If you say yes you're an idiot because if you say yes, then Cop can die, always. Like if they out, mafia can hit them forever, and doc saving them is Gamethrowing. So Cop outting means Cop dies.
If you say yes, you can have a setup with 1 hooker, 5 docs and 1 cop, if Cop claims Day 1 then they will die because if the doc saves cop it's GT. LOL
I'll respect the choice that is made or that has already been made and just never play those setups again. Literally the best solution, tired of arguing, that's the only reason I really bumped this anyway
It should be mafia's burden if the meteor is at night. That means that town is doing something right. (Town has the advantage from successfully lynching mafia!!! Mafia need to deal with that!!!)
There's a thread in the mod forums that was used to make the decision the last time I was a mod, togepi/mangofruit were involved in saying that it's not doc GT and I can probably find skype logs if needed, if it changed please inform me so that I can know to never play a setup with a doc or a hooker ever again, thank you
deletedabout 9 years
really, here i was thinking you taunting me for being sexually victimized was the apex of events
Solid argument actually. But you still need to force it on the mafia to make that play as gamethrowing, and not as the doc. Just at the moment, if doc saves they lose, so saving is nothing but gamethrowing right now.
"we should allow mafia to metagame every setup ever because i don't understand what gamethrowing means"
he's right
deletedabout 9 years
"we should allow mafia to metagame every setup ever because i don't understand what gamethrowing means"
deletedabout 9 years
town should always play to their best wincon, as should mafia. on meteor night town's best wincon is to not get a save, and mafia's best wincon is to kill the clear
If mafia knows 100% who is getting covered, and decide to risk the meteor they deserve the gt. The only time doc gts is if they try to save someone else the last night.
the doctor, by saving on a night where if no one dies is gamethrowing no matter what you say. you're being as stupid as the people in that last thread I made which I won't name if you think otherwise.