... if play on sandbox normal setup (7-3-2)
check the 2018 topic here https://epicmafia.com/topic/88515?page=3
Jailkeep: An advanced nurse is nice. B-
Comedian: Funny, can prove yourself is a plus, giving role information is good if choosing town but otherwise is meh, the randomness is quite hard to be useful. B, same tier as caroler
Soldier: Good luck having 1 town - who couldnt do anything more than a blue - left when sandbox game ends. D-
King: Sooo, the only bad blue now that could be in sandbox setup are gallis and trickster (40% chance of the blues). You can first test your vote, but maf may notice, so its quite hard for you to realize that ur king. S-
Commuter: Full of bugs, invincible , I wanted to put an S but it is actually a blue so C. nvm, without bugs this role can have a lot of niches, but not so strong. B-
Forager: Selfish than trickster, lamer than tinkerer. Not funny or powerful enough compared to the other two. C+, a tier below tinkerer but above Trickster
Robinhood: You can use this guy to check maf. You can know when people dont have items. And you can some how prove yourself. C-
Seer: With whisper in setup??? S++++++++++ Actually, with this role in setup game will have more messes. Also it may show as blue when dead, which is an auto win for maf. S+
Jack the ripper: "Needs to kill all murderers in the game after 1 full day has passed in the game". Seriously? F.
Vice president: A mastermind that cant win? F. Actually its fun to mess up maf. Still F.
Cat lady: Most of the time people will choose roleblock, and you show off your cat to them. At least you can make people veg. C
Gunslinger/sharpshooter: C-. The chance people shooting you is not that high.
Recruit: A maf partner that cant do shiiiit after 3 nights. D
Friendly cop: B, same tier as other cop. You also need to confirm your sanity too
Snow Queen: Lame, A+, can be used in many ways
Demobomb: This is like a better trapper, plus theres not many towns killing at night. Playing this is like playing monk, require some guesses. You can even choose yourself lol. B-, higher than bg, trapper, doc and nurse
Cyclist: Yeah you mess up meetings for what. You are town, not maf. May be it will flip some kill or help you steal gun from celeb. C+ for high potential
Whistleblower: Sadly there is no fake tree strategy otherwise this would be in high tier. Auto win in lylo, force mylo into lylo, can save teammate and many other tricks can be used . A+
Avenger: Its quite hard to guess whos dying. Ur playing like a doc. C+
Butler: Lame. D
Gossiper: Not really useful. C
Housekeeper: Looks like you can use the ability more than once. C+
Usurper: winable 3rd. Stop maf from winning too. Should be around A-
Queen bee: Bugs creator that will fuk every other players up. I dont know if it can choose maf. If it can, S-. I will put it A for now
Rainmaker: Skip day lynch, ok ... S-
Supervillian: It's unfair for other 3rds when this one win condition is much easier. The average win rate for 3rds is about 20%. Sad. S
Party smacker: if not counting bugs, this is a really bad role. E
So in summary:
S+: Seer
S: Superbad3rd
S-: King, Rainmaker
A+: Snow Queen, Whistleblower
A: Queen bee
A-: Usurper
B: Comedian, Friendly cop
B-: Jailkeep, Demobomb, Commuter
C+: Forager, Cyclist, Avenger, Housekeeper
C: Cat lady, Gossiper
C-: Gunslinger, Sharpshooter, Robinhood
D: Butler
D-: Soldier
E: Partysmacker
F: Recruit, Jack, Vice president
