Back to Forum Games

The Resistance - Game 3

Otherscott
about 7 years

Rules https://goo.gl/JhSwPT

There are 6 good members, and 4 evil members.

Current Game Status

Arthur's knights are victorious...for now. Assassin to pick out Merlin to allow evil to still win.

Past Missions

Mission 1:

Lelmoo, matt, ISamEI (FAILED)

Mission 2:

matt, ISamEI, powerofdeath, LineLiar (REJECTED)

powerofdeath, ISamEI, Spadez0, arisuu (PASSED)

Mission 3:

Tillie, ISamEI, powerofdeath, Spadez0 (REJECTED)

arisuu, ISamEI, powerofdeath, Spadez0 (PASSED)

Mission 4: Tillie, ISamEI, powerofdeath, Spadez0, arisuu (PASSED)

Additional Info

When you want to send a game action (proposing a team or accepting/rejecting a mission), bold your action.

You can bold a comment by doing this: [b]Your Comment[/b]

If you are on the team and the mission is a go, you will send the pass or fail slip by private messaging me.

Rule Changes:

  1. You're allowed to switch your accept/reject if no majority has been reached yet. (As with The Resistance 2)

  2. The Team Leader has the option of rejecting their own mission. 6 accepts are now needed for a mission to proceed.

Finally, you are always free to message me your thoughts on what you think is going on, reads, etc. Doesn't matter if you're a player or a spectator.

ISamEI
about 7 years

Spadez0 says


Lelmoo says

spadez i dont understand your reads rn at all lol I don't get why we shouldn't just go for the same team because it would give it us so much information?


Well, it doesn't really matter if you don't understand... for now I think? It's jest my opinion anyway xD

But if we think about it simply, the same team hasn't been proposed as we all can see.

The team that has been proposed is a team I like so I don't see a reason to reject.

To me, it seems like thou rejected simply because this isn't the same team as the previous one. I don't understand the problem with this team.


the problem with this team is that it doesn't directly clear matt or arisuu, so it leaves room for ambiguity on mission 5

it also makes us royally screwed if for some reason there were TWO mafia on mission three and both passed it
Lelmoo
about 7 years
Sam. No. Do not do that.
Spadez
about 7 years
Accept. *
Spadez
about 7 years
Failed...
Spadez
about 7 years
Also, I [b]Accept[b].
ISamEI
about 7 years
matt if you are willing to stake my trust in you with this mission passing, then I will accept it. lelmoo and arisuu are giving me weird vibes
Spadez
about 7 years

Lelmoo says

spadez i dont understand your reads rn at all lol I don't get why we shouldn't just go for the same team because it would give it us so much information?


Well, it doesn't really matter if you don't understand... for now I think? It's jest my opinion anyway xD

But if we think about it simply, the same team hasn't been proposed as we all can see.

The team that has been proposed is a team I like so I don't see a reason to reject.

To me, it seems like thou rejected simply because this isn't the same team as the previous one. I don't understand the problem with this team.
LineLiar
about 7 years
daily resistance contribution

reject
ISamEI
about 7 years
if arisuu fails

Clear: Spadez, Pod, Matt, Me
Ambiguous: tillie, marry, line
Scum: Arisuu/Highspace/Lelmoo

For mission 5 we would have a 2/3 chance of picking correctly in that case.

in a tillie fail, for mission 5 we would have 1/2 chance of picking correctly (between matt/marry and arisuu/lelmoo)
ISamEI
about 7 years
if arisuu fails....

matt pov
highspace/arisuu/???/??? are scum
I get the logic now
ISamEI
about 7 years
so assuming tillie fails...

matt pov
highspace/tillie/arisuu/lelmoo are scum

arisuu pov
highspace/tillie/matt/marry are scum

The situation would be, for me:
Clear: me, spadez, pod, line
Ambiguous: lelmoo, marry, matt, arisuu
Scum: tillie, highspace
ISamEI
about 7 years
right, I forgot arisuu pinned nadine/marry as morgana
ISamEI
about 7 years
so if we accept the mission and it fails
we would have highspace and tillie as confirmed

then mission 4 automatically passes but mission 5 is ambiguous
ISamEI
about 7 years
so if tillie fails it then we have
lelmoo/arisuu/highspace/tillie as confirmed from matt pov

form arisuu pov we have
highspace/matt/tillie/???
as confirmed?
ISamEI
about 7 years
lelmoo/arisuu/highspace/???

are maf from matt pov
let me think this through
ISamEI
about 7 years
Putting t

Spadez0 says

Pod, although the prev team game gave us all passes, it's optimal to avoid Ari right now. If you don't trust Matt, this team should give you an even bigger reason to accept.

Till is Matt's tr read. If we get a fail, there's a high chance it's from Till (unless we got played real hard by you or Sam). Meaning, it gives us basis to actually suspect Matt's alignment.

