Not sure if any of you solved the second one; the answer is basically you have to ask a bird the same question as the solution to Q1, but instead of asking about "the other bird", you make a hypothetical bird who has the opposite persona of them.
So yeah none of you have solved the god slayer mode riddle. Asking whether each bird would go to heaven or hell is disallowed because it is both a hypothetical construct but also it assumes birds go to heaven or hell.
Take heaven/hell out of the question and exchange them for place you want to go to/place you don't want to go to.
deletedover 10 years
Yu-gi-oh is literally Japanese for "bad at math"
deletedover 10 years
Took me literally 1 minute because I've seen this on yu-gi-oh as a kid.
It's equivalent to the question (Q1) "Is yes the answer that you have to give to the question (Q2) of whether this is the door to heaven?"
When asked about the door to heaven, the liar has to answer no to Q2, but he can't flip his answer to yes prior to answering Q1 because Q2 is never actually asked. Q1 triggers the flip.
They're not assumptions, since Heaven and Hell are fact within the riddle, and fully legal within the parameters of the riddle.
Your question invokes a hypothetical and an "if" without using the word if, which is against the rules of god slayer. Your question is "Would you say yes if I asked you this question?" Read: Hypothetically, if I asked you a question, would your response be yes.
"Would you say yes in response to the question of whether this door leads to heaven?"
Honest bird at door to heaven: Yes. Honest bird at door to hell: No. Dishonest bird at door to heaven: Yes. Dishonest bird at door to hell: No.
Riddler's solution doesn't work because the point of the riddle isn't to invoke assumptions like "Lying is a sin" and "Sinners go to hell."
deletedover 10 years
An electric train is traveling north at 50 mph and the wind is blowing south at 50 mph. which way does the smoke blow if the train has smoke coming out of it for some reason
deletedover 10 years
or adult clubs where they do sex acts
deletedover 10 years
heaven and hell could be the names of bookstores or something
The birds are standing outside of heaven and hell. Their atheism is pretty irrelevant, since it's a given fact that heaven and hell exist in this situation.