Back to Forum Games

Forum Mafia 16

over 8 years

Hey guys welcome to Forum Mafia 16 with your hosts Sonia and Gerry! sign up below (kudos to mist for using her rules thing)

The Mafia have won!

I. The Schedule:

72 hour days and 24 hour nights.

If the majority of night actions have not been submitted by the end of the night, I will extend the night another 12 hours. This will only occur once per night at most.

II. The Setup:

(Changes from previous forum mafia games are in bold)

  • Normal closed roles setup, as always, with the roles and affixes listed below

  • By default there are no Night 1 actions, including the mafia kill.

  • By default no role can self visit, except watcher.

  • Players are always notified at day start if their role is changed.

  • Players who share a meeting may communicate outside the game at any time of day. **

  • One mafia makes the kill each night. They will be the only one to visit the target.

  • On death, players flip their full role by default.

  • Members of the mafia may both make their role action as well as the factional kill on the same night.

III. The Roles:

http://pastebin.com/w0LTVjV7

IV. The Rules:

http://pastebin.com/w9AJgZPR

Please note the addition of the Twilight phase (in short, discussion after the hammer has occurred is now allowed until I am present to begin the night phase). Also, supermajority rules are in effect with no time limit. also

Editing your posts is not allowed. Use the EBWOP function (Edit By Way of Post) if you need to restate something or fix a spelling error.

V. Game Mechanics:

Meetings between players (mafia, masons, templars) will be facilitated in whatever way is most convenient for the players, as long as I can access these communications. Skype, Discord, QuickTopics, or Private Messages which include the moderators are all fine. Votes must be made in the format Vote: Playername. Bolding is done using the tags [b][/b].

deletedover 8 years
if it were just that you had a hard time getting good reads that'd be fine but it seems like you feel obligated to give and push reads that you don't have
over 8 years
I'm finding it very hard to get decent SRs with decent reasoning so i am afraid you will be victim to my infamously stupid gut until you start towntelling lol
over 8 years

justdance666 says


Impoetic says

f.ck it 'm just gonna omgus. Vote: Justdance666

i'll think about it later :\


if you were me would you see this as a legitimate read


I see your point... except that you said my reads were illegitimate before I made that post.
over 8 years
Voting Log 2.3

(L-6) N1ed -
(L-6) mist -
(L-4) justdance666 - Mori, Impoetic
(L-6) UltraAug -
(L-6) JeffreyAaron -
(L-6) Mori -
(L-4) Impoetic - justdance666, Solace
(L-4) Solace - mist, UltraAug
(L-6) papuito -
(L-6) PonyLove -

Not Voting: N1ed, papuito, JeffreyAaron, PonyLove

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch! If 6 isn't reached it will be considered a No Lynch

Day Two ends May 17th, 11:59 PM ET or if a lynch is reached.

Town is currently set to: No Lynch
deletedover 8 years

Impoetic says

f.ck it 'm just gonna omgus. Vote: Justdance666

i'll think about it later :\


if you were me would you see this as a legitimate read
over 8 years
I hated the way pony was playing victim and the "I want to live" thing felt selfish. If you join a game, play to your wincon. There was something along the lines of ate and dumbtelling that made me feel exactly that way about her.
over 8 years

Solace says

Impoetic's lines are more theatrical and appears to be geared towards presenting a 'towny' impression instead of genuinely looking for mafia:


Impoetic says


jesus christ. I hate your play this game with a passion and I will be so salty if you're doing this as mafia



I don't see why a town would say this. I don't buy that someone would feel this way.

vote impoetic




Let me inform you of something: a town would and did say that. Get a better read.
over 8 years
or one can be like me and paraphrase it but put it in quotes anyway. You said you didn't believe my reads were legitimate.
over 8 years
well uh

ive made up my mind

this was null read most all the game but now all i have are null and town and people say pap is town so im just going to

http://vocaroo.com/i/s1xXihTtk4si

vote solace

slight bias but whatever ive got nothing better
deletedover 8 years

Impoetic says

There's the question of whether Justdance's read of "my reads being forced" is genuine or not. I'm obviously biased so could anyone provide input on this?


quotes are generally for things people say
over 8 years
Solace, if Pony is maf with anyone, it would be with Ultra. There's no way Ultra and Pony aren't the same alignment, since Ultra, as a PR claim, confirmed Pony and soda are the same alignment.

