Back to Forum Games

The Resistance Game 4

matt
about 7 years

It seems this game has gained a lot of popularity in this lobby, and I want to see what it's like as the host.

All 3 of the games played thus far have ended in evil being victorious. So as per the idea of HighSpace, I will incorporate an extra servant to the game making it 7 good, 4 evil.

This will decrease the chances of placing evil members on missions and increase the Merlin pool for Assassin to shoot in.

6 players are needed to accept or reject any mission

Rules and guidelines are here: https://goo.gl/JhSwPT

Game Status:

Score: 3-2 Good, Assassin missed Merlin, good wins!

Mission #1 (3 players needed)

  • Attempt #1:

    • Leader: Ripple
    • Members: Ripple, HighSpace, bryce1997
    • Accepted or Rejected: Rejected (HighSpace, colester112, arisuu, tillie, stashio833, powerofdeath)
    • Pass or Fail: n/a

  • Attempt #2:

    • Leader: freshman
    • Members: freshman, tillie, powerofdeath
    • Accepted or Rejected: Rejected (bryce1997, HighSpace, Jeff, arisuu, stashio833, powerofdeath)
    • Pass or Fail: n/a

  • Attempt #3:

    • Leader: stashio833
    • Members: stashio833, powerofdeath, Jeff
    • Accepted or Rejected: Accepted (colester112, tillie, Jeff, Ripple, bryce1997, qrstuv)
    • Pass out Fail: PASS

Mission #2 (4 players needed)

  • Attempt #1:

    • Leader: arisuu
    • Members: arisuu, stashio833, powerofdeath, Jeff
    • Accepted or Rejected: Rejected (Ripple, HighSpace, qrstuv, bryce1997, stashio833, colester112)
    • Pass or Fail: n/a

  • Attempt #2

    • Leader: qrstuv
    • Members: qrstuv, powerofdeath, HighSpace, Jeff
    • Accepted or Rejected: Accepted (Ripple, powerofdeath, arisuu, colester112, HighSpace, qrstuv)
    • Pass or Fail: FAIL

Mission #3 (4 players needed)

  • Attempt #1:
    • Leader: powerofdeath
    • Members: qrstuv, powerofdeath, Jeff, bryce1997
    • Accepted or Rejected: Accepted (colester112, powerofdeath, bryce1997, Jeff, tillie, qrstuv)
    • Pass or Fail: FAIL

Mission #4 (5 players needed, 2 fail slips needed to fail)

  • Attempt #1:

    • Leader: HighSpace
    • Members: HighSpace, Ripple, qrstuv, tillie, colester112
    • Accepted or Rejected: Rejected (arisuu, stashio833, colester112, powerofdeath, Jeff, qrstuv
    • Pass or Fail: n/a

  • Attempt #2:

    • Leader: tillie
    • Members: tillie, Ripple, Spadez0, qrstuv, Jeff
    • Accepted or Rejected: Accepted (arisuu, Ripple, colester112, qrstuv, tillie, HighSpace)
    • Pass or Fail: PASS

Mission #5 (5 players needed)

  • Attempt #1:

    • Leader: Jeff
    • Members: Jeff, Ripple, arisuu, qrstuv, colester112
    • Accepted or Rejected: Rejected (tillie, qrstuv, HighSpace, arisuu, Ripple, Spadez0)
    • Pass or Fail: n/a

  • Attempt #2:

    • Leader: bryce1997
    • Members: bryce1997, Ripple, arisuu, tillie, Jeff
    • Accepted or Rejected: n/a
    • Pass or Fail: n/a

Good passes due to game being compromised, but a 24 hour buffer is allowed for scum to discuss.

FFSierraDamnThomas shoots tillie and is wrong.

Spadez
about 7 years

matt says

honestly being as unbiased as possible, i thought stashio was blatant scum the moment they posted. tried way too hard to sound town.

anyways, as promised some feedback.


Mm, which is why I was bussing them so hard lol.
HighSpace
about 7 years
I'm really curious what arisuu was trying to do with the whole percival claim. Also fishing for merlin LOL
matt
about 7 years
honestly being as unbiased as possible, i thought stashio was blatant scum the moment they posted. tried way too hard to sound town.

anyways, as promised some feedback.
Spadez
about 7 years
That's one thing I'm slightly sad about. If stash didn't gt, there would've been a smol chance I was brought to M5.

So I'm like irejhuifrejhieru

Also, I find this situation really funny cuz I thought ripple was Merlin when I saw how they reacted to Pod initially. But then when I saw Till, I completely forgot about the idea of Ripple being Merlin so igerwjgioewrjgrweio.

