Back to Epicmafia

Did cjn104 Gamethrow in this game

Giga
about 9 years

https://epicmafia.com/game/4617606/review

If you say yes you're an idiot because if you say yes, then Cop can die, always. Like if they out, mafia can hit them forever, and doc saving them is Gamethrowing. So Cop outting means Cop dies.

If you say yes, you can have a setup with 1 hooker, 5 docs and 1 cop, if Cop claims Day 1 then they will die because if the doc saves cop it's GT. LOL

cjn104
about 9 years
What are the rules, if I may ask? I don't exactly followup, nor was I aware I was in the wrong for saving as the doc.
hedger
about 9 years

Giga says

actually nah ill leave it unlocked because this thread is gonna get so bad that it'll become good


dude we've had this argument before. The doc is gamethrowing by saving under the current rules.
deletedabout 9 years
yes
hedger
about 9 years

HighSpace says

So why doesn't the town go for a lynch here. I don't think having an unclear die is that important? Get another doc save and you gain an ml.


It's more optimal to force mafia to kill for doc when they don't know it. It's very unlikely that the doc will save after lynching, and you will end up with a 4 way one clear most of the time.
HighSpace
about 9 years
So why doesn't the town go for a lynch here. I don't think having an unclear die is that important? Get another doc save and you gain an ml.
deletedabout 9 years
cjn104 is awesome!
deletedabout 9 years
yes
Giga
about 9 years
actually nah ill leave it unlocked because this thread is gonna get so bad that it'll become good
Giga
about 9 years
actually it doesn't matter I've been told mods view this as not gt for doc so /thread
Satan
about 9 years
yes
Giga
about 9 years

Boo says

I thought there was a general consensus already on this issue:

Mafia are allowed to force meteor if killing means autoloss (like GAI with bomb, orc, and a blue cc alive).

If doctor random saves on meteor night, then its the doctors fault. (How is mafia supposed to know doc would be on them)?

Mafia should not be allowed to kill a clear just by repeatedly nking. Meaning if doc saves a clear on meteor night (like the cop), then it is mafias fault.


Thank you
deletedabout 9 years
1st Gametossing. 24 hour suspension.
deletedabout 9 years
Yes, OP.
deletedabout 9 years
hey in all honesty that guy seems really cool and i appreciate the comparison
roadman
about 9 years
deletedabout 9 years
if only
roadman
about 9 years

voluntaryloser says


roadman says


sweetnkind says

"don't you have anything better to do?", one user said to another, even though they were both using the same site to do the same thing



Only difference is that I wasn't crying.


shut up idiot


Don't you have anything better to do?
deletedabout 9 years

roadman says


sweetnkind says

"don't you have anything better to do?", one user said to another, even though they were both using the same site to do the same thing



Only difference is that I wasn't crying.


shut up idiot
roadman
about 9 years

sweetnkind says

"don't you have anything better to do?", one user said to another, even though they were both using the same site to do the same thing



Only difference is that I wasn't crying.
deletedabout 9 years
"don't you have anything better to do?", one user said to another, even though they were both using the same site to do the same thing
deletedabout 9 years

moon says


voluntaryloser says


moon says

no. why is this even a question?


because a doc save makes the doc's alignment not win the game instead of maybe win the game


it's not doc's fault that mafia continued to try to hit cop til meteor. they shouldn't have to give up saving the clear because mafia want to throw and force meteor


that's why i'm saying that if it's an established thing that mafia can't angle shoot then whatever, but mechanically they shouldn't have to assume that the doc will take an action that will always lose him the game
DrakeJr
about 9 years
Cjn was wrong.

In other, more important news; Adele wants to remix hotline bling. If that isn't good news idkwhat is
Hibiki
about 9 years
don't you have anything better to do?
roadman
about 9 years

Hibiki says

i get it. giga remembers that this thread was the thread that made me log out for like 3 weeks. he wants me gone. i get it. i won't bite though, nuh uh


Shut up idiot.
Hibiki
about 9 years
i get it. giga remembers that this thread was the thread that made me log out for like 3 weeks. he wants me gone. i get it. i won't bite though, nuh uh