Voltron, willianGallis, wsteyer (during start of the site), xjuicy (as Juke), xsonianevermindx (as Ripple), yoyo200900, ZEEnon, Zovea (before '10)

B: lionel99, jesswhite, imthefool, Facebook, cubfan90, RedCoyote, FBG, RNB, RWF, kylehlp123, KatnissTheRebel, zach420, roughnightbro, bamfcallee, nown1111, LittleV, hungryhippo, kotw10, dle9999, Nbtnbt5, Skoffin, Retti, Schezo, Minxy, rektson, Scubasteve, user80, thegeneral2112, scumboodler, Papuito, Splinterfright, DropKickDiva, pafff, ichizon, icemynipz, Acrylics, Linker, zwink, elise, sonrio, reeses, shinigami, emily, EmmerrLouise, pamda, simplypam, dannie, garyoak, KHNM, innovateur83, shmeur, Markus, Himiko, Ucklar, papoy, Hurricane13, payamcf, Vendetta, mna3631, Nikysha, Heinous, foolonthehill, godofdarkness, mafiagod, supernova, laservp, scholsey, Mastercheif, shieldbearer, Shamzy, Devante, carolineeee, amishguy, RohiniN, Tactic, Hypersoft, Sincerely, schutzekatze, Pocky, thegatso, Pamda, Betmen, evilpyro, johnreid, johnbatman, jonsnow, guyfawkes, ladynemesis, PatrykSzczescie, ponylove, burtonx, adblock, shannonx, datguiser, sweeper, gennehfarrxD, kpcptmku, aquamermaid, usagichan49, charley, stayaway, Nicol, zoolander, RaMpUrI, perro, GotConverted, IAMRobik, Jaleb, utahraptor, coolkidrox123, bebop, jackhammer, FaZ, Soluciones, scumboodler, epicsean, chooksy, billclintonIRL, benmh92, dwightschrute, nightwolfx, madains, bowlinjim, 2gamis, tonkotsu, Rin, Kuno, MisterPresident, mtlve

C+ (slightly better than average) - Not gonna make a list cuz it'd be too long

Average players or below won't be included

Post if you think you're good enough to be ranked if not already on here.

Post if you disagree with a placing or think someone is missing.

For those who posted ITT:

Below B: Rutab, Samuel, Cozy, Mindful, thecolonel, Justrec, Juneau, female, Ark, Bennychaos, annabelle, Redino, shwartz99, LeMeJoe, Jesteroz, RowanJay, Grateful, Hiariej, S1337, evolpz, peach, GayLivesMatter (hes mikeyru??)

Haven't seen your play (probably Below B): k9trip, StevoJR, overcat, carmean, Lionel, miles54321, Player, CTFaithful, jester17, CarmenK72, maxxburn, WhiteMarauder, BeepBeepLettuce

deletedover 8 years

Transcend says

Lol what's been up with all these tier lists. Imo you all suck at mafia.

over 8 years
I have been given B rank. Thanks
deletedover 8 years
I reckon I'd place above tier 4
over 8 years
Lol what's been up with all these tier lists. Imo you all suck at mafia.
over 8 years
HahahaHAHaHAHa somebody actually too kteh time to make this list dating back to

2 0 0 8
0
0
8

jesus christ you cant make this s**t up
over 8 years

Lono says


brownpimp007 says


Lono says

i should be god tier but w/e homie


At lease you got to be on a list that isn't mine


dont steal my trademarks


I change my vote to non-lono
deletedover 8 years

brownpimp007 says


Lono says

i should be god tier but w/e homie


At lease you got to be on a list that isn't mine


dont steal my trademarks
over 8 years

Gerry says


Giant says

https://epicmafia.com/game/5429960/review

This game is a qualified evidence for Gerry's demotion to B- or C+ list.


I was voting John until you blitzed u noob. never blitz as town


I am not as good as people in the list are, but I understand that blitzing your cc is not a scumtell. Demote yourself !
over 8 years

Lono says

i should be god tier but w/e homie


At lease you got to be on a list that isn't mine
deletedover 8 years
i should be god tier but w/e homie
over 8 years

Giant says

https://epicmafia.com/game/5429960/review

This game is a qualified evidence for Gerry's demotion to B- or C+ list.


I was voting John until you blitzed u noob. never blitz as town
over 8 years

iCouldBeatYouUp says

that's why it's really accurate :-)


Several of these rankings are laughable, but again props for the effort.
over 8 years
https://epicmafia.com/game/5429960/review

This game is a qualified evidence for Gerry's demotion to B- or C+ list.
over 8 years
90% of these people don't even play anymore/play on a secret alt now
over 8 years
There are a lot of people on this list.
And I haven't heard of about 3/4ths of the people here.
That's what not finding this site until 2014 does I guess.

But I'm slightly above slightly above average.
over 8 years
huh. i made this list... im not sure how but that's kinda neat thanks i guess for giving me A- even though i've been gone for ages and don't even know what the roles do anymore
over 8 years

JM123 says


JeffreyAaron says

JM123 is too high, mainly based off the fact that you ranked him at all.


actually if you rank the games when i'm actually caring about winning, i should be way above : )


Lol JM123, that hammer was so bad in the f3, you can not ask for a raise here, honestly what you got sounds good enough.
over 8 years
vilden would have put pranay higher and not used exclamation points
over 8 years
wow i made the list lmao
over 8 years
Cool someone included me in a list of players.
over 8 years

cozy says

Tier sh!t : cozy


Don't think you played any setups that weren't dogshit
over 8 years

mindful says

hi what about me


C+
over 8 years
hi what about me
over 8 years
Tier sh!t : cozy
over 8 years
Revert EM back to the scumhunting ways........