Based on trophies, win rates and most of all how you played your best in games. Including cheaters and trolls that i've seen play seriously. Everyone's rank is based on when they're trying their best and in their respective primes (for a few thats specified in brackets).
God tier: BigBadBoy (on any tryhard account), Regfan (before playing w/ Sachy)
A++: Crypto (circa 2011 when not playing in circlejerk tables),
Girallon (as catbae), Fantastic (before returning as skeptical),
Jaguar (before '11), Soben (after he stopped trolling in broken english and before '12)
A+: Brownpimp007 (when running or as immaculate), Chesskid4 (when he was a secret alt as Tatatmi),
Effulgence (before '11), Prevail (during his time as Flex/Fix/Knuckleballer even tho he cheated),
Strider (just before he started dating Kerry), theshiv (during his time as Nero),
A: Alcoway, Anthony642 (as SonOfZeus), Atikur (when she pretended to be a guy), Belthazar666,
Blastoise87 (as Gay even tho he cheated on it), Cirno (as Nimara), CocaCola, Duckhunter (before '11),
Fading (as False even tho he cheated on it), Joole, Radiohated, Rednose2 (as Mertens/Temper),
RickKnight (before '10), Sonseray, SystemOverload (as TweIve), Tatsuya, ThirdAug, Turquoise,
ubaldooo (as Despicable), Vestige, Vigoroth (as Steven), Zyklon
Guy fawkes - has a much better in depth understanding of the game. whether he's won a trophy or not, how many times has he actually ran in comparison to a lot of these guys who you placed higher then him.
FYI - Shini's comp account https://epicmafia.com/user/228040#/ he only lost 41% of comp games back when maymay, derfel, and mikeyru were the only dodges.
You made a list ranking a portion of the community w/ limited, biased, knowledge and then tried to argue to defend it.
Also, BigBadBoy just showed me you had commented on this (which brought me back here) and then trash talked me about my pie lol (remember this is my first account ever, so to talk about someone's pie on their first acc ever is :fp:. all my alts are 60+% w/r in comp.
A couple months ago, I offered to bet BigBadBoy (Self proclaimed EM GOD) any amount of money USD that i would place better than him any comp round he wanted. Pay before play, we both agree on who holds the money.
had to have been lol. i'm not sure how he could have played with all these players while they were playing at their best. i've been here 9 years and haven't seen 3/4 of these people play at their best. To put me, guyfawkes, antidote, STIFFY??, shini?? (years ago) etc. at their best below a lot of the other names listed is comical haha.
guyfawkes - that guy who has been playing forever and never trophied w/ a coin-flip pie lol
antidote - that guy who metas w/ xjade in red heart games and has just a single bronze trophy to his name lol good one
shini - sub 50% win rate, nuff said
stiffy - is ok and ranked higher than the rest u mentioned.
ITT People that can barely post 50% spamming FP whine about how they and their friends are clearly elite