This team's results would definitely make a few things clear so it's better to accept. There's a higher chance we will get all passes again with these 4. And if we don't we get a better idea of who's in which team.


I feel like it wouldn't be as straightforward as that, because if tillie were maf then it would still be ambiguous as to whether matt or arisuu were maf. I would swap out arisuu with matt in that case an approve that team.
Lelmoo
about 7 years
spadez i dont understand your reads rn at all lol I don't get why we shouldn't just go for the same team because it would give it us so much information?
Spadez
about 7 years
Pod, although the prev team game gave us all passes, it's optimal to avoid Ari right now. If you don't trust Matt, this team should give you an even bigger reason to accept.

Till is Matt's tr read. If we get a fail, there's a high chance it's from Till (unless we got played real hard by you or Sam). Meaning, it gives us basis to actually suspect Matt's alignment.

This team's results would definitely make a few things clear so it's better to accept. There's a higher chance we will get all passes again with these 4. And if we don't we get a better idea of who's in which team.
Spadez
about 7 years

arisuu says

i only acted really scummy b/c highspace's post was really long, and it made me want to claim merlin


'Want'... That's some interesting wording.
Spadez
about 7 years

arisuu says

you're not confirmed percival?? i'm confirmed percival. and, i'm also the merlin, so i'm twice as towny as you??


...
Spadez
about 7 years

arisuu says

to clarify, i didn't roleswap with everyone in the game. i only attempted a roleswap w/ you and pod, and i hinted at a roleswap w/ sam but he didn't get the hint. and i thought highspace wanted to roleswap, but i was mistaken.


That's 4/10 names I see there. You should try role swapping with yourself too. That's half the players in the game then.
Spadez
about 7 years

matt says

before anything happens sam spadez and pod all owe me apologies because i literally appealed for my life there honestly


I apologise yeah, but I don't know what I'm apologising for. I literally never sr'ed you except for right at the beginning. And that wasn't even a proper sr because I said you OR Lelmoo is the scum from M1.

And I mentioned why I was proposing the same team from M2 to be brought again.

So either you got triggered after seeing Ari's name in the team and ignored everything else I said or, you got t r i g g e r e d.
Spadez
about 7 years

arisuu says

okay, i'm not actually the perc, matt is the real perc



arisuu says

wait no i was just kidding lol i was trying to confuse mafia by claiming that i wasnt perc. i actually am the perc. you're not allowed to take charge



arisuu says

because, i'm actually the merlin, not pod. i was roleswapping w/ him because i knew he was the real perc. after reading highspace's post i felt like it was the most logical thing to do.


If you guys genuinely think this is town... I pray for you.

If this is really town... I pray for Ari.

If Ari's was trying to confuse Mafia, they achieved their purpose with 110% success as they threw the whole town in disorder.

What the effects of the claims show? Ari is unreliable and not trustworthy.
Spadez
about 7 years

HighSpace says

PAGING ASSASSIN

It's time. I'm looking at the development of the game, and I believe that at this point, our only way to win is to kill Merlin. We may get in mission 3, but getting in mission 4 or 5 will be an impossibility.

I've asked Scott if we were allowed to discuss after the town passes 3 missions, but we aren't allowed, so right now is a great time to give my thoughts.

I'm also pretty much obvious scum so I don't mind outing myself. I also don't know which one of you is Mordred (I'm pretty sure I know who, though), but it shouldn't change anything.

I am pretty damn sure that PoD is Merlin. I know his reads weren't perfect but he did it to throw us off. The biggest factor in him being Merlin is that he composed a team that did not contain any of [minion, assassin, morgana]. His wifom post is also a huge Merlin tell. His general behaviour reeks of Merlin, he wasn't even scumhunting. How many questions did he ask exactly? If I remember correctly, it's a number between zero and zero. He already knew the mafias and it's evident in the way he's been posting. Look at his reads in particular. How can you be mostly correct with such atrocious reasons? Don't let his misreads fool you.

I've also been asking a bunch of questions yesterday just to see if it would help me figure out who Merlin is. I'm not sure if it has, but I guess it helped confirm my belief that PoD is merlin?


powerofdeath says

how the f do you guys have scum read already? It just started?

Are you guys just fos trigger happy?


lol

You can uhh come discuss this with me if you want, I guess. LMAO. Like, we're not gonna fail 2 more missions. But I'm confident that PoD is merlin and that you should assassinate him.


Hey. Thanks for revealing. I don't feel as bad for targetting you now :)
Spadez
about 7 years

arisuu says


tillie says

u keep saying that alice but give no reason for it


look at it this way:
- matt is scum fmpov
- matt is constantly defending u + wants you on the team
- therefore: you're guilty by association to matt


Following this logic, since ari's 'confirmed' tr is Lelmoo, Lelmoo is guilty by association to Ari.