Back to Epicmafia

new rule is bad

almost 9 years

https://epicmafia.com/game/4650359/review here is an example of mafia abusing the new rule to kill a clear, they were not in autolose.

almost 9 years
and before anyone says "who cares"

You can make fun of me for caring. You can try to inhibit proper and open debate and discussion with tacky insults like that. But I will not be silenced, I will fight this and I will always be against it. I don't see why it is wrong or juvenile to care about this ruling, as would be implied by that statement.
almost 9 years
You guys do realize you've no say in the matter because the administration is on a godcomplex right?
deletedalmost 9 years
i agree, this new rule is dumb
almost 9 years

Devante says

Like I said before I was a mod, while I was a mod and now, still as a mod


Mafia killing clear on meteor night = game continuing

doctor saving on meteor night = game ending.


if you don't want mafia to kill your clear on meteor night lynch them before it goes to meteor night.


that's dumb. it's mafia's job to try and kill the clear in whatever way they can before it gets to that situation, be it getting them lynched, or going for the doc early so they don't have to deal with it.

whoever made this rule is pretty dumb
almost 9 years
All these questions literally would not exist if it was mafia gt and not town gt. Mafia lose NOTHING by killing outside in this game. NOTHING! Why are town forced to compromise? THEY GAINED THE ADVANTAGE BY INTERCEPTING A KILL.
almost 9 years

Devante says

Like I said before I was a mod, while I was a mod and now, still as a mod


Mafia killing clear on meteor night = game continuing

doctor saving on meteor night = game ending.


if you don't want mafia to kill your clear on meteor night lynch them before it goes to meteor night.


Mafia blindly hitting the person they know will be saved like cavemen when killing outside is not autoloss SHOULD BE gamethrowing. Town have GAINED AN ADVANTAGE BY SAVING A KILL. Why do they lose it for free? Why do mafia get priority even though their kill was already saved once? Why are Mafia rewarded for playing suboptimally here? Is there a refund if Doc saves their save on meteor night? (cc: admins) WHAT'S THE POINT OF DOCTOR WHEN THERE'S NO INVESTIGATIVE ROLE ALIVE?
almost 9 years
You better hope I'm never doc in that situation three times in a six month span, because if I am, well guess what I'll be banned for gamethrowing lol
deletedalmost 9 years

Devante says

Like I said before I was a mod, while I was a mod and now, still as a mod


Mafia killing clear on meteor night = game continuing

doctor saving on meteor night = game ending.


if you don't want mafia to kill your clear on meteor night lynch them before it goes to meteor night.


I just said why this was dumb i would have ccd doc no matter what the situation was. If it was mylo and i got lynched blister would get killed then its 1 clear with three unknowns. Then if they let the kill go through (like they did) and i got lynched instead then it would go to 3 way no clears. Both those situations mafia has a 1/3 chance to get lynched when there is one left. Doc has the mechanic to try to prevent this from happening. Mafia would know that only the clear could be covered
almost 9 years
@ OP: Exactly. This is complete bs and this is EXACTLY the kind of thing I was hoping to avoid happening by fighting against this rule. If there's no investigative role, you have made doctor obsolete.
almost 9 years
Like I said before I was a mod, while I was a mod and now, still as a mod


Mafia killing clear on meteor night = game continuing

doctor saving on meteor night = game ending.


if you don't want mafia to kill your clear on meteor night lynch them before it goes to meteor night.
almost 9 years
it's towns job to stop the bad mafia, not mafia to play to help town stop them, the bad guys.

stop complaining about having one more unclear in the game, instead find the mafia. the rule isn't changing no matter how many threads with the same title you make
almost 9 years
yeah, fam if we were forced to kill outside, town wouldve likely been in a better position (eh honestly if we had to kill i thought burial was doc anyways), but I'm saying in this case town shouldve lynched for 4way with a clear if they got it right (town had 0 clears because you cced doc when we were at 5way)
deletedalmost 9 years
Even if town would have decided to lynch instead of nling i would have still claimed doc and fished out blister and it would have gone to 4 way with 1 of those being clear, this just gives mafia the right to always force a mylo situation.
almost 9 years

Devante says

i have a solution

deletedalmost 9 years
This new rule is terrible and be easily abused by mafia.
almost 9 years
They can't. If it's Mylo and mafia nk as well, they get meteor and they are forced to lynch or gamethrow and lose the game.
almost 9 years

Anthony says

My question is what's the difference between mafia forcing doc not to save the clear, and town nking on Mylo until meteor? Why can't town force mafia to kill pre meteor?


town can nl as much as they want
almost 9 years
My question is what's the difference between mafia forcing doc not to save the clear, and town nking on Mylo until meteor? Why can't town force mafia to kill pre meteor?
almost 9 years
don't let mafia bully you of your clear (btw town shouldve lynched with the clear alive) 4way with a clear alive is better than 3way no clears.
deletedalmost 9 years
you should have stuck to your guns i wouldn't of reported you lmao
almost 9 years
i have a solution