deletedover 10 years

Hello. A select bit of mods have been deliberating for a while on how to improve the forum experience, and we've discussed the idea of implementing Forum Rules. This is something that we want to include the community in, so your feedback/opinions are worthwhile.

Here's a rough draft for what we have in mind.

  • Every subforum that isnt OT is going to be moderated more heavily for off-topic posts, and moderators will reserve the right to delete your post. Don't ruin threads with your banter, go to OT for that.

  • We're going to try and be harder about flaming/harassment on the forums. We want to try and make the place more friendly and while it might be a bit of a change we're asking that you be patient with us and what we have in mind is merely things to be discussed.

  • Negative and constructive criticism is fine. We're not going to silence your opinion for disagreeing or being abrasive, just never make it personal. That's all we ask. We understand that mafia is a competitive game at it's nature and that things are bound to get heated, but that doesn't mean we have to let things get out of control.

  • Trolling will be treated as the same as trolling in-game. A user has a right to report you if he believes that you are trolling them or their thread. Punishments will be handed out accordingly after we readjust what the repercussions will be for forum trolling.

  • OT will be moderated lightly, and GD will be at the discretion of the person making the topic. All rules are going to be in effect for all other subforums.

All mods reserve to delete your posts if they are off-topic.

over 10 years

pereking says


runwithfire says


Miki says


runwithfire says


Miki says


runwithfire says

Link me to a few


look at other forums in general, they're modded much differently


specifically? I don't frequent any others. Please don't include neopets


never been on neopets :)


then show me a reasonably visited non-religious forum more moderated than what's being proposed


You missed it but I did that.

http://www.giantitp.com/forums/announcement.php?f=29&a=1
http://www.kongregate.com/pages/conduct
http://forums.erfworld.com/viewtopic.php?f=26&t=272


second two bad examples. I'll give you the first
over 10 years
Retti:
It might be a heavier workload on us but It's something we're willing to do to overall improving the attitude of the forums.

kyahahahahahaha
deletedover 10 years
u and kerry both have a bad habit of >green texting things that doesn't adequately portray what you're trying to say
deletedover 10 years
well justrec, you're wrong
deletedover 10 years

Mitch says

is "you're wrong" harassment


No
deletedover 10 years
r u ignoring my posts as well jasprar. cause i've already commented on the OP if that's what you're referring me to WITH AS LITTLE INTERACTION AS HUMANLY POSSIBLE
deletedover 10 years
is "you're wrong" harassment
over 10 years
hi I just got here.

if you implement all of this dumb rules are the other mods going to post or are they going to still be these distant overseers that no one likes??
deletedover 10 years

Mitch says


Rutab says

Poor Justrec has been abused by just about everyone including me


i've never seem him get abused


You must be blind
deletedover 10 years

Rutab says

Poor Justrec has been abused by just about everyone including me


i've never seem him get abused
deletedover 10 years
Ah yes Carly. You big bully
over 10 years

Nonon says


Jasprar says


Nonon says


Jasprar says

Not a good enough excuse for them to become an actually nice & enjoyable place to visit, imo.


maybe if you started punishing people for actually trying offend people, instead of just punishing people who get far enough to heavily offend people


expand


no one gets in trouble for trying to offend or hurt someone else's feelings unless they actually succeed at it, is my point


So you're saying a more definitive rule, rather than something along the lines of harassment (where the offended user has to report, etc)?
deletedover 10 years
Poor Justrec has been abused by just about everyone including me
deletedover 10 years
I'm not going to read this whole thread but I'm glad that the staff are trying to cut down on the toxicity of the forums, and I bet the people in the thread that are against it are the ones that love to be rude.
over 10 years
Empire shush :{
deletedover 10 years

Jasprar says


Nonon says


Jasprar says

Not a good enough excuse for them to become an actually nice & enjoyable place to visit, imo.


maybe if you started punishing people for actually trying offend people, instead of just punishing people who get far enough to heavily offend people


expand


no one gets in trouble for trying to offend or hurt someone else's feelings unless they actually succeed at it, is my point
over 10 years

runwithfire says


Miki says


runwithfire says


Miki says


runwithfire says

Link me to a few


look at other forums in general, they're modded much differently


specifically? I don't frequent any others. Please don't include neopets


never been on neopets :)


then show me a reasonably visited non-religious forum more moderated than what's being proposed


You missed it but I did that.

http://www.giantitp.com/forums/announcement.php?f=29&a=1
http://www.kongregate.com/pages/conduct
http://forums.erfworld.com/viewtopic.php?f=26&t=272
deletedover 10 years

MeIody says

I am just glad the "forumers" were asked about this before implementation. Now you know no one wants it, so it won't go through...right? D:



Empire says

i think the funny part is that regardless of what the community's reaction was, if the mod team could justify it within themselves despite the more than enough room to create controversy, they would go forth with their plan regardless of how many users opposed them

this thread is not a legitimate attempt at community discussion, moreso "please pat us on the back a few days before we make the rules official" with a smaller sidegoal of "well even though the chance of us changing our minds is 0 maybe you can narrow one specific point that doesn't change the overall plan"



Empire says

fortunately for you the extent of freedom on a community IS a controversial/grey area and thus you will get enough backpatters to enable you to feel good with moving forward, even though you could probably make a thread with the reverse and get just as many

deletedover 10 years
Not a good enough excuse for them to become an actually nice & enjoyable place to visit, imo.


They are enjoyable in my opinion. There is an entire internet out there that is just as boring as you seem to want this site to be. This site is unique and fascinating. If you want to improve the forums, focus on making the "Epicmafia " subforum about "Epicmafia" instead of trying to bubble-wrap everything. I've been here for a long time, and I dealt with my fair share of hate. But you know what? I didn't cry or report anyone, because this is a psychological game on the internet and I knew I should put on my thick skin.
over 10 years
"Every subforum that isnt OT is going to be moderated more heavily for off-topic posts, and moderators will reserve the right to delete your post. Don't ruin threads with your banter, go to OT for that."

Honestly--what about this idea. Just ask lucid to give the people who make the topic a right to delete posts within their own topic? What could be the trouble in that, do you think?

I mean, not like lucid will get to it any time soon but it's worth a thought?
deletedover 10 years
its possible to moderate other forums of similar size more heavily because its in keeping with that communities standards and culture.

you cant apply the same to epicmafia six years down the line and expect it to magically morph into the neopets forums. you will kill it.
over 10 years

Nonon says


Jasprar says

Not a good enough excuse for them to become an actually nice & enjoyable place to visit, imo.


maybe if you started punishing people for actually trying offend people, instead of just punishing people who get far enough to heavily offend people


expand
deletedover 10 years
well yeah i already approved of point 4 of OP
over 10 years
i wasn't even arguing for/against the forum being moderated heavier, i was pointing out a fact to sims when he stated em is moderated like other sites. (general rudeness which tends to be found on sites with a larger userbase on the forums because moderation isn't possible)

your snub about neopets was petty
over 10 years
I am just glad the "forumers" were asked about this before implementation. Now you know no one wants it, so it won't go through...right? D: