Back to Complaints

Symphony

Podrick
over 7 years

is ineligible to trophy.

https://epicmafia.com/topic/80302

The rule: Do not moderate competitive reports or rule on refunds if you are over 1k points

EdarkOct 12, 2016!+11 The rule has been changed a long time ago to that you cant do comp reports after you've passed 1000 points due to the fact that you might not know untill then if you actually have shot for a trophy. I cant really find this rule written down somehwere tho but I could fix that.

https://epicmafia.com/post/2728530/goto_page

https://epicmafia.com/post/2728548/goto_page

Considering Edark is still the admin and one of his mods broke this trophy running rule:

Charley doing comp reports after passing 1K round score on 2 accounts (Symphony + charley):

https://epicmafia.com/report/210474 https://epicmafia.com/report/210473 https://epicmafia.com/report/210472 https://epicmafia.com/report/210471 https://epicmafia.com/report/210470 https://epicmafia.com/report/210466 https://epicmafia.com/report/210454 https://epicmafia.com/report/210445 https://epicmafia.com/report/210400 https://epicmafia.com/report/210399 https://epicmafia.com/report/210337 https://epicmafia.com/report/210334 https://epicmafia.com/report/210333 https://epicmafia.com/report/210331 (there are probably more)

Prediction: Edark will ignore his own rule that he wrote up and allow his mod friend to trophy.

Edark
over 7 years

mandevian says

EdarkOct 12, 2016!+11 The rule has been changed a long time ago to that you cant do comp reports after you've passed 1000 points due to the fact that you might not know untill then if you actually have shot for a trophy. I cant really find this rule written down somehwere tho but I could fix that.


You clearly stated it is a rule.


Technically yeah. But as the picture states, its more of what you call guidelines considering how we enforce them.

If we wanna get even more technical I can also state that we dont have any listed "punishment" for said "rule", thus its kinda up for the admin to decide whats the most appropiate. Nathan checked through the reports and saw no bias, thus it was decided to let it slide.

TL:DR dont act like a manchild and cry about petty things
Becomeclear
over 7 years
dealing with pranay must be the biggest drawback of being an admin
mandevian
over 7 years
EdarkOct 12, 2016!+11 The rule has been changed a long time ago to that you cant do comp reports after you've passed 1000 points due to the fact that you might not know untill then if you actually have shot for a trophy. I cant really find this rule written down somehwere tho but I could fix that.


You clearly stated it is a rule.
mandevian
over 7 years
No it isnt. It is a rule. You are now changing it to guideline to suit your need.
Edark
over 7 years

mandevian says


Nathan says

But yeah. Being new, charley forgot about this rule and once she realised she immediately let us know. I did skim over the reports she did do and I didn't see any bias in them so I let them be whilst warning her not to do a similar thing in the future. Plus, whatever Sonse said above. : )


That doesn't negate the fact that she is ineligible. Just remove the rule altogether or make another change that they are allowed if there is no bias.

Why is the rule even there? If you say there was no bias, and will thus allow it, it implies that you assume that mods have bias most of the time while doing reports?

Also she is not new. Also why didn't any mod tell her the rules before modding her?

Charley will take this in a negative way.


Dag
over 7 years

mandevian says

Mt01 would ask for proof even on skype. He asks reason to vote confirmed mafia.


lmao
mandevian
over 7 years
@ charley, Whitepimp007, nathan- the bad thing about abusing powers is that the power never lasts if you abuse it.

This is the kind of thing that I wouldn't allow if I were a mod. That is why the mod team is afraid to have me.
mandevian
over 7 years
Mt01 would ask for proof even on skype. He asks reason to vote confirmed mafia.
deletedover 7 years

vilden says

Doesn't really take a high IQ to have the following conversation with someone on skype:

"hey im blue
"wow me too lol"
"ok"


i don't think you know her iq :^)
vilden
over 7 years
Doesn't really take a high IQ to have the following conversation with someone on skype:

"hey im blue
"wow me too lol"
"ok"
Cody
over 7 years
she couldn't figure out how to cheat even if she tried
vilden
over 7 years
MikeyRu could never trophy without cheating and I can guarantee you mt01 is 100% legit
mandevian
over 7 years

Venus says


vilden says

mt01 deserves a trophy. She's been actively trying to get better (by being mentored) and actually plays legitimately


well they couldn't get worse


Firstly, this is hilarious. I don't know if I will ever stop laughing.

Secondly, you should see mikeyru. He got worse. Not worse than mt01. Mt01 has hit bottom.
deletedover 7 years

vilden says

mt01 deserves a trophy. She's been actively trying to get better (by being mentored) and actually plays legitimately


well they couldn't get worse
deletedover 7 years
Let's just hope someone misclicks on the reset round button before that happens
vilden
over 7 years
mt01 deserves a trophy. She's been actively trying to get better (by being mentored) and actually plays legitimately
Cody
over 7 years
just the thought of mt01 trophying makes me shudder
mandevian
over 7 years
The sad part about pod getting banned is that mt01 and parkover will trophy. Just read their games.
deletedover 7 years
It's the same thing when brown wasn't allowed to trophy two rounds in a row. You can't bend the rules for one person.
JeffreyAaron
over 7 years
And Podrick wonders how everyone knew he was a banned user.
mandevian
over 7 years

charley says


mandevian says


charley says

Yes do you think i shouldn't?


I thought you were unlike others and actually respected the rules.


I respect the rules I just forgot about this one. Do you really think i dont deserve the trophy?


So if a new player comes and cheats for a trophy or breaks rules to win a trophy and later says that they didn't know the rule, will you allow it?

What you did is a breach of rules. Entire mod team was there to warn you.

I told you in the game. I wanted you to win the trophy even though you didn't deserve it. But now you don't deserve it at all.

How can you be a mod without knowing such important rules.

You should be ashamed of yourself.
deletedover 7 years

charley says


mandevian says


charley says

Yes do you think i shouldn't?


I thought you were unlike others and actually respected the rules.


I respect the rules I just forgot about this one. Do you really think i dont deserve the trophy?


whoops I forgot I couldn't cheat. Can I pls still have trophy
Cody
over 7 years
yo pranay it's just an epicmafia.com trophy why you got your panties in such a bunch over it
deletedover 7 years

mandevian says


charley says

Yes do you think i shouldn't?


I thought you were unlike others and actually respected the rules.


I respect the rules I just forgot about this one. Do you really think i dont deserve the trophy?
deletedover 7 years
YOU MADE A MISTAKE, YOU MUST BE PUNISHED!!! -praynay