This is my third attempt at creating a forum mafia game, I have decided that the previous ones have not received enough participation and hope that this one will.
If you decide to join please note that a mandatory 50 posts will be required within a 24 hour period. If I do not see that level of participation i will replace you.
man i honestly have no idea why i worded my post so badly but what i was trying to say was: -i made a weak read based on very little information near the start of the game. -wadanohara said that me making a weak read was scummy, and then made weak reads. -i am not calling him out for having weak reads, but rather for saying that weak reads are scummy when they're expected at this point in the game
if we're gonna replace people we should do it soon. it was horrible last game when scummy people just bounced halfway through the game and their replacements had to tryhard immediately to avoid getting lynched
I say if anyone with less than 10 posts (Memoji, poser, SteelixMega, NCRAW) doesn't pick it up asap we boot em
it seems odd to critique wadanohara for outing reads based on little information, when you did the same thing with your townread on mac/dex.
if you're saying your townread on mac/dex is only based on a few lines and could change, why are you calling out wadanohara for doing the same thing you're doing?
i didn't like his 50/50 read on take either, but his tone is reading town to me.
Well January, youre definitely proving my point on you probably not being town. If not for how overly defensive you are, your defense itself makes little to no sense.
First, calling me hypocritical, because of how weak my reads are seems to be the basis of your defense, but that is just a deflection, basically the equivant of, "Yeah, Im doing it but so are you!!" Which tends to be a more mafia mindset in an effort to get eyes off their own behavior. Also, the reasoning itself, "Your read is wrong because youre doing it too" really is?? Because whether you think my reads are weak or not is a matter of opinion. When I said your read was weak, I meant it lacked any sort of logic to me, it felt like a jump.
But, what do you mean about my reads? Because theyre based off one liners, etc? The game has just started, so I couldnt get any strong reads, I could only say what I thought indicated town or mafia behavior. Notice I never said I only fosd someone bc of filler, I said the way they were fillery came off as scummy to me. And I was going through people, trying to get my thoughts on each. I stopped short, because I was having difficulty reading bc everything got too fillery and not substantial, and I didnt want to make a giant post about that. I only put what popped out to me. I said Take was 50/50 because I wasnt ready to put any sort of commitment towards him. Not important, maybe, but I want to make my reads clear.
Another thing though. Do you think this is an indication that Im mafia or town?
deletedalmost 6 years
We back
deletedalmost 6 years
Hi guys I had a major accident yesterday putting this on pause for the moment
addressing your other reads, i feel like your reads on everyone besides me are weak as hell too
your reads on everyone besides me are all based on one line or being "upfront" with roles. being fillery can be scummy in normal games but considering that dylan asked us to filler, i don't think it's very alignment telling yet
you literally outed a read on take being 50/50 mafia which is useless and also seems there for the towncred
yes it is a pretty weak townread lol, having a strong townread here would be weird. i gave my initial reads on two people based on a very few lines, and they weren't meant to be definite lol -idk what you mean about "going along" with a mac read because im pretty sure the only other read outed on him was a sr by dex
