Epicmafia

Positive, Neutral, Critical

over 8 years

Post in this thread with a positive, neutral, or critical observation of me and I'll post the opposite for you. Please state the category of your observation. If your observation is neutral, I'll reply with a neutral one as well.

I'll be writing all three for each person, so if you want more, you can give me more and receive more in return (this means that you can get up to 3 responses from me in this thread).

Example: A says "Positive. Cody is smart and observant." I will reply with something like "Critical. A is too easily influenced by other people."

I'll be gathering all of the observations that I write into a file somewhere and maybe making a wrap-up post to summarize them.

EDIT: Here is the file that I've made with all of my responses for everyone in the thread. If you're seeing this, then I'm only doing responses for those people that I feel like responding to from now on. There are a few people on the file that didn't post here for whom I wrote these observations down prior to posting the thread, so if you didn't post here and you're someone who knows me pretty well, you might be in there!

Are you...

Positive?

Neutral?

Critical?

Lumos

over 8 years

Positive :smart dude, super good at mafia, one of the more eloquent typers on this site, good friend

Neutral: coder

Negative: don't be fake lol

Cody

over 8 years

cinnanie says

Positive: Cody is meticulous and neat. He does his best in everything he does. He is a precious darling, and is loyal to his friends. Has a 200+ WPM. Codybae for life!!!

Critical: He succs and always rigs his games against me so I'd get voted out before I come back on computer.

Neutral: He has dentist appointments.

Critical: You allow yourself to get manipulated by others too much.

Positive: You are a tremendously positive force to be around. Your cheer and good humor is a contagious one and I'm glad to have been able to experience it.

Neutral: You are very introspective.

Becomeclear

over 8 years

https://epicmafia.com/game/5320856

Cody

over 8 years

thecolonel says

Critical: you started the chain of people thinking I'm Ian

If you aren't Ian, then I don't know you and I can't say anything about you.

If you are Ian:

Positive: You are probably one of the only people on the site whose (serious) opinion I could consider as an unbiased one. Serious in parentheses refers to when we used to have private conversations about site issues.

deletedover 8 years

Retti says

Cody - Neutral: You seem to carry yourself well

ill do positive/negative too

Positive: You seem you have everyone's best interests

Negative: You can become overbearing because of said interest

Cody

over 8 years

Sonrio says

Positive: One of the most level headed people I've seen on EM. You stand by your beliefs instead of letting others step all over you. Also cool at mafia.

Negative: I believe you should be less critical of yourself. Hitting yourself over your mistakes won't solve them, instead I think you should move on and just acknowledge it instead of being so uptight. I don't know if what I just said makes sense but I hope I got my point across.

That's not even negative lmao

Positive: You're very concerned with the well-being of your friends. When you sent Lilin some mean messages and were defended for it because it was Lilin, and then attacked for it again by her complaint thread, you asked us to let it go and owned up to your words and took the punishment.

You're also a pretty good writer, it's a shame that we never got to submit the story that you wrote for the Pokemon Survivor competition.

Neutral: You're oddly similar to Elise.

Critical: Occasionally, you're overly impulsive and careless and end up making a mess of things for others to clean up.

roadman

over 8 years

JeffreyAaron says

Critical: You trust your ability to judge people/situations properly way too much and ignore other's opinions even when they are far more versed or knowledgeable of said person/situation. This leads to lots of problems for you down the line when you realize you could have avoided them by just listening to others and setting aside your belief in your superior judgment.

*lmao*

Becomeclear

over 8 years

https://epicmafia.com/game/5320832

JeffreyAaron

over 8 years

Critical: You trust your ability to judge people/situations properly way too much and ignore other's opinions even when they are far more versed or knowledgeable of said person/situation. This leads to lots of problems for you down the line when you realize you could have avoided them by just listening to others and setting aside your belief in your superior judgment.

Lux

over 8 years

Critical: Cold and calculating. You know that any action is of no consequence, so your moves are planned and maximized to what would suit you best. You criticize urself a lot when you make decisions based on ur emotions but life isn't a cube, u can slow down and it's not always played logically. You're allowed to make mistakes. Also add me back on Skype.

deletedover 8 years

Neutral: You trust people have good intentions.

deletedover 8 years

Cody - Neutral: You seem to carry yourself well

Shamu

over 8 years

Positive: You are a really great em player, and was a very good admin as well. I think you took peoples best interests at heart when you did things. You're also really really good in vivor.

