I'm not contradicting myself at all. Do I like Anthony? Sure. Do I think he's a good mafia player? Better than me. Do I think he should be allowed to trophy run? No, because he knowingly participated in stealing a trophy from someone else who earned it.

Arcbell says

Can someone put me in contact with Sidekick atm? Or is she afk?

She's there I'm talking to her RN.

i've got a solution. how about past cheaters have to inform the mods when they plan to trophy run and mods just keep a close eye on their games?? that seems like an everybody wins solution to me.

Can someone put me in contact with Sidekick atm? Or is she afk?

Apostasy you are totally contradicting yourself

Anthony is a prime case of a formerly banned user for cheating who deserves to trophy run

Rutab says

If you are willing to give Anthony a shot how come all of the others do not

Probably because he's friends with Anthony and 'trusts' him, lol.

Frankly I'm not willing to give Anthony a shot and he knows that. I do believe that he legitimately learned his lesson but unfortunately for him the rest of them are freaking psychotic

If you are willing to give Anthony a shot how come all of the others do not

I think it's pretty ridiculous that you guys let former cheaters trophy run at all, even if they aren't cheating anymore. The only remotely forgivable cheater is Anthony and he is the exception that proves the rule.

thats just screwing over the few people who have cheated in the past, gotten unbanned and stopped cheating.

Slow found that DrJackSheppard was probably cheating in red heart games after he was unbanned

Apostasy says

If you want to unban cheaters fine, just don't let them trophy run ever again. If someone was inconsiderate enough to steal someone else's hard earned trophy by means of fraud they shouldn't be allowed to try for trophies.

ever again is a long time.

I don't really care if they cheat in red hearts, and I bet that would satisfy most of them

Apostasy says

Jackhammer how does it feel to know that sidekick cheated for two trophies and you did not catch her either time, because you are freaking naive?

It's not entirely Jackhammer's fault, unfair to put the whole blame on him. Jackhammer was busy looking into me.

lol you completely misunderstood

I'm not saying unban them or throw suspicion off, or cut em some slack because they did it again. I'm saying "don't assume automatically without looking at proper evidence" because evidence is what cheating investigations are based off of. There's definitely a higher chance of a former cheater cheating again, evidently, but it's only fair that a person should look at the evidence first. Like, I can currently accuse any former cheater with cheating and put a completely bogus pastebin with no evidence at all, the pastebin remains bogus even though the chance a former cheater cheated again remains high. I can't say "User X Cheated before, there is no proper evidence to rule on it as cheating again but he did it once why the hell would he not do it again?".

TLDR look at evidence and deal with it knowing a person did it before; you can't do the latter without the former or the former without the latter.

If you want to unban cheaters fine, just don't let them trophy run ever again. If someone was inconsiderate enough to steal someone else's hard earned trophy by means of fraud they shouldn't be allowed to try for trophies.

xxerox is in 3rd place so he's obviously cheating

Lashka says

The games are sadly a pretty much identical set to last time. The alts are the same person and the same patterns as last time.

Man, Sidekick.

MAn

i do agree that most people who cheat once cheat again and there should be a period of not being allowed to trophy run after being unbanned

Unknown is probably cheating if you ask me.

theres nothing wrong with having a little faith in people. but i guess the moral of the story is to be faithless, get it.

I mean it's hard not to make assumptions when it happens every single round, is all.

"Also don't auto assume people who've done it before will do it again systematically that is a very cynical and braindead thought imo."

Actually Jackhammer is my favorite mod currently but he basically asked for it by posting this

sonseray there are lot of mods that need a good butt pounding, and youre pounding one of the few who dont.