Back to Epicmafia

Is hipfiring gamethrowing?

about 10 years

Is hipfiring gamethrowing?

Why or why not? Discuss.

What if one hipfires correctly, should they be reported for gamethrowing?

And why does someone who hipfires incorrectly get in trouble with doing so when they were simply taking the risk that they would hipfire correctly and be rewarded for good behavior?

https://epicmafia.com/report/111188

Is hipfiring gamethrowing?
12
No
8
Yes
about 10 years
hipfiring was perfectly legal in the wild wild west. i never saw a town peasant complain about a cowboy shooting someone too quickly. what is inherently wrong about it? i say it's wrong when a blatant noob hipfires. but if an experienced player hipfires it's A-OK. i love hipfiring. it's so fun.

DON'T YOU ALL SEEK THE THRILL OF HIPFIRING A DIRTY HOOKER? don't put a stop to our desires for basic human emotions: thrill, and perhaps disappointment for being wrong but that's just part of the game.
part of the game
the game
game
me
e

bye ily
about 10 years
There are no options in the poll that are correct
about 10 years
It would have and still should have been game throwing even if a banned user filed the report it's still a flagrant game-throw. At the least the mod who handled the report could've open their own report against the player to give then the violation.
about 10 years
I was in a game where sheriff shot someone because they were "sick of this ", the player that got shot was mafia discussing a previous game.

Even though they correctly shot mafia, it actually helped the mafia and lead to a mafia win.

They were reported, I was interested to see the result, but the result was that banned users cannot file reports... so no result.
about 10 years

Betrayal says

Is hipfiring gamethrowing?

Why or why not? Discuss.

What if one hipfires correctly, should they be reported for gamethrowing?

And why does someone who hipfires incorrectly get in trouble with doing so when they were simply taking the risk that they would hipfire correctly and be rewarded for good behavior?


Yes because it plays against your wincon.

Yes, even if it is correct you still were playing against your wincon.

Hipfire? Good behavior? Really? You must have hit your head on something. HIPFIRING IS GAMETHROWING. GAMETHROWING IS NOT GOOD BEHAVIOR. THE RISK IS AWFULLY TOO HIGH.

To close this response I give you my definition of hipfire.

hipfire: To shoot someone with your gun without any information.

Cops with guilty shooting their guilty at the start of the day is NOT hipfire because they have information (their report). (This same goes for other information roles)

Mafia shooting at the start of the day is NOT hipfire because they have information (their team).

Vig shooting N1 IS hipfire because Night 1 the vig has no information at all.
about 10 years
Why would u hipfire if you feel the same about everyone?
The answer is you wouldn't and the game shouldn't be affected by what you're feeling.
about 10 years
Oh, okay I understand now Steven however Riddler knew exactly what I meant so he can go be a smartass in the complaint & reports section where he tends to reside.
about 10 years
Riddler is saying that cop with guilty cannot hipfire, because the fact that it is a guilty makes it by definition not a hipfire, which is the same thing you mean, Sanctify, but you still used the word hipfire, which is what Riddler is correcting you on
about 10 years
Once again, riddler did you read my post? Clearly not.
deletedabout 10 years
vondoom hipfires mafia, so no
about 10 years
Certain scenarios will alter the rule. IF COP IS GUNNED AND GETS A GUILTY THY CAN HIPIRE THE GUITY. IF ORC ORCS MAFIA AND THEY ARE NAKED TOWN CAN HIPFIRE THE GUILTY .
deletedabout 10 years
no1curr
about 10 years

Sanctify says

Riddler are you sane? Read to post I said it's hipfiring if it's the beginning of the game . If no one has spoken you have no information.... So it's hipfiring


>if cop is gunned and gets a guilty

that's not hipfiring. they have information.

if you're literally any other role EXCEPT roles that give you enough information to determine a shot via night action, you're gamethrowing by hipfiring
about 10 years
If u have gun n1 shoot the person with the most wins so u have a better chance of winning
about 10 years
Riddler are you sane? Read to post I said it's hipfiring if it's the beginning of the game . If no one has spoken you have no information.... So it's hipfiring
about 10 years
me hipfire who I think is maf , why ppl think u need proof to use item built into game what is this , trouble in terroist town ?
about 10 years

Sanctify says

Betrayal you can use common sense and know that no rule or law is ever set in stone. Certain scenarios will alter the rule. IF COP IS GUNNED AND GETS A GUILTY THY CAN HIPIRE THE GUITY. IF ORC ORCS MAFIA AND THEY ARE NAKED TOWN CAN HIPFIRE THE GUILTY .


it's not hipfiring if you have information
deletedabout 10 years
Towns hipfiring are obviously not playing towards their win condition. I don't see why it shouldn't be refunded.
about 10 years
Didn't * ^^^^
about 10 years
You're a good player we don't play 50 games more like 10. But you're clearly trolling.
about 10 years
also sanctify to tell u the truth i actually liked u and the 50+ games we played together, i looked up and respected u, its a shame u dont feel the same for me, bro
about 10 years
Stop.
about 10 years

Sanctify says

Stop posting


I can post in my own thread as I please.

You are the one trolling now.

Get off my turf, please or I'll hipfire you as self defense.
about 10 years
Stop posting
about 10 years

Sanctify says

The game cannot just flip to d1 like in Fronter Justice and sherif decides to HIPFIRE because THAT DOES NOTHING. You cold have shot the cops inno, the cop, the journalist. And even if you do shot mafia you're now losing possible partner tells that could have happened if that said person was alive AKA READS. How are you not comprehending this???


What about a setup where mafia has a gun and can also shoot? What if you don't shoot fast enough and get shot by mafia before you can shoot your gun? That's a lost opportunity. Sniper + Illusionist are roles that can shoot as maf.