Back to Epicmafia

Suggestion regarding reports

deletedabout 7 years

Introduction
As of now, most (if not all moderators) provide no reason at all when they violate or no-violate a player.

Why should this be changed?
It is quite obvious what power the moderators is given by basically letting them do what they want without even giving an explanation why they took a certain measurement. Namely:

  • Favor friends and moderators
  • Disadvantage people they do not like
  • Manipulate the competitive play

What are possible disadvantages?
The only disadvantage I found so far is that mods have to put greater effort into dealing with reports. And with "greater" I mean appending one (!) more sentence that explains why one has taken that measurement. It shouldn't be much of an issue because a moderator clearly knows why they violate a player, they just need to write down their thoughts about it :)

Can we, vanilla users, change anything about it?
Perhaps. If there is a wide range of players who would wish to apply such a change to moderating rules, they might as well think about doing so. For this purpose, I have created a little poll in which you can have your voice about this matter.

~ Your one and only MarcellDavis

Enforce providing reasons when giving a violation or a NV?
39
Yes
8
No
deletedabout 7 years
THIS WOULD GREATLY REDUCE THE NUMBER OF REPORTS, IF THEY PUT THE REASONS WHY ON THE REPORT THAT IT WAS VIO/NO VIO. THEN I WOULD LIKE KNOW WHY THEY NO VIO SOMETHING SO I DONT REPORT THAT THING AGAIN!

Also mods see so many games, so I think that this would help with the appeals. they would know their reasons without having to re-read the games. This would help everyone find mod errors more quickly too. Like its not that uncommon for a verdict to be bad because the mod missed part of the game. You catch this sometimes when they tell you why it was a vio/no vio and you can point them of where to read better.
about 7 years
it's pretty lazy moderating if you don't leave a reason why
about 7 years
em user deranged is still upset i didn't get a harassment violation for jokingly calling a user fat once when they weren't even there
deletedabout 7 years

Kerry says

bebop is a good mod that em does not deserve


I hope this is sarcasm I can’t read tone on the internet
deletedabout 7 years

Kerry says

bebop is a good mod that em does not deserve


I laughed
about 7 years
bebop is a good mod that em does not deserve
about 7 years

joga says


Kerry says


Bebop says

sure it does, but i don't think you should force mods to do it. i already do it for my reports where i think the reason i gave or didn't give the vio might be unclear.


good job


no need to act catty


im sorry that it is difficult to read tone on the internet
deletedabout 7 years

Kerry says


Bebop says

sure it does, but i don't think you should force mods to do it. i already do it for my reports where i think the reason i gave or didn't give the vio might be unclear.


good job


no need to act catty
about 7 years

Bebop says

sure it does, but i don't think you should force mods to do it. i already do it for my reports where i think the reason i gave or didn't give the vio might be unclear.


good job
about 7 years
sure it does, but i don't think you should force mods to do it. i already do it for my reports where i think the reason i gave or didn't give the vio might be unclear.
about 7 years
writing out your thought process on the report validates your actions and gives transparency to your moderation

some reports it's unnecessary though
about 7 years

Orienteering says


Bebop says

the only reason a closed report won't have the name of the mod who handled it on it is when the mod who handled it gets removed


tell charley to come back cuz i got her skype


you're not going to be modded dude
about 7 years
if you choose not to message a mod to ask them politely to explain something to you then i don't know what to tell you lol, i don't think mods should be forced to write a sentence for every report because it'd burn mods out even faster than they get burned out already, among other reasons
about 7 years

MarcellDavis says

While itself does not prevent the site from dying, it is a small step towards this goal.

Also, may anyone (or even jess herself) explain me why this was NV'd?

https://epicmafia.com/report/231634

Keep them comments coming guys, but only constructive stuff thx


grudgeshooting isn't a vio anymore? hMMM
about 7 years

Bebop says

the only reason a closed report won't have the name of the mod who handled it on it is when the mod who handled it gets removed


tell charley to come back cuz i got her skype
about 7 years

Bebop says

the only reason a closed report won't have the name of the mod who handled it on it is when the mod who handled it gets removed


what if was closed before the moderator is added? :doge:
about 7 years
the only reason a closed report won't have the name of the mod who handled it on it is when the mod who handled it gets removed
deletedabout 7 years

Bebop says

if you don't know why a mod gave a particular ruling you can always just shoot them a private message asking them


Not everyone wants to message a mod for various reasons. It seems simpler to just explain something right then instead of having to message the mod - when sometimes there isn’t even a name of the mod who handled the report.
about 7 years

joga says

nothing worse than an eager new mod thinking they're doing a good service by negging innocent comments


It was meant to prevent things from escalating like they always do.
deletedabout 7 years
nothing worse than an eager new mod thinking they're doing a good service by negging innocent comments
deletedabout 7 years
While itself does not prevent the site from dying, it is a small step towards this goal.

Also, may anyone (or even jess herself) explain me why this was NV'd?

https://epicmafia.com/report/231634

Keep them comments coming guys, but only constructive stuff thx
about 7 years
inane language policing probably isn't going to help the site when it's dying either, let the boys have their fun as long as it's not hurting anyone's feelings
deletedabout 7 years

jess says

good thread




explain please??
about 7 years
I would appreciate if you refrain from turning this into drama and you stick to the topic. This is meant to be a helpful thread that aims to bring a positive change during a time where it's visible that the website is dying.
deletedabout 7 years

dzanek1143 says


jontytt says

r*tard


Only rеtards don't know how to spеll this word and use it.


HOOOOOOOOOOOLY crap you got him