Critical: Back in my noobier days I found you kind of... intimidating, you always try your best at what you do, and because of that perhaps you can scare people off?

deletedover 8 years

huh cool

Satan

over 8 years

Positive:

you seem to have people's best interests in mind.

Neutral:

you seem to take this website way too seriously.

Critical:

you seem to be extremely naive.

Cody

over 8 years

Shrub says

Positive - you are a good person and good at this game of Mafia and good at moderating this game of Mafia. I think you are very good at responding to criticism. Also polite and verbose.

Neutral - you seem to have little emotion when you play Mafia.

Critical - you have expectations of yourself that you probably shouldn't, and you seem to think you are worse at things than you are. I think you could be too trusting and see the best in people a little too much.

Positive: You are a good older-brother figure in the little family that we were a part of. Keep it up.

Neutral: You still seem bitter about being disqualified from a trophy that one round 2-3 months ago and make a point of it whenever meta-abuse cases pop up.

Critical: You have a hard time understanding the words and thoughts of others occasionally. You try "novel" strategies in mafia games that end up getting you lynched while you tell the people lynching you that they're dumb, even though in reality you just did something that makes more sense from the point of view of mafia.

Edark

over 8 years

That is very fair criticism. If you got any more Im all ears.

Becomeclear

over 8 years

https://epicmafia.com/game/5320801

Cody

over 8 years

Edark says

Positive: Extremely professional and take criticism at heart. Got very eloquent ways of expressing yourself that makes me drop my panties(if I had any). Very polite and just a general nice person aswell.

Negative: Maybe a bit too nice to his friends, which in all honesty is a good trait if you look in the grand scheme of things.

Critical: Sometimes emotional and sometimes can come across as a bit manipulative.

I'll do one of each - it was supposed to be positive, neutral, and critical.

Positive: You work very hard to try to get people to see things your way, indicating that you stand firmly by your beliefs. I remember reading multiple long walls of text and even a few pastebins that you put together to try to convince me/the team that you were in the right. You never let arguments over ideas get personal - even if you were personally attacked for a belief you held, you took it well and did not retaliate in a personal way; rather, you tried even harder to find more reasonable points to defend your stance and convince those who doubted you.

Neutral: You didn't do what you wanted to do, even with my support, because of the way you felt that it would make you look.

Critical: Personal biases aside, I think you have a bit of a hard time making the people around you feel important to you. The scope that I'm talking about is probably only as large as the mod team, since outside of that I don't have too many strong connections on the site. The point that I'm getting at is that I think that if I were to ask a smattering of the mods on the team the following question, the responses wouldn't be enthusiastic affirmations: "Do you feel like you're important to Edark?"

roadman

over 8 years

Critical: Your own interests will always be more important to you than those of others. You are cunning when giving the impression you are acting earnestly.

deletedover 8 years

Positive: very nice person to talk to and give/receive advice and all that. great friend to anyone close to you and very smart and level headed.

Neutral: you are a good mafia player

Critical: sometimes you are hesitant at putting your foot down and standing up for yourself before it's too late and act abruptly in situations where you get mad. also you try to please everyone when you know it wont always work

deletedover 8 years

Critical: You blindly put your faith and trust in certain people whilst disregarding basically anyone's advice/suggestion pertaining to them. Not sure if this means if you're a stubborn human being or if you think you're intellectually superior to anyone talking to you.

deletedover 8 years

Positive: You're very loyal and will do anything for a friend. You have no qualms about apologizing if you believe you're in the wrong. You're always willing to help anyway you can.
Neutral: ur sleep schedule is wild
Critical: You have a tendency to act in the heat of things, mostly mafia, and end up saying things you regret later on.

Cody

over 8 years

jack says

Critical: you lend your trust out too often, and it has come back to bite you. you also let your emotions get the best of you from time to time, and can overreact to minor things as a result

Positive: You're good at seeing the big picture and understanding what people want. You have a cool, collected demeanor and know how to tackle conflict when it comes up - one particular instance you showed how to solve a problem by simply avoiding it for a while and then tackling it head on at a more opportune time.

Sonrio

over 8 years

I posted early enough for mine to be done but idk abt yall after me lol