It shouldn't even be about roles - setups should be blacklisted if they're uneven or misused. The setups cause the issues, not the roles. SITD is unranked but no one is blacklisting Lightkeeper.
Yet there's a ton of other roles I've already talked to you about that are perfectly fine for ranked play and you're still banning them.
You can't expect us to go digging setups when a lot of those roles do not have exposure because of how new they are! That is backwards thinking. Instead you should be banning them because of all the setups that they are abused in but you're putting the burden on them getting in and that makes no sense.
I really don't know what else to say here - I've been pretty abundantly clear on my stance on Voodoo. The setup itself is fine, Voodoo is why it can't be ranked. I gave you suggestions for how to rework it. I'm not allowing voodoo.
So you can't show me where it's a pointfarm and is not played correctly and it remains blacklisted despite just saying that you'd allow setups that met this criteria.
Emmer's setup wasn't a pointfarm though, people actually played a legitly. The same 2 or 3 words was always voodooed, so you knew not to say those words.
and since Gallis Hunter weekend has started, Can we possibly have a rMaf weekend just once! lol
Find me setups that get any plays that use any of these roles properly and I'll allow it. Until then I'm not opening the doors for people to make pointfarms with them.
We have sandbox, no sense in taking away people from their lobby. Main doesn't need all of the roles since a lot of them aren't well-suited for ranked anyway.
Roles like Santa make it much easier to troll/throw because of the diversity of options that they have.
You can play it in unranked, Emmerr. Voodoo is one role that definitely shouldn't be allowed in ranked. It is all RNG and kills someone just for saying a word and can disrupt communication. It is not good for ranked. You can fix your setup if you want it ranked, like I said.
Alien is a more balanced version of cult, yet it's disallowed. The whispering roles are disallowed (wth?). Roles with counterparts that have the same ability are disallowed. Roles previously used in competitive games are disallowed (silencer in BAC for example)
You're going way too far bronto
deletedabout 11 years
Is it really hard to make voodoo available only in unranked games? I get not allowing it into ranked games, but voodoo lady makes unranked sitd games fun.
