If you say yes you're an idiot because if you say yes, then Cop can die, always. Like if they out, mafia can hit them forever, and doc saving them is Gamethrowing. So Cop outting means Cop dies.
If you say yes, you can have a setup with 1 hooker, 5 docs and 1 cop, if Cop claims Day 1 then they will die because if the doc saves cop it's GT. LOL
it's not doc's fault that mafia continued to try to hit cop til meteor. they shouldn't have to give up saving the clear because mafia want to throw and force meteor
deletedalmost 10 years
because a doc save makes the doc's alignment not win the game instead of maybe win the game
dave, when you get married are we invited (serious)
deletedalmost 10 years
i wonder what series of life events led to me believing that this is a game throw
deletedalmost 10 years
yes. in a not joking way, too
the only way i'd say no is if there's a clearly established exception principle outlined somewhere. the only result of a doc save is a town loss. this is like one of those psychological tests where people see the same scenario in one of two ways and are absolutely convinced they're right, it's weird
exactly the same could be said from the mafia's point of view
My understaning is that town can't force mafia to kill into auto loss. Like in doc tests in a 4 way. Or something like that. Being on the cop the whole time as doc is not GT. As mafia knows Doc would be on the cop. And it's their fault for pushing meteor.
