@Satan - there are many like you, but it is an important skill- you always seem ineffective, everybody sees you as ineffective, even you know you are ineffective, BUT, you are not. You influence the whole thing and over 90% of the times the outcome depends on your actions alone. This is because you convey your thoughts with very few words. You have great communication skills basically. You are the average guy with very directed communication. You influence the whole town's vote with just one thing you say. The outcome is not negative for you though. It is positive. You are not the ineffective troll you appear. You are the unsung hero in many situations.
@TMJuke- I don't know if you do it on purpose or if it is involuntary, but you do have the amazing skill of getting into the nerves of other people. When you play mafia, you not only beat your opponents, you destroy their game. Be it in a game or forums, you are able to argue being one step ahead every time. Those who are experienced and have the patience, know how to deal with you. Dealing with you anywhere is a huge pain in the ***. It works for you when you have to beat any direct cc as either alignment. You do not attack the voters, you attack the opponent. A great example would be what you did to peta in this thread. He lost his mind and got carried away by your posts.
@Dezerie- You are one of the few users on this site who can see everything from different angles. Basically your thinking is broader than most others. You are able to consider all scenarios. Judging from the games you played, I can say that you do not jump to conclusions due to the things that appear. For example: you will not auto assume that a person is mafia if a dying cop has softed a guilty. You will think about the state of mind the cop was in and then make an informed decision unlike most others. You also do not take too much time to deduce conclusions while accumulating all the information. The crux is that your conclusions are better than others because you are ahead of the curve.
@Eris - You are a mediocre nothing special at mafia guy. You have no personality in a game. You always come around as someone who has no stake in anything and thus you stay under the radar. What you are good at is staying alive on forums without playing games and still now noticed as someone who does just forums. You have the skill that people like peta do not. You have the skill to appear normal.