If Ultra was maf claiming PR and Pony was town regardless, then it makes no sense for Ultra to "clear" her if they aren't the same alignment; especially when practically everyone in the game was scumreading Pony and willing to vote her.

Are you guys even reading this game?
over 8 years

N1ed says


i still dont like having pony on my town list but ultra is towny enough to where i can believe it and that gut feeling agrees



"I dont like having ____ on my town list"

N1ed is towntelling rly hard atm. Complaining about your townreads isn't something mafia does.

altho i think the townread on ultra is wrong. I'd vote either impoe or ultra. probably 1 mafia between impoe / pony. If impoe/pony were maf together they'd probably collectively push on another player instead of spending the days arguing about who knows what
over 8 years
hello

I skimmed through a few of N1ed's lines and still think they're town. This was a good line:


N1ed says


and i really want to believe that you rolled "villager"



That's going above and beyond to challenge (or question) another player that submissive mafia wouldn't think of saying.

Impoetic's lines are more theatrical and appears to be geared towards presenting a 'towny' impression instead of genuinely looking for mafia:


Impoetic says


jesus christ. I hate your play this game with a passion and I will be so salty if you're doing this as mafia



I don't see why a town would say this. I don't buy that someone would feel this way.

vote impoetic
deletedover 8 years
i still dont like having pony on my town list but ultra is towny enough to where i can believe it and that gut feeling agrees

its just the content that makes me wonder
deletedover 8 years
okay I lied idk if im actually gonna work on that

IM STILL PROCRASTINATING ON THINGS I HAVE TO DO FOR TOMORROW FML
deletedover 8 years

JeffreyAaron says

Ok N1ed then who is mafia


while I'm working on that, let me tell you who ISN'T mafia:
UltraAug
PonyLove
Impoetic

that's not a very big list not that I'm looking at it but if we're voting together, than I just got rid of half the game your move

hey wait if I'm right on all of these than I have either a 1/3 or a 1/2 chance of getting a mafia today wew
over 8 years
Also, I would very much like a votelog.
over 8 years

Impoetic says

aww thanks guys <3 I just hope my townpool isn't mafia white knighting me right now

The solace sr is one i'm not very confident in. He has been sorta towny sometimes




Honestly, look. Solace knows how to look really towny, at least in regular mafia. At the moment he's null to me, but it's something to take into consideration. Imo he started off really well but then got progessively worse.
over 8 years
I've been meaning to reread and get back to you with better reads but :|
over 8 years
aww thanks guys <3 I just hope my townpool isn't mafia white knighting me right now

The solace sr is one i'm not very confident in. He has been sorta towny sometimes
over 8 years
Ok N1ed then who is mafia
over 8 years
Cut Impoetic some slack. Everyone SR'd both PonyLove and even UltraAug at some point and Impoetic was one of the only who was willing to reconsider or TR PonyLove. Even when she was really scummy, which she was.
over 8 years

JeffreyAaron says

Jk just got to page 44..... Pap I thought you SR Mori and I?


I'm not sure Pap ever SR'd me, I remember him TRing me even when he was my main FOS
deletedover 8 years
i would say to take the few votes off of impoetic, because I don't think she's given any specific reason to be read as scum and it seems kind of bitter if that's the right word

im probably going to have to make a good reads list today or tomorrow and today might be hard because I'll be just a tad busy so uh yeah idk
deletedover 8 years
well I suppose this took a turn since last we left

what's with the votes on impoetic? i can't really read into her under pressure because I don't think ive specifically seen her under voting pressure but i read a lot of this as town because this is completely different than the lovers mafia game

also mist and impoetic are right and I was actually really surprised at my lovers mafia gameplay, but i feel like if you compare it to any of my town games (thank god I finally rolled mafia in a game so you guys can fckin compare it), you can probably get somewhat of a meta read on this game and like yeah

okay so, for starters I don't really like how people are flipping this over to impoetic just because she scum read a scummy town. let's fix that

also jeffrey that was a towny thing but like???? fix ya damn votes