I think Butterfly could be really interesting in a medium-sized setup where all sides have a role with a powerful one-shot ability. Would they dare to restore the Ghoul and Bulletproof if it means the live Sniper gets to shoot again? That sort of thing.
Also, Bride with Tailors, plural.
deletedabout 8 years
Butterfly and Huntsman are useless and stupid. Use shrinks and play gallis hunter. Monkey is an overpowered driver. Snowman is a day roleblocker, we have 3 official roleblocking roles. Prosecutor is selfvote for someone to hammer it.
Versions of roles that have been made for the other alignement are unoriginal. Except hooker and drunk, Don and Governor, paparazzi and oracle & lookout and watcher.
Out of all of the roles added in this latest batch, I'd say the biggest "retreads" are Justice and Cutler. Butterfly and Huntsman can't just be achieved with old role combinations, nor can Monkey. Snowman turns anybody into a daytime drunk/hooker which is pretty good. Prosecutor has a lot of use (probably more than the Judge, I'd say.)
deletedabout 8 years
New roles don't add anything to the game. They're just overcomplicated and old roles can achieve those mechanics with certain role combinations.
