this is what happens when mafia is taken to its logical conclusion. it's no better than chess
deletedover 9 years
I warned everyone about bell becoming admin. I bloody warned you all!
what does bell have to do with this lol
deletedover 9 years
Connor if it's fp and the cop dies n1, and the mafia nk the town nl's, then the mafia nk the following night, and town continues to nl ect until meteor DAY when town nls with the mafia, should the mafia get the violation? Since we're flipping the blame clearly
that isn't an equivalent. town would know that they're forcing a draw. when mafia puts a kill through on meteor night they should be able to expect that doc won't use their power because if the doc knows em mechanics they know that nothing can come from it but a draw
did you even spec the game? there's no way mafia shouldn't get a violation for this, they were killing someone they knew was NOT the doc and that the doc was likely going to be on, why should the doctor allow his only clear to be killed just to benefit the mafia when the mafia are not in auto loss if they kill outside of the clear?
everyone who intends to finalise a "no one" vote on meteor day sans special cases such as hammer passing are playing against their win condition, yes
if anyone says "well if mafia fight the NL they make themselves obvious!!!", it's irrelevant, because "being obvious" is not a 100% loss, unlike an NL
deletedover 9 years
Connor if it's fp and the cop dies n1, and the mafia nk the town nl's, then the mafia nk the following night, and town continues to nl ect until meteor DAY when town nls with the mafia, should the mafia get the violation? Since we're flipping the blame clearly
that isn't an equivalent. town would know that they're forcing a draw. when mafia puts a kill through on meteor night they should be able to expect that doc won't use their power because if the doc knows em mechanics they know that nothing can come from it but a draw
if the town decides on meteor day to NL, should mafia go along and NL along with them? in that case, who deserve the GT vio? what if mafia instigates the NL idea? i think that's what he's trying to say
i read your post and couldn't determine the point you were making
deletedover 9 years
Connor if it's fp and the cop dies n1, and the mafia nk the town nl's, then the mafia nk the following night, and town continues to nl ect until meteor DAY when town nls with the mafia, should the mafia get the violation? Since we're flipping the blame clearly
deletedover 9 years
meteorists don't do the kindness of refunding hearts
how the rule is applied now focuses on pandering to the love of townsidedness that you get on em.
untrue.
deletedover 9 years
ive become a warm beverage snob. im looking forward to going to every cafe in seattle and finding the best dark roast.
make sure you get to bauhaus and volunteer park cafe. also near volunteer park is lake view cemetery where i recommend you pay your respects to bruce lee
deletedover 9 years
if meteor logic was applied in black and white terms (ignoring current site meta) then it's objectively the right answer
how the rule is applied now focuses on pandering to the love of townsidedness that you get on em. i hope you'll be able to change it but i don't think you will