Back to General Discussion

Corporal Punishment?

almost 7 years

Do you believe that physically disciplining a child is acceptable and an efficient way to teach them between right and wrong?

I would think fear can be a very effective and persuasive tool, but I don't think it should be applied to a parent and child dynamic. I just don't like the idea of hitting kids.

what does your morals say
21
No, it's not effective
14
Yes, but only sometimes
5
I don't know/I'm in between
2
Yes, absolutely
0
No, only to juveniles
almost 7 years
Or be a decent human being and let them know they did something wrong by telling them, or even punishing them by giving them chores, not beatings.
almost 7 years
i got physically disciplined as a kid back then. i would probably agree if you hit them by not using full strength you know, to show them that you really discourage their behavior.
almost 7 years
just cooked some lobsters in runecsape. ask me naything
almost 7 years
it's prostate stimulation..
almost 7 years

peach says

einstein is on the record as gay LOL


ain't nothing gay about taking a bbc up ur boypussy
almost 7 years

peach says

ignoring my gay einstein comment...coward



peach says

ignoring my gay einstein comment...coward


sry didn't get that was a continuation thing i'll think of something
almost 7 years
ignoring my gay einstein comment...coward
almost 7 years

groundhogday says

i don't think i was spanked i can ask though


she said once after i got mad when she took the video games away
almost 7 years
einstein is on the record as gay LOL
almost 7 years
i don't think i was spanked i can ask though
almost 7 years

peach says

there's obviously a line between spanking ur child and disciplining them in an abusive way. regardless of that, the science on the subject almost always says that physical discipline is both less effective and more psychologically harmful in the long run.

regardless of the severity, using corporal punishment will almost always result in more negative outcomes (long & short-term) for the child when compared to verbally communicative & non-fear/pain-centered methods of punishment for bad behavior


i don't think there's a line like that i think spanking is disciplining in an abusive way and my opinions are very important
almost 7 years

peach says

yikes lol


i mean u can say that but einstein is on the record as a definite racist
almost 7 years
those dam commies
almost 7 years

somethingwhatever says


illuminati says

Also shoutouts to Stalin.

You don't want your kid to be that guy.


i do


tfw u want ur child to be stalin ¿
almost 7 years

peach says


Zhuorb says

Shut up and go to your room, Violet


i'm gonna spank u with a soup spoon


reported for hate crimes
almost 7 years

illuminati says

Also shoutouts to Stalin.

You don't want your kid to be that guy.


i do
almost 7 years

Zhuorb says

Shut up and go to your room, Violet


i'm gonna spank u with a soup spoon
almost 7 years
i don't think myself or most people are fundamentally f*cked up as a result of being spanked as children, but it's pretty much proven to be a pretty ineffective way of teaching children to discern right from wrong in the long run. it just leads them to fear their parents/authority figures rather than making intelligent and informed decisions based on realistic consequences
almost 7 years

MonteCarrlo says

You can't have accurate studies on this, since there are way too many factors. As you said, "NOTE THAT THIS IS NOT KNOWN TO BE CAUSE>EFFECT", so everything said after that is irrelevant. Bad people will be bad, whether they get spanked or not. Spanking someone won't turn them into a bad person.


Yeah but even without those 27 studies, there are literallly hundreds of others that say Corporal Punishment is ineffective. Basically every single unbiased study ever conducted has concluded that CP is not necessary nor practical.

tbh Before writing my report I was 100% for CP, but SciENcE! is never wrong, so i've reversed my views, what a useless report.


peach says


Linke says

In an analysis of 27 distinct studies,


we need to work harder, fellow epicmafia forum posters


My neck hurts from trying nek myself :(


Zhuorb says

You missed the target demographic @Linke


*cries*
almost 7 years
Shut up and go to your room, Violet
almost 7 years
there's obviously a line between spanking ur child and disciplining them in an abusive way. regardless of that, the science on the subject almost always says that physical discipline is both less effective and more psychologically harmful in the long run.

regardless of the severity, using corporal punishment will almost always result in more negative outcomes (long & short-term) for the child when compared to verbally communicative & non-fear/pain-centered methods of punishment for bad behavior
almost 7 years
yikes lol
almost 7 years
it depends on whether they like it
almost 7 years
You missed the target demographic @Linke
almost 7 years
i think that the more we beat kids the better theyll be