Back to Epicmafia

Remaking Disguiser Setups

almost 7 years

Comp used to have a bunch of setups that regularly rotated through like 'Stalk, Disguise, and Sue', 'Trust Each Other', and 'Politics as Usual'.

They all have disguisers in them, which means that while the script bug is in effect, they can't be comped.

These were good setups, with different mechanics to the ones we have now: towns had to decide to vote together rather than bow to the will of a single clear, there was D1 mylo, and there were multiple role lists in the game.

So what I'm proposing is we remake these setups so that they don't feature a guiser anymore, and can be recomped, while maintaining the same balance of the old versions.

I tried to remake TEO the other week by replacing the guiser with a nilla mafia in all four iterations, and replacing the nilla from the second setup with a ninja. I don't think it worked too well because the guiser, while not often used bc of tests, had the ability to visit and claim to be doc or cop.

With that in mind, I suggest an Enforcer replace Disguiser in PAU and TEO. Enforcer can visit, but only has two effects: to prevent conversion (by cult and mason), and to convert killer to traitor. If a setup has no mason, cult, or killer, the enforcer is a non actioning role which still visits, meaning he can replace the disguiser as an effective fake-PR claim if caught by Watcher or Tracker. In SDS, I've put in a nilla because there is no one to catch the guiser anyway.

Here is altered PAU: https://epicmafia.com/setup/1456286

Here is altered SDS: https://epicmafia.com/setup/1456289

Here is altered TEO: https://epicmafia.com/setup/1456290

If you have any suggestions on other ways to fix or rebalance these, please post them! Otherwise, it'd be great if we could test the setups to see if they're viable

deletedalmost 7 years
https://epicmafia.com/topic/88629


LioneI says

Replace Guiser in DDP with lookout, enforcer, second janitor, strongman, driver (bad idea cuz drunk idk if it will work or not), or paparazzi.


Already thought about driver w/ drunk in my forum. ^
almost 7 years
Replace Guiser in DDP with lookout, enforcer, second janitor, strongman, driver (bad idea cuz drunk idk if it will work or not), or paparazzi.