Back to Forum Games

Sandbox Court

about 8 years

Welcome to the Sandbox Court!

I've realized that a lot of people love to debate about many topics on Epicmafia, but don't have a proper place to express these opinions. Hence, I've come up with Sandbox court. Note: This thread is only for suggesting a case or asking to take part in the next case.

‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍

‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ Current Case: Death vs Justice

Pending Cases

Inbox me if you'd like to join one. Include which ones you want to join, and your stance for them.

  • Do you think Net Neutrality should be protected? If not, what is the benefit of getting rid of it? (Protect: 4) (Don't: 3)

  • Do you believe that vaccination should be mandatory or optional? ‍ (Mandatory: 1) (Optional: 2)

  • Should countries take in Syrian Refugees? Would your answer change if you got to pick which religious groups can enter? ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ (Yes: 1) (No: 1) (Only specific groups: 0)

  • Barring external factors (i.e. AdSense), should people be banned for hateful comments? This does not include sustained individual harassment. (Participants: 2)

  • Is human cloning justified, and should it be permitted? (Random Teams)(Participants: 1)

How does it work?

Simply put, every Sunday, there will be a thread dedicated to a new court case. You can suggest a court case either in the comments below or in a pm to me, or any other people I designate as hosts. The case will always end on Saturday.

The topic for a court case can be anything, either on or off EpicMafia, but the more interesting it is then the more likely we will pick it. When a topic is picked, anyone can ask to be included in the court case on either side. For example, if the court case is abortion, then you can ask to be on the pro-life or pro-choice side. An example topic you can choose relating to EpicMafia might be whether or not banning users is effective.

On each of these threads, only the people who are debating can comment. However, there will be a poll included that allows users to vote which side they think is winning. This can be used to determine the winner. However, if not enough people vote or if there is a tie, then we might opt for judges to make the final decision.

Despite there being two teams usually in a court case, we will allow more than two if someone can present an additional point of view that differs from the others.

Rules

  • No harassment or personal attacks on the opposition. Doing so will result in a warning, and if continued, it will result in the person being removed from the debate. You are expected to always be respectful during debates.
  • You are NOT allowed to vote on more than one account. If we discover that multiple votes have been placed by you, then you will be disqualified from the voting process. If this was done by accident, please pm me.
  • Stay on topic. If you want to talk about things outside of the debate, then please do it somewhere else. Getting off topic will result in you being removed from the debate.
  • Rules are subject to change anytime for any reason at my discretion. I will inform of any rule changes to avoid confusion.
Sign here if
25 signed
You love to debate with other people because it's fun and allows you to experience the ideas of others from different backgrounds.
Would you consider taking part in this?
22
Yes, I would love to debate!
15
Yes, but I would only vote as the jury.
6
No.
about 8 years

Parudoks says

New debate topic will be added to the list of pending cases: Do you believe that vaccination should be mandatory or optional? (Suggested by Bebop)


mandatory
about 8 years
New debate topic will be added to the list of pending cases: Do you believe that vaccination should be mandatory or optional? (Suggested by Bebop)
about 8 years
The Pineapple Pizza Debate has been chosen as the next debate! This is good because its a light topic I can use on the trial run. The following teams have been chosen:

For: DouradaGrelhada, EpicSides, JohnMiller, BaneofMafia, Jimbei.

Against: Dooze, TennisBallBFDI2, luis4rod, Collokey, Serveaux.
about 8 years

Bebop says

i think the for and against should be decided for participants rather than letting them decide


I agree, that is more fun imo. I'll leave it as is for this one, next one I'll randomly assign everyone. Only because this weeks one is more of a trial run.
about 8 years
i think the for and against should be decided for participants rather than letting them decide
about 8 years
Guys urgent situation here. Scumbag user xxerox wants to delete all our hard-written literature https://epicmafia.com/topic/84283. I'd like to sue user xxerox and take him before the sandbox court.
about 8 years
It seems like Pineapple Pizza will be the first debate. I'll wait until Saturday night before declaring it the winner.
about 8 years

Plissken says

Plissken is Dead. And Jamal's 200th killed him.
I am The Artist Formerly Known As Plissken now.
You will address me as such. I am entirely different.
I only wish to serve my master and spread the good news. Anyone who would object to that is an enemy of our church, The Holy Church of Jamal. Any works of JamalMarley is good news and that is all I speak.
So call out the true spam for what it is. Have you not seen chat lately or the lobby wall where numerous posters post the same thing? If they were going to post, they need only post testaments of the works of the true greatest user on EM.

Don't discriminate against me for my faith.


