Back to General Discussion

Top Ten Doctor Who Episodes

over 9 years

To all you lonely Whovians on EpicMafia...

...this thread is for you!

Here I rank my personal favorite Top Ten Doctor Who episodes of Series 1-7.

I will do a ranking of Series 8 when I am able to see all of it. (Spoiler Alert - Flatline and Listen are pretty high on the list!)


Spot 10: The God Complex

To kick off my list i thought I'd begin with somewhat of a contoversial choice...however I think this episode is one of Matt Smith's best.

The whole 1980's hotel setting adds to the tension and sense of dread evident throughout the episode. The characters are well defined, the pacing is solid, and it would have been an acceptable sendoff to Amy and Rory for good.

Spot 9: Rose

Of the 4 intro-to-the-doctor episodes, this one has a soft spot in my hear. It was MY FIRST episode of Doctor Who, even though it was a little bit goofy with the trash can scene.

What a way to start a show.

Spot 8: The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances

"Are you my mommy?"

shudders

Seriously, gas-mask zombies in WW2 is one of the scariest things Moffat has thought up, and he created the Weeping Angels!

So much character development, it felt like I was watching a full-length movie. Eccleston at his finest, Piper with Barrowman, this is how you make a piece of film/TV.

Just think that 11 is with Churchill at this time as well, and he knows exactly what is going on...

Spot 7: The Eleventh Hour

Oh Matt. What an episode to start on. It can only go down from here.

And it did. Regardless, this episode is so spooky. It introduces way more questions then it answers, but that's my favorite part about it. (why are there no ducks in the duck pond?"

Edges out "Rose" by the smallest of margins.

Spot 6: Dalek

This is how you make a Dalek story. Eccleston's scene with the beast is one of my favorite TV moments of all time. Van Statten makes for a menacing villain who is motivated by money. The only downside is that "DALEKS CAN FLY NOW? WHAT???"

Spot 5: Amy's Choice

The pure tension of who Amy chooses is wonderful. Also both realities are equally interesting, and Toby's performance as the Dream Lord is scarily good. All of the development, all of the monsters, it's stellar. Amy and Rory at their finest.

Spot 4: The Waters of Mars

This episode is scary. Plain hide-behind-the--couch scary. Having the Doctor know what will happen to everyone, and then HIM INTERFERING IN A FIXED POINT just shows how far he is willing to go to save a few lives. Acting is stellar, the threat is nervewracking, just an all around good episode.

Spot 3: Father's Day

This will certainly turn a few heads. I love this episode. The fact that it takes the age-old concept of going back to save someone you lost...and showing the consequences of that...I love this. Billie Piper in this is amazing as seeing her dad for the first time. The Doctor also acts as the one who has to play the bad cop, but you know he's right. The reapers were a lil' underwhelming tho...but that's just nitpicky. My favorite episode of the Eccleston era.

Spot 2: Blink

'WAT BLINK ISN'T NUMBER ONE UR CRAZY MYTHS WAT DO YOU DO WITH YOUR TIME'

Don't get me wrong, this is Moffat's best episode since...this. This defines the creepiness that Doctor Who is known for. Carey Mulligan stars as an amateur investigator whose friend goes missing, only statues are the clues. So creepy, well acted, it won the FREAKING HUGO AWARD! However, there is a story better...

Honorable Mentions

The Doctor's Wife

  • Neil Gaiman's Writing
  • Karen/Arthur's Acting
  • The TARDIS is hot

Cold War

  • Clara actually DOES something
  • The Ice Warrior redesign
  • Fast Pacing

AND THE NUMBER ONE BEST DOCTOR WHO EPISODE OF SEASONS 1 - 7 IS...

Don't.

Spot 1: Midnight

The tense, claustrophobic atmosphere really gets to you. Spending 40 minutes on that tin can is enough for me. Since the whole point of the episode is saying 'humans are the monsters' is chilling. Everything about this is scarily scary. AMAZING ACTING (yes that is Colin Morgan) just adds to the whole equation. The first time i watched this I couldn't sleep. imo, 'Blink' has the substance, but this has a distinct style which adds to the episode's greatness.


Well that's my list. Leave a comment on how you think it's wrong!

Who is your favorite Doctor of the new era?
10
David Tennant (10)
5
Christopher Eccleston (9)
5
Matt Smith (11)
2
Peter Capaldi (12)
deletedover 9 years
For me, it would be:

1. Series 4
2. Series 2
3. Series 3
4. Series 8
5. Series 5
6. Series 1
7. Series 6
8. Series 7
over 9 years
ooh we ranking series now? i'm gonna count 8 because i've seen pretty much all of it.
deletedover 9 years

kylehlp123 says

I think one of the most underrated episodes was Human Nature/The Family of Blood. It doesn't make my top 10 but nobody really talks about it in the conversation of one of the better doctor who episodes and I really think it deserves to be there


Made it 3rd in mine =D

The monsters were ridiculous but there was so much commentary on race/gender roles and I always love that side of the show. Now that I think about it, the third series didn't romanticize the places (in the past) it went like Doctor Who has a tendency of doing. I still like the fourth series better though. :P
over 9 years
over 9 years
I think one of the most underrated episodes was Human Nature/The Family of Blood. It doesn't make my top 10 but nobody really talks about it in the conversation of one of the better doctor who episodes and I really think it deserves to be there
over 9 years
Also the Lazarus experiment was interestingly bad. Other than that there aren't any episodes that I despise
over 9 years
One episode that I found so so boring was The Rebel Flesh/The almost people. Like thinking about it now, the storyline and all that should be really good cuz the concept of the episode is well crafted. Yet the episode just put me to sleep
over 9 years
the one with the big green blob that like eats all the people in the episode, I think that one is universally hated
over 9 years
yes i agree season five was a mixed bag, but amy's choice is really, well it's just an interesting episode. what's an episode you hate?
over 9 years
I mean it's great if you're like an english teacher that dissects Shakespeare and how a red curtain symbolizes agony or something like that. But in terms of how good of an episode it was, it was average like most of the matt smith episodes of the time
over 9 years
hrm...now that i think about it, it was better than rose, but not dalek or fathers day. all performances in fathers day were amasing, also amy's choice was a great character study episode
over 9 years
I don't see how in the world you could put the doctor dances behind 3 other eccelston episodes. I thought the two parter was undoubtedly his best work
over 9 years
I can see everything on your list being a potential top 10 except for Dalek and Amy's choice
over 9 years
over 9 years
Who???
over 9 years
oh that makes more sense now, I'm pretty sure I took up like an entire page on this forum detailing my top 10
over 9 years
kyle what's ur list then big boy
over 9 years
i have no idea what you just said
over 9 years
nah blink is actually really good, but my personal preference is the second episode of dr who i ever saw, not the 30th or so
over 9 years
I think people don't put blink number 1 because they think it's too cliche cuz everybody does it. But there's a reason everybody does it, I think that it's easily the best doctor who episode to exist in the new series
over 9 years
im still not impressed with the new doctor :{
over 9 years
wish i could swear on the forums : [
over 9 years
I haven't really seen the new season tho, only the first two episodes
over 9 years
hi there what would you like to talk about regarding doctor who
over 9 years
i'm just trying to keep this thread alive please people talk about this shite