What if one hipfires correctly, should they be reported for gamethrowing?
And why does someone who hipfires incorrectly get in trouble with doing so when they were simply taking the risk that they would hipfire correctly and be rewarded for good behavior?
a cop shooting their guilty isn't hipfire anyway. Hipfire is when you shoot at the start of the day based on no evidence. A cop would have a report, so they have evidence. Since it's generally agreed upon that a town with a gun should a) consult with gunsmith, b) scum hunt, and c) talk about their shot, a maf hipfiring would be automatically scummy and not playing towards their win condition. It's basically outing oneself. And hipfire creates a situation where the town had less time to scumhunt, no time for GS or cop to establish themselves, and distracts from finding mafia. There is no way hipfiring as a town is helping your win condition, even if you are lucky and hit maf. It automatically makes you look suspicious and allows the real maf to hide in the chaos.
No. A law is a law, Sanctify. That's like saying, the white man who shot the black teen isn't GUILTY because it was self defense. Are you saying that he's above the law because it's a special exception?
The game cannot just flip to d1 like in Fronter Justice and sherif decides to HIPFIRE because THAT DOES NOTHING. You cold have shot the cops inno, the cop, the journalist. And even if you do shot mafia you're now losing possible partner tells that could have happened if that said person was alive AKA READS. How are you not comprehending this???
Betrayal you can use common sense and know that no rule or law is ever set in stone. Certain scenarios will alter the rule. IF COP IS GUNNED AND GETS A GUILTY THY CAN HIPIRE THE GUITY. IF ORC ORCS MAFIA AND THEY ARE NAKED TOWN CAN HIPFIRE THE GUILTY .
Do you not see how arrogant you are right now? You are judging me when you don't really know me. Anywho, I didn't say I was right about anything, I am speaking theoretically therefore what I say is different from what I believe.
he's stating that any mafia hipfiring is not a vio since they're playing towards their win condition, any townie shooting could be a vio especially if its baseless.
cop is playing towards town's win condition by hipfiring a guilty
Betrayal I knew you sucked at this game based off the few games I did play with you, however I didn't know you also suffered mental retardation. Do you not see how wrong you are right now?
Yes, I know but according to Ucklar, a cop is town sided therefore hipfiring as town is worthy of the violation. I agree with you but Ucklar does not. Ucklar believes any town who hipfires is not an exception to the rule, only mafia are.
For the most part, if most people have talked and the accused can come up with a plausible reason for shooting, it's fine. The only way its a violation is if you shoot so early in the day that it would be impossible to gather reads. The bottom line is you need to have at least a little bit of reasoning as to why you shot, and not just, "Oh, I have a gun. Yolo."
okay but you havent answered, what if I'm nilla and after saccing the COP n1, I decide to hipfire a townie and that townie was doc. Do I have to explain myself or is that gamethrowing and I deserve to be banned/vio for it? roflmao
There are always exceptions to rules~ The hipfiring rule only applies to townies shooting.
so how is a mafia hipfiring a townie any different from a townie hipfiring a mafia?
or a cop hipfiring a miller who was guilty?
a cop hipfiring a miller is not GTing bc the cop is using the resources hes given to play towards his win condition
whereas a townie hipfiring is GTing bc there's no substance to their fos. they just hipfired for no reason
For the most part, if most people have talked and the accused can come up with a plausible reason for shooting, it's fine. The only way its a violation is if you shoot so early in the day that it would be impossible to gather reads. The bottom line is you need to have at least a little bit of reasoning as to why you shot, and not just, "Oh, I have a gun. Yolo."
okay but you havent answered, what if I'm nilla and after saccing the COP n1, I decide to hipfire a townie and that townie was doc. Do I have to explain myself or is that gamethrowing and I deserve to be banned/vio for it? roflmao
There are always exceptions to rules~ The hipfiring rule only applies to townies shooting.
so how is a mafia hipfiring a townie any different from a townie hipfiring a mafia?
or a cop hipfiring a miller who was guilty?
deletedover 10 years
yeah betrayal *doesn't look up from book i'm reading* you should definitely stop hipfiring *doesn't make eye contact* heavens knows what would happen if you hit 8 vios