So after 5 seconds of thinking Ripple was Merlin, Till took over the rest of that timeline xD
HighSpace
about 7 years
Ripple is the reason my scumread on stashio was so strong since the start
HighSpace
about 7 years
well, spadez did have a chance to get in mission 5. I don't know if it would've happened, cause my ideal team before stash gamethrew was me/jeff/qrs/ripple/tillie. However, I wasn't the one that was gonna make the final team
powerofdeath
about 7 years

Jeff says


matt says

It's pretty hard not to flop when someone outs the entire scum team.


they didn't even have merlin in their pool tho


Thats because ripple did a good job by not really helping the town at all beside the fact that she avoided assassin. This wouldve been a scum victory in a situation where scum team arent flops.
Jeff
about 7 years

matt says

It's pretty hard not to flop when someone outs the entire scum team.


they didn't even have merlin in their pool tho
powerofdeath
about 7 years
My only mistake was probably including bryce in mission #3. I brought him down with me for absolutely no reasons.
powerofdeath
about 7 years
I mean I alone basically caused 2 failures, and was hoping my team would carry that last fail. Half of us were replaced out and one of us gamethrew, rip
matt
about 7 years
It's pretty hard not to flop when someone outs the entire scum team.
Jeff
about 7 years
evil flopped lol
matt
about 7 years
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EIeuNZ0nCkg

Sorry to the evil team, but tillie was not the Merlin you were looking for! It was Ripple!!! Good wins their first game!!! Thoughts on the whole game and feedback soon to come but lemme extend my apologies to the evil team because this was very likely going to be a win for them!
matt
about 7 years


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OJSCnWKq3Bw
matt
about 7 years


Should pod have trusted his initial instincts? Find out soon!
matt
about 7 years
It is revealed that arisuu and Jeff are both Servants of Arthur.

This means either Ripple or tillie is the Merlin.

Did evil win for a fourth time?

You'll soon find out.
matt
about 7 years
It is revealed that qrstuv and colester112 are Servants of Arthur, and that HighSpace is in fact the Percival.
matt
about 7 years
Alright.
FFSierraDamnThomas
about 7 years
Agreed with the above and I think tillie's reactions since the outing have kinda made it seem like they could be it (not trying to not speak at all as if they're purposefully resisting giving any further reads but also not really mentioning too much). I assassinate tillie.
powerofdeath
about 7 years
Alright I think us 3 kinda all agree on tillie then, safest shot. If it isnt, meh game was compromised anyway. We wouldve had it with spadez potentially getting involved in mission 5.
powerofdeath
about 7 years

Spadez0 says

Sigh, I'm too tired to complicate this so I'll jest out my reads x.x

So mai Merlin read rests between Till/Ari/Jeff.

Till was mai original Merlin read considering how they reacted to Pod earlier on in the game. Also:


tillie says

i reject cos idk why jeff would make a completely different team when we had all 5 passes, although i still am sus of spadez. the fact that ppl r still playing after being called out leads me to believe that stashio didn't tell the complete truth about whos scum so


Considering the fact that I'm Mordred and Merlin wouldn't know me, that statement makes Till a really big Merlin read for me.

Ari was mai Merlin read in the middle of the game who was attempting a roleswap with the perc.

However, from both perc claims, High only mentioned the fact that they thought Pod was roleswapping with them. High never considered Ari roleswapping as Merlin. Keeping in mid that Perc knows Merlin and Morgana, I don't think Ari is Merlin.

Jeff is mai latest Merlin read because of their reaction towards Stash outing the Mafia list. Only Merlin would know how accurate or inaccurate that list was. Jeff's reaction clearly indicated that they knew Stash gt'ed.

Also, if thou look at how high reacted to Jeff throughout the game, Jeff seems very Merlin-y.

In conclusion, I think the Merlin is between Till and Jeff.


Jeff isnt merlin because of mission 2 + 3, plus Highspace interaction aka letting me include potential morgana for 2 missions in a row
Spadez
about 7 years
I still think Merlin is between Till and Jeff for reasons stated above somewhere
Spadez
about 7 years

matt says

Alright everyone, I'm making a judgment call here. Unfortunately my game has been compromised and someone revealed their entire team as seen by all four of its members hard claiming scum. There's no need to go through the motions of getting Mission 5 to pass, so what I'm going to do is allow the scum team to deliberate for 24 more hours and then the thread will be locked until FFSierraDamnThomas shoots. If anyone has a problem with this please PM me but I think it's a fair call to make.


Welp, I guess that's that. Rip to this thread.
matt
about 7 years
Alright everyone, I'm making a judgment call here. Unfortunately my game has been compromised and someone revealed their entire team as seen by all four of its members hard claiming scum. There's no need to go through the motions of getting Mission 5 to pass, so what I'm going to do is allow the scum team to deliberate for 24 more hours and then the thread will be locked until FFSierraDamnThomas shoots. If anyone has a problem with this please PM me but I think it's a fair call to make.
Spadez
about 7 years
Sigh, I'm too tired to complicate this so I'll jest out my reads x.x

So mai Merlin read rests between Till/Ari/Jeff.

Till was mai original Merlin read considering how they reacted to Pod earlier on in the game. Also:


tillie says

i reject cos idk why jeff would make a completely different team when we had all 5 passes, although i still am sus of spadez. the fact that ppl r still playing after being called out leads me to believe that stashio didn't tell the complete truth about whos scum so


Considering the fact that I'm Mordred and Merlin wouldn't know me, that statement makes Till a really big Merlin read for me.

Ari was mai Merlin read in the middle of the game who was attempting a roleswap with the perc.

However, from both perc claims, High only mentioned the fact that they thought Pod was roleswapping with them. High never considered Ari roleswapping as Merlin. Keeping in mid that Perc knows Merlin and Morgana, I don't think Ari is Merlin.

Jeff is mai latest Merlin read because of their reaction towards Stash outing the Mafia list. Only Merlin would know how accurate or inaccurate that list was. Jeff's reaction clearly indicated that they knew Stash gt'ed.

Also, if thou look at how high reacted to Jeff throughout the game, Jeff seems very Merlin-y.

In conclusion, I think the Merlin is between Till and Jeff.