I gave a warning.
about 8 years
Plissken is Dead. And Jamal's 200th killed him.
I am The Artist Formerly Known As Plissken now.
You will address me as such. I am entirely different.
I only wish to serve my master and spread the good news. Anyone who would object to that is an enemy of our church, The Holy Church of Jamal. Any works of JamalMarley is good news and that is all I speak.
So call out the true spam for what it is. Have you not seen chat lately or the lobby wall where numerous posters post the same thing? If they were going to post, they need only post testaments of the works of the true greatest user on EM.

Don't discriminate against me for my faith.
about 8 years
Plissken, stop spamming or I'm muting you. If you have nothing to contribute, don't post.
about 8 years

JohnMiller says


Bebop says

the problem is you're picking arguments (aside from the pineapple pizza one, which is stupid either way) that most people (on epicmafia) will agree on. i probably should have thought about that before suggesting them though.


In many debate clubs, you sign up for the topic, but you flip a coin to determine whether you're for or against.

It's like an Ideological Turing Test (http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2011/06/the_ideological.html)--could a pro-life guy successfully pretend to be pro-choice, or vice versa?

The catch is that both sides actually have to try, even when the beliefs they are assigned are the polar opposite of what they actually believe. And it means you have to make sure those who vote only are judging the debaters, not how they actually feel about the topics.


I was going to do this, but I wanted to see if it would work with people willingly choosing what they want to do. I might end up randomly assigning people instead of asking them to pick their stance.
about 8 years

luis4rod says

Sign me up please


Just pm me which one you'd like to join from the pending cases and what stance you want :)
about 8 years
I have to vote no as I can not support anything close to the stuff that sad user Plissken would do. I, as The Artist Formerly Known As Plissken, just can not partake in it since there was a Court Case at ..."Plissken's 200th" yuck. I hope that's the last time I ever have to think about that pathetic event. Luckily, Jamal's 200th saved this lobby and reigned in his Second Coming.

I understand you had no affiliation with that user and I am certainly reborn in the name of my lord & savior, JamalMarley, so I have nothing to do with that loser, Plissken, either. I just bare the name as a curse and punishment for my past sins.

The life I lead now is a better one with purpose all thanks to one person, who is simply...

Glorious!
about 8 years

Bebop says

the problem is you're picking arguments (aside from the pineapple pizza one, which is stupid either way) that most people (on epicmafia) will agree on. i probably should have thought about that before suggesting them though.


In many debate clubs, you sign up for the topic, but you flip a coin to determine whether you're for or against.

It's like an Ideological Turing Test (http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2011/06/the_ideological.html)--could a pro-life guy successfully pretend to be pro-choice, or vice versa?

The catch is that both sides actually have to try, even when the beliefs they are assigned are the polar opposite of what they actually believe. And it means you have to make sure those who vote only are judging the debaters, not how they actually feel about the topics.
deletedabout 8 years
allow me to elaborate -- the combination of the sweet but also slightly sharp pineapple adequately complement the unami [savoury] flavour of the cheese to an indisputable degree; this union of flavours is, in my own humble opinion, what separates the wheat from the chaff, so to speak.

what i mean to say is, if you dont like pineapple on pizza ur inferior lol
deletedabout 8 years
1.) good

i rest my case , gentle men ; harsh ladies.
about 8 years
Sign me up please
about 8 years
the problem is you're picking arguments (aside from the pineapple pizza one, which is stupid either way) that most people (on epicmafia) will agree on. i probably should have thought about that before suggesting them though.
about 8 years
OK HOLD UP THERES ONLY ONE AGAINST PINEAPLPE PIZZA I WILL JOIN THEM TOO
about 8 years
I'm on it Parudoks.
deletedabout 8 years
all rise
about 8 years
I'll update how many people are in each team in the OP under "Pending Cases". Then the most popular one will get to go on Sunday. I've placed how many are on each team so people can know how many there are of each. Because if there's like 5 on one team and 0 on the other, then I can't use it.

Each debate will last from Sunday to the following Saturday.
about 8 years
I'm interested in talking about 2, maybe 3 but I think i'd get too heated in 1
about 8 years
You can apply to more than one debate by the way.
about 8 years
I've decided on three topics. If you'd like to participate, inbox me with the name of the debate you'd like to join as well as your stance. The most popular of the three will be the first case on Sunday.

1. Is pineapple pizza good or bad? Should it even be sold in stores? (Collokey)

2. Should the death penalty be abolished? If not, which crimes should be punished by death? (Bebop)

3. Do you think Net Neutrality should be protected? If not, what is the benefit of getting rid of it? (Bebop)