Since this is a appeal and you can only appeal once, I'll make sure to go over every detail of the report and how it was handled by poser.

I'm guessing what poser meant from https://imgur.com/a/HYtkf is that I waited to give my report, therefor I'm not annoyed at the game at all. I should note I was annoyed in game, although I'll go over that later, but that shouldn't matter at all since blacksnakemoan did the most cut and dry OGI that I've seen in a while. I'm also going to go out on a guess and say poser did not review my report at all and I suggest she should pay more attention to it. Since this is a game related issue, the only thing that should effect the verdict of the moderators who view this is a few things. Did the person honestly admit to doing what he did on the report. And, if it's not clear if the person did what he was accused of, does he have a history of doing said thing.

Going on how it was actually 100% OGI without a doubt. https://imgur.com/a/hzpUt is where the OGI started. You could say that blacksnakemoan said the wrong thing on accident and I actually thought that when I saw this so I tried making him retract what he said in https://imgur.com/a/nyhLB He, instead of retracting what he said, replied with https://imgur.com/a/oteuq At this point, it was easy OGI, that effected the entire game, and at this point I was planning on reporting him. I wanted to point out his OGI to save any of the newer players who were in the game from possibly getting a GT violation mistakenly because they listened to blacksnake's claims. https://imgur.com/a/LqZMV At this point, blacksnakemoan denied all attempts to OGI and I honestly believed he didn't mean to OGI. Before I contiune, I should note, OGI isn't like gamethrowing. You can OGI by accident and still get a vio because you OGIed. So to make it very clear on how some people could think from blacksnakemoan's claim, I responded with this https://imgur.com/a/o4EQS At this point, I was very annoyed, hints the caps lock, because I had to deal with thinking about OGI and reporting while in a relaxing game of mafia playing my favoriate role. And then at that point, blacksnakemoan attacked me with statements that called me a https://imgur.com/a/dOxGb At this point I was past annoyed and very triggered which is why I said nothing for the past while. I probably would've lurked the entire time being annoyed from what blacksnakemoan has said but then he told sheriff to shoot me and I felt forced to play https://imgur.com/a/2I3l6 You could probably even tell how much I didn't enjoy that game from blacksnakemoan's OGI attempt and attack on me. I was maybe set of easily, although I was drosy at the time, but that doesn't justify ANYTHING blacksnakemoan has done. After I was done with that game, I was so disgusted with it, I decided to leave without reporting. This being the next game hosted by the table https://epicmafia.com/game/6485904/review Outside of being disgusted, I also didn't report because I thought either Tartosis, tanget or justin because they either pointed out that it was OGI or they're tart and I know tart knows it's OGI and hates it. The next day I get on and see https://epicmafia.com/report/244201 Which suggested he didn't get a violation for his OGI so I decided to report him.

As for if blacksnakemoan should get a note because he didn't mean to do it, or to get the violation. I think he should get hit with the real deal since it made me annoyed, blacksnakemoan annoyed, tartosis annoyed, tanget slightly annoyed, I'm guessing justin was annoyed, made it harder for town to scumhunt since it ended up effecting the entire game, and could've effected one of the 2 less expereinced players if they were alive blacksmith during night 2. There shouldn't be any exception for this case. I do believe he wasn't meaning to OGI but this effected way to many things to go unpunished, and would be a learning lesson to not lightly speak about reports in game for blacksnakemoan.

I believe everything I stated why this is OGI and why I didn't immediately report blacksnakemoan even though that fact doesn't matter in the report.