Back to Epicmafia

Round 378 Discussion

Gerry
almost 10 years

Congratulations to the winners of Round 373!

Merry Christmas & Happy holidays from the EM moderator team!

sly

Setups

Body

Setups

banned

Setups

Good luck to the participants of Round 378!

Join the competition!!

Giga13
almost 10 years

Kronk says

How about we get rid of the rules tab altogether?
*bad gif*


"Well if you're into anarchy, then sure I guess"

- The user formerly known as 'LetzShake' - 2015
deletedalmost 10 years
no me.
Giga13
almost 10 years
Now give me a spot on your mod squad so that one day I can fulfill one of my New York Resolutions and be demoted promoted to admin of EpicMafia
Kronk
almost 10 years
How about we get rid of the rules tab altogether?
Devante
almost 10 years

Giga13 says

Meta Abuse should be a subsection of Cheating since that's pretty much what it is; 4 is too lenient and one per game is far too strict since in order for the rule to be broken, it generally has to happen across a series of games. You could get a note for the first offense, then subsequent violations could become Cheating violations via Meta Abuse and would just follow the Cheating infringements


this is actually a good idea.
deletedalmost 10 years

Devante says


Fidelis says

f u devante


<3 <3


gross
deletedalmost 10 years
Yeah if meta abuse is constant over a round. Then yeah it should be given a cheating vio.
Devante
almost 10 years

Fidelis says

f u devante


<3 <3
Giga13
almost 10 years
Meta Abuse should be a subsection of Cheating since that's pretty much what it is; 4 is too lenient and one per game is far too strict, since, in order for the rule to be broken, it generally has to happen across a series of games. You could get a note for the first offense, then subsequent violations could be Cheating violations ("via Meta Abuse" would go in the verdict) and would just follow the Cheating infringements
deletedalmost 10 years
f u devante
deletedalmost 10 years

harodihg says

if you put what you say in quotes and say 'it would be against the rules for me to say' before it then you're not breaking any rules

example:

it would be against the rules for me to say "hey lilin, it is me the real harodihg and I can prove this by sending you a text right now"


thats cheating.
Devante
almost 10 years

lilinonlyknows says

that's OGI


cheating, actually
Giga13
almost 10 years

Fam says


apeescaper says

https://epicmafia.com/setup/626748 is this setup allowed to be comped, its nearly perfectly balanced and fun


I dont think two guns is allowed in comp :/


a setup this round had 2 guns
Giga13
almost 10 years

Fidelis says

meta=/= meta abuse

Meta is unavoidable.

Arbre
almost 10 years
Oh alright, thanks.
deletedalmost 10 years
that's OGI
deletedalmost 10 years
if you put what you say in quotes and say 'it would be against the rules for me to say' before it then you're not breaking any rules

example:

it would be against the rules for me to say "hey lilin, it is me the real harodihg and I can prove this by sending you a text right now"
deletedalmost 10 years

Arbre says

"meta abuse is "i NEVER kill this person as mafia, and i ALWAYS start days with this line as town, so i cannot be mafia""

So we can now report people who try to meta clear themselves?


sorry, i should've been clearer. that's meta abuse if done over the span of multiple games or within the entirety of a round. it's being debated if that should be limited to that or extended to a game per vio.

as of now the former is the current rule.
deletedalmost 10 years
sorry
deletedalmost 10 years

voluntaryloser says

hi lilin


hi, I miss your green tails avatar
Hunt
almost 10 years
It is not meta abuse to say " I always sac bomb because it is optimal, so I'm town." Just putting it out there for noobs
deletedalmost 10 years
hi lilin
deletedalmost 10 years
i mean it was always reportable as ogi or cheating, it just has its own spot now
deletedalmost 10 years

harodihg says

hi lilin


hi harod
deletedalmost 10 years

Arbre says

"meta abuse is "i NEVER kill this person as mafia, and i ALWAYS start days with this line as town, so i cannot be mafia""

So we can now report people who try to meta clear themselves?


if it's a meta that's indisputable, and other people at the table know it's indisputable, then probably yes