why would we ever speculate what mafia roles are? you're pretty much asking everyone what they think mafs roles are based on their own power role abilities.... something akin to almost fishing.
also, i actually do not think gerrys overall attitude and way he is playing is really screaming "not maf".
i'd say maybe there is one thing about him that leans more town, and the rest of it would actually kinda lean more scummy
so explain what about his attitude/way hes playing you don't think a mafia would do
Hello, How is this going? This is only my second game of Forum mafia, but i promise to be as annoying as if it was a real one.
deletedabout 8 years
Give Jeff a -1 also now that I think on it.
deletedabout 8 years
Not really much to comment on atm since the game is just getting started (duh) I'm gonna brush off Jeff's vote on me atm and wait for others to post but here:
Well im gonna defend my fake post. I don't think there is anything wrong with talking about mafia roles like does that really hurt town in your opinion or something? Like since there are 10 town prs im genuinely curious how you can balance that out. Maybe other peoples prs aren't as good as mine. Anyways with that being said i slightly townread gerry and xxnicolexx. I like what jeff just said and everyone else is null. Out of the townreads that i said people are probably wondering why i townread gerry and i just think his attitude and the way he is playing is not the way i imagine someone who rolled mafia would want to play the game. It could still change but thats where im at so far.
I think I already understand this game from a quick read, Gerry, Transcend, and Ripple all know what they are doing...
and no one else does...
So anyone mind telling me as to how they reached their reads besides the occasional *well that reaction was bad*, they're scum because I'm scum. Blah blah blah? Or do we just kinda wade through and RL, this seems a lot more mechanics based on night actions from what I can tell than whatever the heck you guys are doing.
