over 8 years

does this exist and is it against the rules

this isn't a gotcha! topic i actually wanna know what ppl think

over 8 years
deletedover 8 years

N1ed says


Pinche says

any n1 kill against me is a grudge kill and will be reported as such.


scenario:
player 1 clearly doesn't like player 2
player 1 rolls mafia
"Player 2, the cop (or other important role), has died."
player 2 reports for grudge killing
"but he rolled cop!!!!"
alternatively
"n1 kill is always random!1!1!1!"

i don't think player 1 is able to get a vio there because grudge killing is a dumb reason to report. just join a different game or report for lobby camping if you can't.


You know its not only 1 time but more !
he has 2 accounts his been on and doing it.
and i even told him to stop it!!! but no its really funny for him to n1 everytime.
I really dont give a shi't about me being the cop or not i wouldnt report someone because of that
deletedover 8 years
Again, it isn't about restricting n1 kills at all. You're completely missing what I said.
deletedover 8 years
this thread should be nuked
deletedover 8 years

harodihg says

Suggesting the mods step in and try to stop someone from n1ing the same person every time they roll mafia by getting them to let their partner pick the kill is vastly different from doling out violations lol.


noah offense but i don't think you understand any of the arguments presented against your claim
deletedover 8 years
Suggesting the mods step in and try to stop someone from n1ing the same person every time they roll mafia by getting them to let their partner pick the kill is vastly different from doling out violations lol.
deletedover 8 years

Pinche says

any n1 kill against me is a grudge kill and will be reported as such.


scenario:
player 1 clearly doesn't like player 2
player 1 rolls mafia
"Player 2, the cop (or other important role), has died."
player 2 reports for grudge killing
"but he rolled cop!!!!"
alternatively
"n1 kill is always random!1!1!1!"

i don't think player 1 is able to get a vio there because grudge killing is a dumb reason to report. just join a different game or report for lobby camping if you can't.
deletedover 8 years
any n1 kill against me is a grudge kill and will be reported as such.
over 8 years
WHY IT'S A COMP GAME
over 8 years
over 8 years
The answer is yes btw, yes they should be. if u disagree you are no different than mr. harodigh
over 8 years

Devante says


hardeffingworker says


harodihg says

If you disagree with me you're wrong, so instead of posting more contrarian nonsense figure out why you're wrong and correct your thinking.


suggesting that mafia should be able to make whatever night kills they want isn't contrarian at all


precisely why the meteor rule should be changed, if it hasn't already been changed for the millionth time


that's completely different since it's letting mafia exploit the meteor mechanic in order to kill clear/pr when they shouldn't be able to
over 8 years
imagine i reignite the is-mafia-allowed-to-kill-the-clear-with-doc-alive flame with that one post
over 8 years

hardeffingworker says


harodihg says

If you disagree with me you're wrong, so instead of posting more contrarian nonsense figure out why you're wrong and correct your thinking.


suggesting that mafia should be able to make whatever night kills they want isn't contrarian at all


precisely why the meteor rule should be changed, if it hasn't already been changed for the millionth time
deletedover 8 years

harodihg says

If you disagree with me you're wrong, so instead of posting more contrarian nonsense figure out why you're wrong and correct your thinking.


suggesting that mafia should be able to make whatever night kills they want isn't contrarian at all
over 8 years

jana says

n1 ling everytime

deletedover 8 years

johnreid says

If you want something more concrete and logical as to why you can't restrict n1 kills.

If someone has been "warned" to not grudge kill someone anymore, that is OGI in itself and will result in meta reading based on kill.

If I am compelled not to lynch someone, if I am lynched as Mafia that person becomes a clear.

Conversely if said person does die n1, I am meta clear because of the OGI that I would be reported if I had n1ed the person.


this is actually a fairly strong point
deletedover 8 years
It has never, and shouldn't ever in the future, be against the rules to continuously n1 someone. Hope this helps.
over 8 years
If you want something more concrete and logical as to why you can't restrict n1 kills.

If someone has been "warned" to not grudge kill someone anymore, that is OGI in itself and will result in meta reading based on kill.

If I am compelled not to lynch someone, if I am lynched as Mafia that person becomes a clear.

Conversely if said person does die n1, I am meta clear because of the OGI that I would be reported if I had n1ed the person.
over 8 years
n1 ling everytime
over 8 years
Thanks mclove
over 8 years
Killing someone repeatedly n1 is not a vio , you people are a joke for even discussing it.

Just kill the other person back when you are Mafia.
over 8 years
Grudge lynching is gt cause its not playing to your win condition but if u kill someone u dont like its not playing against your win condition
over 8 years
Funny you mention this. Once I got reported and noted for NIGHT TWO killing Leo 5 times in one day. He was outed PR 4/5 times.
deletedover 8 years
No Violation