mite b cool

Played in the first game.
Mimic can be used to clear everything up.

This is actually pretty sweet, just need to get the mechanics down.

With three PRs and one weak PR (drunk), this is pretty townsided. Drunk can stop Jan's and Ninja's while Mimic can confirm cc's or take the real tracker's role before he dies. And Bomb is Bomb.

It should be noted that Ninja can kill bomb without dying, so bomb can easily be the N1 janned kill. People seem to be forgetting this.

>drunk >weak lol theworst you seriously dont realise how powerful the drunk is

Drunk can possibly drunk tracker or mimic, so it's weak. It could drunk the Janitor, but that's purely N1 choice luck. It could drunk Ninja as well, but that means tracker still can't find the Ninja and I guess it could die by bomb, never tried. I should test that.

And the Ninja cannot be tracked or bombed, so between that and the fact that only one maf can be tracked as long as ninja is alive, it suddenly becomes slightly maf sided.

I really don't see the advantage of drunk drunking blindly N1. He's at his best when there's only one or two mafia.

I drunk blindly n1. If tracker claims to have been drunked, then that's a good sign. And it can stop the jan, which only happens n1. Also, if mimic is stupid and tries to choose, it deserves to be drunked.

Wow, can town stop sucking? This should not be so Maf sided.

Take out the ninja and replace with a nilla/other maf PR; maybe town can start winning. The possibility of Bomb being janned, only one possible guilty etc etc makes it quite difficult for town to win.

Or add whispers

If you add whispers, you might need to change guiser, though. Those two tend not to mix well.

Bomb is useless because of ninja
Tracker is near useless because of ninja + one maf Nks.
Drunk is only somewhat usefull day 1 if he drunks the jan.
mimic can mimic those useless roles.

and because of the jan, none of them are truly clear if they claim. this explains the shitty % even thought there is 4 PRs and an ML.

There's also the fact that people are still getting used to mimic. But yeah, ninja makes bomb worthless, remove one or the other, replace with something else.

let it stay the way it is for now. bomb is as useful as ever once ninja is lynched, and it is still a clear for town to make use of. i think the % will change once people learn how to play w/ mimic/ninja

scumsided as fuck
ninja makes tracker and bomb worthless
tracker can only get one guilty
jan makes it worse

Replaced Bomb with Doc, then it might be cool.

This is crap. Ninja ruins this setup.

Bomb with doc? I disagree. Watcher, maybe, but not doc.

I said replace bomb with doc. It doesn't mean they're together. :P

Wow, suddenly it is turning balanced.

that's because it's a great setup

I know, I think it's a bad replacement when there's mimic too.