Epicmafia

Back to Off Topic

Unban Arcbell

Renaldo

over 9 years

But only on TheWhiteBunny.

If he breaks character, permaban.

Hibiki

over 9 years

remember, in order for meteor night to happen, town must actively choose to NL 3 times

Jaleb

over 9 years

Hibiki says

Jaleb says

Hibiki says

that is already answered in the post above, mafia and doctor are both being stubborn, but doctor is the only one that is actually doing an action that hurts his win condition

Saving a clear is against win condition? Also i haven't read the game yet so i don't know if it was f6 or f4

saving (and thus preventing a death) on a meteor night is against win condition, yes

It's also game throwing to let clears die for no good reason. The idea of the game is to not let town die from the attack of the mafia.

deletedover 9 years

Hibiki says

Jaleb says

Hibiki says

that is already answered in the post above, mafia and doctor are both being stubborn, but doctor is the only one that is actually doing an action that hurts his win condition

Saving a clear is against win condition? Also i haven't read the game yet so i don't know if it was f6 or f4

saving (and thus preventing a death) on a meteor night is against win condition, yes

Mafia gt'd

Hibiki

over 9 years

Jaleb says

Hibiki says

that is already answered in the post above, mafia and doctor are both being stubborn, but doctor is the only one that is actually doing an action that hurts his win condition

Saving a clear is against win condition? Also i haven't read the game yet so i don't know if it was f6 or f4

saving (and thus preventing a death) on a meteor night is against win condition, yes

Satan

over 9 years

tl;dr jaleb

Jaleb

over 9 years

A friendly reminder https://epicmafia.com/topic/69870

deletedover 9 years

It's mafia's fault, not doc's in that situation. Thus they get the GT for forcing meteor.

Jaleb

over 9 years

Hibiki says

that is already answered in the post above, mafia and doctor are both being stubborn, but doctor is the only one that is actually doing an action that hurts his win condition

Saving a clear is against win condition? Also i haven't read the game yet so i don't know if it was f6 or f4

runwithfire

over 9 years

that gimmick was the worst please no. I regret that immensely

Satan

over 9 years

hi twist, it's still going on, i've been unpacking all day, just taking a break

deletedover 9 years

Hey Satan how was your day

Satan

over 9 years

no one says hi to me...

Hibiki

over 9 years

that is already answered in the post above, mafia and doctor are both being stubborn, but doctor is the only one that is actually doing an action that hurts his win condition

deletedover 9 years

connor if the setup was B2NS and the mafia hit the doc save who was cop day 1, and tow nnl'd to avoid 4way and mafia kept hitting the doc save until meteor night who gamethrew?

Hibiki

over 9 years

well in all honesty, yes, if it's incredibly obvious that the doctor is saving someone even on meteor night, intentionally killing the save is just as bad (but NOT worse) than the doctor's actions.

but it's a terrible precedent to set that the doctor is not at fault themself, and one i want to change

deletedover 9 years

in this situation even if mafia hit the remaining blue outside of Nashi one could have cc'd doc and the other could've cc'd whatever role Markus was,

if they hit the orc who was on solace, one mafia would've been confirmed and the doc would've claimed leading it to 3way with 1 semi-clear (nashi the doc)

and if they hit the doc, of course no clears other tha nthe orc.

soo....... tell me... where's the auto loss

Satan

over 9 years

hey everyone

Hibiki

over 9 years

maybe the doc shouldn't be actively using a power than can only cause their loss

deletedover 9 years

the only time i agree mafia are allowed to trigger meteor is the 1/5 times they're in auto loss with orc and bomb alive in GAI, and if town doc tests tests with an orc/bomb, a blue, and doc ccs

deletedover 9 years

Niceeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee.

Hibiki

over 9 years

maybe i was but i wouldn't now

deletedover 9 years

Wasn't this argued before and weren't you backing the fault lies on scum and not doc

Hibiki

over 9 years

nah, i am semi-joking

in all honesty, logically, the doc should be at fault. that might not be the way it was but that's what i want to discuss with ppl.

but it won't be in this thread

deletedover 9 years

okay, tell me how was it not gamethrowing and how is it not a refund?

Hibiki

over 9 years

the criteria's changing, pal