over 8 years

I need to make a list of players who are not noobs.

Noobs are those who do not understand basic mechanics

Noobs are those who do not know what is optimal

Noobs are those who bus for no reason

Noobs are those who don't know what their next move will be

Noobs are those who have no contingency plans and give up too easily

People already know other traits of noobs. Whoever isn't a noob is a pro.

Please post. If I don't already know you, then you might have to share a game evidence.

List

Soda Nown Giga Kerry Dave Slow Iceaac Riot Shivv Devante Zhuorb Author PatrykSzczesci Dzanek Sims Bacde PINKIEPIE

deletedover 8 years
I would like to volunteer for the list.

I feel my stats may speak for themselves. If that doesn't convince you, then just gaze upon my glorious avatar.
over 8 years
hullo pick me ;)
over 8 years

panthero says

I'll simplify it for you guys. How can you convey your report to only the orc such that mafia is not able to kill the inno.


is orc known to the mafia to?
over 8 years
nice list but

panthero says

Noobs are those who bus for no reason


is not necessarily true imo

edit: depends on the specifics and what you consider bussing, as well as waht you'd qualify as a "reason."
over 8 years
Tfw my alt is also put in the list - double pro.
over 8 years

Goodbar says

actually maybe i was wrong.

if person 1 has an inno report and person 2 and 3 aren't reported, the possible outcomes for the clear are:
blue 1, miller 2, scum 3
blue 1, scum 3, miller 2
scum 1, miller 2, blue 3
scum 1, blue 2, miller 3
so 50% chance of 1 being scum and 25% chance of the other two

if person 2 is clear (or self-perspective from three way lylo), then:
blue 1, miller 2, scum 3
scum 1, miller 2, blue 3
scum 1, blue 2, miller 3
so a non reported town member would see 67% chance of the reported being scum since there are less scenarios that involve him being town.

none of these are overwhelming odds but hey, if that's your last logical resort and you're in a gridlock, i suppose it doesn't hurt to see them



thanks for the breakdown. i didn't really believe myself the other day when i tried to convince the other blue that gf was being gf with "he's inno he has a higher chance of being gf than both of us!" as an excuse. turns out i wasn't wrong.
over 8 years
actually maybe i was wrong.

if person 1 has an inno report and person 2 and 3 aren't reported, the possible outcomes for the clear are:
blue 1, miller 2, scum 3
blue 1, scum 3, miller 2
scum 1, miller 2, blue 3
scum 1, blue 2, miller 3
so 50% chance of 1 being scum and 25% chance of the other two

if person 2 is clear (or self-perspective from three way lylo), then:
blue 1, miller 2, scum 3
scum 1, miller 2, blue 3
scum 1, blue 2, miller 3
so a non reported town member would see 67% chance of the reported being scum since there are less scenarios that involve him being town.

none of these are overwhelming odds but hey, if that's your last logical resort and you're in a gridlock, i suppose it doesn't hurt to see them
deletedover 8 years
It is 33% then with unknown miller
over 8 years

Author says

He has 50/50 chance of being mafia. One of the other blues is miller.



Goodbar says

if you're in lylo then your perspective is 50:50 anyway so it's a meaningless statistic for you


ok, let's change the original scenario. let's add a pr for a 4 way where town is forced to lynch. would the statistic be of any importance then? (assuming you're the pr)
over 8 years
I never use maths to find mafia
over 8 years
if you're in lylo then your perspective is 50:50 anyway so it's a meaningless statistic for you
deletedover 8 years
An inno is 50/50. But since there are three blue claims it is 33% when miller is unknown.
deletedover 8 years
He has 50/50 chance of being mafia. One of the other blues is miller.
over 8 years
noob math question, putting it out here so hopefully the pros can answer it for me. in a 3 way with godfather, blue and miller, person A was inno'd by cop. does he by any means have a higher chance of being maf than the other two?
deletedover 8 years
he is the pro
over 8 years
i am the pro
over 8 years
I'll simplify it for you guys. How can you convey your report to only the orc such that mafia is not able to kill the inno.
over 8 years
lmfao
over 8 years
You left me out!!!!
over 8 years
aladrew it's already assumed you're on the list dude
deletedover 8 years
why am i not added i am best pro
over 8 years
Orc is already known. That is how you don't have inno on orc.
over 8 years

panthero says

I think you can solve it. Tell me a way to get your inno into 3 way. That is what I'm looking for. Or someone may have a better solution than I do.


l

Well obviously if you can get your inno to become uncc'd Orc, but I don't know how tbh.

It would be easy if there were whispers
over 8 years
honestly its probably something like making your inno claim orc so maf won't ever kill him

edit: sorry in a overwatch game, btw im complaining that you made the premise for your riddles dumb
over 8 years
I think you can solve it. Tell me a way to get your inno into 3 way. That is what I'm looking for. Or someone may have a better solution than I do.