I'll retract from the discussion now, I told you all what I think because 1) I think openness is very important 2) I wanted to avoid any 'oh which mod would have recommended gaf' speculations and 3) I feel bad for Gaf, I don't think he deserves this.
Last words, I am very sorry to see good 2 mods that want to quit this. I never expected that to happen. I don't think it's necessary either, because I truly think we could all work together in peace and fun. I'm sorry to see not all my mod colleagues seem to feel that way.
so you don't trust your predecessors? basically you're saying that you don't think the mods who worked on that case were right.
also regarding the fact that you ignored bronto's statement saying that any cheater (this includes anyone who received a cheating violation) is barred from becoming a mod
I'll retract from the discussion now, I told you all what I think because 1) I think openness is very important 2) I wanted to avoid any 'oh which mod would have recommended gaf' speculations and 3) I feel bad for Gaf, I don't think he deserves this.
Last words, I am very sorry to see good 2 mods that want to quit this. I never expected that to happen. I don't think it's necessary either, because I truly think we could all work together in peace and fun. I'm sorry to see not all my mod colleagues seem to feel that way.
Your opinion is almost worthless since you weren't there when the investigation was going on. The pastebin was strong enough evidence, there was evidence prior to that showing him cheating in training with the same user but went lost due to games being unspeccable.