Symphony

Podrickover 9 years ago

is ineligible to trophy.

https://epicmafia.com/topic/80302

The rule: Do not moderate competitive reports or rule on refunds if you are over 1k points

EdarkOct 12, 2016!+11 The rule has been changed a long time ago to that you cant do comp reports after you've passed 1000 points due to the fact that you might not know untill then if you actually have shot for a trophy. I cant really find this rule written down somehwere tho but I could fix that.

https://epicmafia.com/post/2728530/goto_page

https://epicmafia.com/post/2728548/goto_page


Considering Edark is still the admin and one of his mods broke this trophy running rule:

Charley doing comp reports after passing 1K round score on 2 accounts (Symphony + charley):

https://epicmafia.com/report/210474 https://epicmafia.com/report/210473 https://epicmafia.com/report/210472 https://epicmafia.com/report/210471 https://epicmafia.com/report/210470 https://epicmafia.com/report/210466 https://epicmafia.com/report/210454 https://epicmafia.com/report/210445 https://epicmafia.com/report/210400 https://epicmafia.com/report/210399 https://epicmafia.com/report/210337 https://epicmafia.com/report/210334 https://epicmafia.com/report/210333 https://epicmafia.com/report/210331 (there are probably more)

Prediction: Edark will ignore his own rule that he wrote up and allow his mod friend to trophy.

mandevianover 9 years ago
charley
Yes do you think i shouldn't?
I thought you were unlike others and actually respected the rules.
deleteddeletedover 9 years ago
Yes do you think i shouldn't?
mandevianover 9 years ago
charley
mandevian
charley
Whitepimp007
Pranay, TL;DR.
same
Look at the mod's response. Fit to argue about this, but new when the rule is to be applied.
my actual response was what nathan said i dont think i needed to say much more, i made a mistake.
charley
mandevian
charley
Whitepimp007
Pranay, TL;DR.
same
Look at the mod's response. Fit to argue about this, but new when the rule is to be applied.
my actual response was what nathan said i dont think i needed to say much more, i made a mistake.
So do you think you should be allowed to get the trophy?
deleteddeletedover 9 years ago
Whitepimp007
Sorry, you quoted Pranay and I had to modneg that.
i understand
Whitepimp007over 9 years ago
Sorry, you quoted Pranay and I had to modneg that.
13
deleteddeletedover 9 years ago
mandevian
charley
Whitepimp007
Pranay, TL;DR.
same
Look at the mod's response. Fit to argue about this, but new when the rule is to be applied.
my actual response was what nathan said i dont think i needed to say much more, i made a mistake.
deleteddeletedover 9 years ago
praynay = cheater
1
mandevianover 9 years ago
charley
Whitepimp007
Pranay, TL;DR.
same
Look at the mod's response. Fit to argue about this, but new when the rule is to be applied.
mandevianover 9 years ago
Yeah, because rules mean nothing to you guys. You only worry about whether your friend gets their candy.

Nathan doesnt deserve to be admin.

At first people were not allowed to run if they modded gold heart games.

Then when gerry broke the rule, they changed the rule to the 1k points thing

Now when symphony broke the rule, they are saying she is new and thus should be allowed. Another change in the rule. This also implies that the mod team doesnt share the rules with mods. This rule is literally there in the mod forums.

We can all see how every rule is twisted to suit the mods.
deleteddeletedover 9 years ago
LOL!
Whitepimp007over 9 years ago
I quoted you so I could modneg that again.
14
Whitepimp007over 9 years ago
mandevian
Nathan
But yeah. Being new, charley forgot about this rule and once she realised she immediately let us know. I did skim over the reports she did do and I didn't see any bias in them so I let them be whilst warning her not to do a similar thing in the future. Plus, whatever Sonse said above. : )
That doesn't negate the fact that she is ineligible. Just remove the rule altogether or make another change that they are allowed if there is no bias.

Why is the rule even there? If you say there was no bias, and will thus allow it, it implies that you assume that mods have bias most of the time while doing reports?

Also she is not new. Also why didn't any mod tell her the rules before modding her?

Charley will take this in a negative way.
deleteddeletedover 9 years ago
Whitepimp007
Pranay, TL;DR.
same
Whitepimp007over 9 years ago
Pranay, TL;DR.
12
mandevianover 9 years ago
Nathan
But yeah. Being new, charley forgot about this rule and once she realised she immediately let us know. I did skim over the reports she did do and I didn't see any bias in them so I let them be whilst warning her not to do a similar thing in the future. Plus, whatever Sonse said above. : )
That doesn't negate the fact that she is ineligible. Just remove the rule altogether or make another change that they are allowed if there is no bias.

Why is the rule even there? If you say there was no bias, and will thus allow it, it implies that you assume that mods have bias most of the time while doing reports?

Also she is not new. Also why didn't any mod tell her the rules before modding her?

Charley will take this in a negative way.
BSelserover 9 years ago
The wrath of Recidivism
deleteddeletedover 9 years ago
Nathan, I'd like a respectable answer to my question in the mentor/mentee thread
deleteddeletedover 9 years ago
SYMPHONY YOUR FIRST COMPLAINT THREAD!
10
Arcbellover 9 years ago
Podrick abc ban ban abc ban Podrick abc ban
10
deleteddeletedover 9 years agoedited
Podrick
Don't shoot the messenger.
You bring the crowns and heads of conquered kings to my city steps. You insult my queen. You threaten my people with slavery and death! Oh, I've chosen my words carefully, Podrick. Perhaps you should have done the same.
Arcbellover 9 years ago
Podrick abc
Podrickover 9 years ago
Don't shoot the messenger.
10
deleteddeletedover 9 years ago
harodihg
jinkies!
u rang
1
deleteddeletedover 9 years ago
Basically what nathan said ^
Nathanover 9 years ago
But yeah. Being new, charley forgot about this rule and once she realised she immediately let us know. I did skim over the reports she did do and I didn't see any bias in them so I let them be whilst warning her not to do a similar thing in the future. Plus, whatever Sonse said above. : )
13