RD reveal is okay. I know its Comedy with Horror too, and reveal was totally fine. but it's dumb how in every murder mystery they try to pin murders up on obvious accomplice. I mean, Hester killed only 2 or 3 people.
Also, Ryan Murphy said only four or five characters would survive. >whole main cast survives.
this is gonna sound salty, but I feel cheated. :D and most of fans of this show do too
Although I enjoyed 1-12 episodes, Ryan Murphy is a R, F, C, S, W, I...
I am self-deleting
P.S. y but if there is going to be a second season, I am going to watch it. Because Ryan Murphy is a soretime loser making money with dumb idiotic scenarios and cheating show fans, so he can consider my watching second season as a charity. always happy to help that kind of R and soretime loser-liars
deletedalmost 9 years
hahahah anyone else feel really sorry for the chanels?
But Pete had to confess that he was a killer to Grace, after having a tense phone call with whom we can only assume was the remaining living Red Devil?? Therefore Grace can't be the killer - why would Pete have to confess that to Grace in a dramatic manner when it is just the two of them in the room together?
lets be real: chanel #3 is the best chanel aside from the real chanel
i really want to agree that the killer is anyone but grace, but no one else has as much evidence as her. hell she wore a sweater once with the letter 'R' and boone wore one with the letter 'D'
ill check out harpers island
deletedalmost 9 years
i've watched harper's island already.
i also hate shows where the killer isn't a main character throughout the season. tbh the only satisfying reveals for the killer would be chanel, chanel #5 or hester.
chanel #3 doesn't make sense coz she believed boone was a ghost, and boone kept up the act in front of her.
deletedalmost 9 years
at first i thought it was pete because he wanted to stir up a story for his paper and dismantle greek society but after the last ep idk i doubt they would have him say that if he was the killer
If you guys enjoy this kind "who dunnit" show I highly recommend Harper's Island - it's a one season show with serial killer and romance etc. It isn't as light hearted or jokey but I think it might vibe well with a lot of you.
i read an explanation that grace vs gigi confrontations werent about the killer, and upon a rewatch, it was true. they werent even talking about the killer, just about the relationship between gigi and wes or the bathtub babies. the theory where grace is the killer is that grace and gigi were acquainted before the start of the killings, because grace thought she was a bathtub baby. then when chanel told the truth to grace, grace confronts gigi about it, and thats about it.
another thing i caught was when wes accused grace during thanksgiving, the meeting between her and the RD had grace in her clothes before she met pete, so her alibi doesnt add up there, unless she decided to wear the same clothes or something.
imo grace is the most plausible out of the cast but if its melanie im gonna be upset because i hate the twists where its actually this person that appeared once and never showed up again (plus melanie would be too old to be a bathtub baby and the scene with her doesnt make sense when she screamed with the RD showing up)
deletedalmost 9 years
yeah, i started watching it coz i like emma roberts and jamie lee curtis, then i realised it wasn't as much of a logic thingy as i had hoped. but i can't stop watching now coz i've watched 11 episodes so i need to know who the killer is haha
deletedalmost 9 years
Oh damn that's a good one
Also you're taking the show too serious, lighten up a bit fam
deletedalmost 9 years
tbh i reckon that melanie dorkus chick is the killer, the one who got burned by the spray tan thingy... that's just my pick. all other main characters just don't make sense in one way or another
deletedalmost 9 years
this show really annoys me, coz there are certain scenes with every character that just don't make sense for them to be the killer.
for example, grace whenever she talked to gigi, there was obviously tension, and gigi was obviously hiding that she was the killer from grace, therefore it would make no sense for grace to be the killer, and it would also make no sense for pete to have to confess that he is a killer to her. therefore grace can not be the killer.
chanel #5 - driving in the car and getting chased by the red devil, makes no sense for her to be really scared for her life if she was the killer herself??
hester - when she poked her finger through the dead maid's leg, under the impression they were just fake bodies, and being genuinely terrified...
etc etc etc, this show is too silly, i like logic hahaha
