Maybe for scubs like you, frontier justice is the best setup to farm because people are dumb and don't understand how to play it.
GentIeman says xxerox says GentIeman says PonyLove says 1-2% difference is not much adventage or disadantage. 6% is overkill.
xxerox says GentIeman says PonyLove says Good setups are balanced out to where scum has the advantage. Otherwise its a bad setup imo.
xxerox says Only 2 or 3 people are winning instead of 5-7. Someone isn't going to roll mafia 10 times in a row. But someone can roll town 10 times in a row. If you can't play a good town and fall into the 57% losing category, then you aren't very good anyway.
GentIeman says Like Pony said. Mafia usually has slight adventage.
PonyLove says Note on the slightly. 53 - 54% win for mafia is ok.. But 56% is plain scumsided unbalanced setup.
xxerox says https://epicmafia.com/setup/672315 except for the other 43% of the time
Lets try this again:
In all 3 setups you posted, the mafia has the higher advantage...
https://epicmafia.com/setup/672315 Frontier justice
43/56
after 7k plays.
UNBALANCED.
This is more like flipping a coin. If you flip mafia : WOHOO FREE WIN!
https://epicmafia.com/setup/132122 Janitorial
48/51
after 30k plays.
Again balanced.
xxerox says https://epicmafia.com/setup/731112 so is flipping a coin
Cry n' Spy
https://epicmafia.com/setup/471195 48/51
after 5000 plays.
This again is balanced.
xxerox says you got it
https://epicmafia.com/setup/731112 Holywood Illusions
49/50
after 7000 plays.
THIS is balanced.
So now mafia should have the handicap of winning over town...
deleted over 7 years
PatrykSzczescie says yes
xxerox says There's less mafia so they should get the handicap.
With town winning every time, the only impact is that more players win.
Lono, you copy pasted that old rule, just changed three to five in one place and included that trophies can be won consecutively, but the rest was left out-of-date.
Well, yeah, but i mafia wins every time and just hoard points at 57% . . .
PonyLove you have not a single clue
There are more town members than maf members in a game. Not everything is supposed to be equal.
Most competitive setups are generally slightly more scum sided. Setups with higher town win ratios than maf ratios are town sided for comp. That's why the ratios are different.
Either make it 57% for town too or 55% for mafia too, or there won't be a point to the rule.
PonyLove says But that is just picking sides. You are picking mafia to win more games rather than town :/
They should have EQUAL chances to win. Not a table where mafia wins almost every time, but when town does, to be banned.
