giga dont selfdelete

Sims says

thanks for the post-game review

You're welcome. I was really conflicted on doing it or not. On the one hand I felt like a complete loser, but on the other the compulsion to do it was really strong.

thanks for the post-game review

I just read this game. It's pretty clear that Ani had no clue what was going on. He didn't actually take note that Giga was clear on day 1 it was just that he acknowledged that BP was being called a PR ... that was enough for him to process at the time.

Giga didn't cross right away. He said he really wanted to cross but would reread. I'm assuming that if Giga decided after his investigation that Anigay was town he'd have convinced him to take his vote off.

I don't get Giga's logic though thinking that it's a dumbtell based on the 26% mafia win rate. You basically said "no one is that dumb he has a 26% win rate as scum" .. so you just pointed out that he IS that dumb, and that's why he was faking being dumb? No no no that is very bad logic.

All around we had some bad reasoning by giga, but I don't think him not telling Anigay he was clear was really an issue in the end, it was more just the bad logic.

Sims says

even if giga said he was the clear bp there isnt any guarantee that he would hammer right so it's a moot point

Care less about the fact that he hammered wrong and more about the fact that he didn't even bother to explain or state anything to Ani trying to fall onto the reasoning of "26% as mafia so he's just bad at mafia". Had he explained it to Ani had him change his vote and read his reaction ect. I would have a much less of an issue with the game.

And that was before the game even started.

Giga says

That's nice guys but you missed the part when I said that somebody had already explained it to him and he acknowledged it and then magically instavoted me on Day 3 (which happened 5 minutes after). It looked like an intentional dumbtell. If nobody had explained it to him, then I gladly would have.

If you are not referring to the game I am talking about, then okay

Well was kinda referring to your comment about it's not your job to teach new players I kinda rue that attitude in general. I think it's time we saw the game in question though.

God I'm a loser.

I was 90% hammering wrong regardless

even if giga said he was the clear bp there isnt any guarantee that he would hammer right so it's a moot point

That's nice guys but you missed the part when I said that somebody had already explained it to him and he acknowledged it and then magically instavoted me on Day 3 (which happened 5 minutes after). It looked like an intentional dumbtell. If nobody had explained it to him, then I gladly would have.

If you are not referring to the game I am talking about, then okay

Steven says

It's always people's job to explain things. Mafia is a team game and there no blaming the newbie. Thought I should say that bye

This. I mean treating newbies as valued members of the community and encouraging them to develop their play is really the only way we're gonna get more people to play mafia here.

It's always people's job to explain things. Mafia is a team game and there's no blaming the newbie. Thought I should say that bye

Alright. I thought it was explained on Day 1, by you.

Even D1 he didn't understand what was happening. He spent the whole day under the impression that BP isn't a PR so you not reminding or explaining to him that you're clear is bad. Don't make out as if it's a "job" or requires "effort" to take 5 seconds to explain that you're un cc'ed BP.

I'm not even mad at anyone I just don't really get how what he did is possible

It's no longer my job to teach new players Max, it's Gold Heart and they should know what a clear is before joining a competitive game

I shouldn't have to teach somebody how to remember stuff from Day 1 5 minutes prior to the lylo. It looked like an intentional dumbtell.

On Day 1 he realized I was clear and then on Day 3 he magically forgets? ...

He was very very clearly new, he didn't understand anything about the game. You didn't attempt to explain it to him in the 3 way either nor bring up the fact you're clear. Instead you crossed with him blaming him while never actually teaching him. It's horrendous play;

Read my last post

Resurgence says

You let town vote you in lylo while never reminding them once that you were 100% clear and instead just crossed with them blaming them saying "they have 26% mafia win rate, so they're just bad mafia".

oh my

He acknowledged I was clear after we explained it on Day 1 so I figured he was intentionally dumbtelling, plus I was hammering him even if he didn't do that

You let town vote you in lylo while never reminding them once that you were 100% clear and instead just crossed with them blaming them saying "they have 26% mafia win rate, so they're just bad mafia".

Better not mishammer in a game with Maxwell guys, he'll dodge you!

hey junter i sback (:

would i be a **** if i said maybe reducing red heart refilling to the same rate as golden hearts would encourage people to not make a bunch of red heart games and perhaps encourage people to play the gold ones

also the fact you can't make an alt and join the competition has to be hurting things a bit