I'm just gonna help you out, Lono, since it doesn't look like the thread is going too well. There were 6 mods present who discussed it. I was the only one present who thought it should not receive a vio. Lono hammered the sustain, but he was just the person to close the report. There were a total of 5 mods who agreed with a harassment vio and I was the only one who thought it shouldn't receive a vio.
deletedover 7 years
thats cool, but i have a star
what do you think you look like when the reason you give for sustaining a verdict is "sustained," and then that other people said so? do you think you look like someone who is not a lapdog?
what do you think you look like when the reason you give for sustaining a verdict is "sustained," and then that other people said so? do you think you look like someone who is not a lapdog?
whitepimp ot'd to nv, you need one more mod to sustain it because its 1-1 rn
no you don't. appeals are taken as a best of three sort of thing, and the original verdict is counted in that, that's why it's 2 to OT, but only 1 to sustain, because the original verdict counts towards the sustain
im not randomly saying it, this is what denial told me [16/01/2017 22:45:37] dag: Yup [16/01/2017 22:45:55] denial: if he thinks the vio should be changed, he'll say why and in the report he'll say "OT to blah blah" [16/01/2017 22:46:03] denial: then we wait for the second mod to make the deciding vote [16/01/2017 22:46:11] denial: but if the first mod agrees with the report and thinks "nah thats a vio" [16/01/2017 22:46:16] denial: then just close the report and put "sustained" [16/01/2017 22:46:29] denial: appeals are a decision from 3 mods pretty much [16/01/2017 22:46:38] denial: but if the second mod agrees, then its 2-1 anyways and the third doesnt matter [16/01/2017 22:46:40] denial: so u can close it right then
he's mistaken, the original verdict is taken into account in the best of three
whitepimp ot'd to nv, you need one more mod to sustain it because its 1-1 rn
no you don't. appeals are taken as a best of three sort of thing, and the original verdict is counted in that, that's why it's 2 to OT, but only 1 to sustain, because the original verdict counts towards the sustain
im not randomly saying it, this is what denial told me [16/01/2017 22:45:37] dag: Yup [16/01/2017 22:45:55] denial: if he thinks the vio should be changed, he'll say why and in the report he'll say "OT to blah blah" [16/01/2017 22:46:03] denial: then we wait for the second mod to make the deciding vote [16/01/2017 22:46:11] denial: but if the first mod agrees with the report and thinks "nah thats a vio" [16/01/2017 22:46:16] denial: then just close the report and put "sustained" [16/01/2017 22:46:29] denial: appeals are a decision from 3 mods pretty much [16/01/2017 22:46:38] denial: but if the second mod agrees, then its 2-1 anyways and the third doesnt matter [16/01/2017 22:46:40] denial: so u can close it right then