- The Choirmaster is a third party.
- Every night, the Choirmaster chooses a member of the game to join them in the choir.
- That person permanently (and silently; he can still pick) loses their night action, choosing to go caroling instead of doing their job.
- If the Choirmaster is killed, everyone who was caroling goes back to their original role.
- Wins when everyone in the game is caroling.